I have a hunch that everyone who enters my archive is a little bit queer, so, in order to have people and cookies find others like them, here's a list of all the queer cookies. This is cookies who are in queer relationships in the game, are genderqueer, have showed up in Pride Art, or have had voice actors headcanon/confirm them as queer.
Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Cookies
A
Aloe Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Apple Cookie - Has appeared in pride art
B
Banana Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Blackberry Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts
Black Forest Cookie - Wants to marry a witch, beings who were shown to mostly be fem, and also refers to the witch as "They" instead of he or she.
Black Garlic Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts
Black Lemonade Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts before
Black Sapphire Cookie - Has nothing in game that would imply his sexuality but Barret Leddy retweeted the pride post where he edited Black Sapphire to be there, so take that as you will 🤷♀️
Blue Lily Cookie - Implied to be a lesbian and has a crush on Lilybell Cookie (could be in a relationship with her maybe???)
Butter Pretzel Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
C
Carrot Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Captain Ice Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts
Cauliflower Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts before
Cheesecake Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Cherry Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Chili Pepper Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts before
Cinnamon Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Clover Cookie - Has appeared in Pride art before
Cotton Candy Cookie - All of her crushes are either women or nonbinary
Crunchy Chip Cookie - Has appeared in Pride posts before. Also, his voice actor ships gim with Wildberry (watch the Amongus Streams)
D
DJ Cookie - Bisexual (literally wears the bisexual flag as their shirt)
Dreamweaver Cookie - Nonbinary
E
Espresso Cookie - Bisexual and has appeared in Pride Posts before
Eternal Sugar Cookie - She is HORRENDOUSLY ill for Hollyberry and constantly calls her things like "My love", "Dearest", and, "My other half."
F
Fairy Cookie- Has appeared in Pride Posts before
Fire Spirit Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts before
G
GingerBrave - Has appeared in pride posts before
H
Habenero Cookie - Has appeared in pride art
Herb Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts before
Hollyberry Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts before and also has that whole thing with Eternal Sugar Cookie
Hydrangea Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts before
I
J
K
L
Lilybell Cookie - Implied to be a lesbian and has a crush/maybe relationship on/with Blue Lily Cookie
Lime Cookie - Pansexual and has a crush in Orange Cookie
M
Madeleine Cookie - Bisexual and has appeared in Pride Posts before
Mala Sauce Cookie - Has appeared in pride art
Mango Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Milk Cookie - Most likely gay and has a MASSIVE crush on Dark Choco Cookie
Moonlight Cookie - Has a crush on Sea Fairy Cookie
Mustard Cookie - Has appeared in Pride art
N
O
Orange Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
P
Pancake Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Pomegranate Cookie - Lesbian and has a crush on Dark Enchantress Cookie
Popping Candy Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts
Pumpkin Pie Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts before
Pure Vanilla Cookie - Had that whole thing with Shadow Milk, so he's probably bi or pan
Q
R
Raspberry Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts before and tried to marry Princess Cookie in Knight Cookie's dream. Also, while it doesn't really count as proof, Pavlova did try and matchmake her with Tiger Lily Cookie
Roguefort Cookie - Is shown to be flirty with every cookie no matter the gender and is attracted to Cotton Candy Cookie
Rose Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
Rye Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts before
S
Sea Fairy Cookie - Has a massive crush on Moonlight Cookie. They have also appeared in pride posts together.
Shadow Milk Cookie - Has that whole thing with Pure Vanilla Cookie that I don't even wanna get into again. Just read this
Shining Glitter Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts before
Sparkling Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Posts before
Spinach Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts before
Strawberry Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
T
U
V
Vampire Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
W
Whipped Cream Cookie - Has appeared in Pride Art
White Choco Cookie - Her story mentions that she has a lot of female fans and she dresses up as Lady Oscar; a bisexual character
Wildberry Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts before and is implied to have a crush on Crunchy Chip.
Wind Archer Cookie - Has appeared in pride posts before
X
Y
Z
Gender Queer Cookies
A
Amber Sugar Cookie - Technically a typo, but, when he was first introduced, the game used she/her pronouns for him. This was quickly changed
Ananas Dragon Cookie - Nonbinary
Angel Cookie - Nonbinary
B
C
Candy Diver Cookie - Nonbinary
Candlelight Cookie - Nonbinary
Choco Werehound Brute - Shown to be genderfluid and go by he/she/it pronouns
Cream Ferret Cookie - Nonbinary
Cloud Haetae Cookie - Nonbinary
Cookiedroid - Nonbinary
Cream Unicorn Cookie - Gender queer and goes by they/it
Cyborg Cookie - Genderqueer and goes by she/they pronouns
D
Dark Enchantress Cookie - Goes by she/her/it
Devil Cookie - Nonbinary
DJ Cookie - Nonbinary
Dragon Eye Cookie - Nonbinary
Dr. Bones Cookie - Nonbinary
E
Electric Eel Cookie - Nonbinary
Fettuccine Cookie - Goes by she/it pronouns
F
Fig Cookie - Nonbinary
G
Granola Cookie - Genderqueer and goes by she/they pronouns
Goblin Cookie- Nonbinary
H
I
Ice Juggler Cookie - Goes by she/they pronouns
Icicle Yeti Cookie - Nonbinary
Ion Robot Cookie - Agender
J
K
L
Lobster Cookie - Nonbinary
Longan Dragon Cookie - Nonbinary
Lotus Dragon Cookie - Nonbinary
Lychee Dragon Cookie - Nonbinary
M
Mocha Ray Cookie - Nonbinary
N
Nougat Cookie - Genderqueer and goes by he/she pronouns
O
P
Peppermint Cookie - Nonbinary
Pinecone Cookie - Nonbinary
Pitaya Dragon Cookie - Nonbinary
Poison Mushroom Cookie - Nonbinary
Pond Dino Cookie - Nonbinary
Q
R
Roguefort Cookie - Nonbinary
S
Shadow Milk Cookie - Genderfluid and sometimes transformers into women
This guy istg. Meet my new oc Umbra, I based him on tumblr sexymen, he is a magician and has a boyfriend chimera jester named Vixagra, I hate these sluts so much. But anyway they’re so peak😇
This guy istg. Meet my new oc Umbra, I based him on tumblr sexymen, he is a magician and has a boyfriend chimera jester named Vixagra, I hate these sluts so much. But anyway they’re so peak😇
blakekathryn
kaledo-art
annaxmalina
dededos
