There’s so many cases of powerful villains in fiction being like “if you surrender/serve me I’ll bring XYZ fundamentally vital character back” but it’s a gripe of mine that even characters who have the power to do it, only let this be a hypothetical.
Like Batman has had a laundry list of villains be like “if you stop trying to catch me I’ll bring back your parents”, Spiderman’s had a dozen “I’ll bring back Uncle Ben”s, and like a solid fraction of all fantasy fiction hinging on Necromancer antagonists pull this trump card.
But what if they actually did it…..
The hero shows up to stop the big bad, and is greeted by their lost loved one. John Paladin kicks down the palace doors only to be greeted by their actual dearly departed wife and kids or something to that affect, and the villain give the simple offer akin to Orpheus
If you leave here, you can take them with you.
But in this case, there’s no catch, no Eurydice trust. Just a premise, they’re already here, already back in the flesh, and if you try to stop me, I’ll kill them all over again.
Bargaining with hope is one thing for a villain, redoubling loss though, that’s a sledgehammer.
So far, in all the media I have observed, the only thing I’ve found do it in a satisfying way, was the Punisher of all people.
He becomes the face of the evil ninja cult, The Hand, because they have his resurrected wife as collateral. He goes on a warpath because he already has her back, and now every act he takes is motivated by his trauma to never lose her again. It pushed him to limits and depths that left him a shell of himself.
I want more of that!!!
















