Listening, Learning, and Leading: A Circus Artistās Contradictions
Part One: You Should Absolutely Listen to Other People
Circus is one of those art forms where ignoring advice can get you injured, embarrassed, or both. Sometimes simultaneously. If someone who has been doing this longer than you says, āHey, maybe donāt do itĀ thatĀ way,ā itās usually worth at least pausing mid-stubbornness to ask why.
I learned early on that most circus skills are not invented in a vacuum. There are reasons progressions exist. There are reasons coaches repeat themselves. There are reasons youāre told to drill the boring stuff before the flashy stuff. Someone else already tested what happens if you skip steps, and generously survived to warn you about it.
Listening, in this context, is less about obedience and more about efficiency. You borrow hard-earned knowledge so you donāt have to personally discover every possible wrong way to do a thing. Itās a communal act. A quiet acknowledgment that you are not the first person to try spinning upside down while trusting your body to obey physics.
And honestly, some of the best breakthroughs Iāve had came directly from advice I didnāt want to hear at the time. The kind that sounded obvious, annoying, or suspiciously like work.
I remember when I was training hand balancing for the very first time, and at that time, my shoulder muscles were pretty weak. I remember balancing against a wall, and my instructor came over and said āHey, your favoring your right arm, make it even.ā To which I thought, āPshh, of course Iām favoring my right arm, my right arm is stronger! I wouldnāt be able to hold this position otherwise.ā Belligerently, I kept favoring that arm.
In short order, the time came to come off the wall and freestand. Filled with confidence that only a novice can have, I threw myself into it, and straightened out as best I could. In moments, my weight shifted over my left side, I couldnāt correct, my left arm dislocated, and my face met the floor with a resounding thud. (Luckily the arm popped back into place almost immediately, but it still hurt a lot).
Bruised in both body and ego, I got up. Only after my instructor made sure I was alright he said āIf you always rely on your right side, you wonāt be able to correct on your left. DUHHHā.
Ok he didnāt actually say āDuhhhā at the end. But I could tell he was thinking it.
I made the adjustments and tried holding my weight evenly over both sides. Immediately, handstands became easier (NOT EASY, just āeasier.ā Meaning vaguely possible). I wasnāt able to hold it for nearly as long, but it felt stable, and that was a feeling I had never experienced before.
From that day on, I trained both sides equally, even if it sucked. And now I can hold a handstand!
Check it outā¦!This is a moment from a routine where I perform an āinverted tight rope walkā
So, big takeaway, listen to people when they tell you stuff! It might be helpful! Especially if theyāve done what youāre trying to do!
Then again, maybe not becauseā¦.
Part Two: You Should Definitely Ignore Other People
Hereās the problem. If you listen toĀ everyone, you end up doing nothing. Or worse, doing a very convincing impression of someone else.
Circus advice is abundant. Opinions are plentiful. For every person telling you to slow down, another is telling you to push harder. One coach wants precision, another wants risk. One artist swears by structure, another insists chaos is the point. If you try to incorporate all of it, youāll collapse under the weight of contradictory wisdom.
Thereās also a sneaky trap where learning becomes a substitute for doing. Watching tutorials. Taking notes. Asking questions. Waiting until you feel āready.ā At some point, preparation turns into avoidance, and you realize youāve become extremely informed about a skill you have barely tried.
Some things canāt be taught. They have to be felt. You have to make the wrong choice to understand why itās wrong. You have to follow an idea to its inevitable failure before you can let it go. No amount of advice replaces that moment when your body figures something out despite your brainās best efforts to interfere.
And yes, sometimes ignoring advice leads to discovery. Not always a good one, but usually an educational one.
I have another example from the same routine pictured above! I remember working on this routine with some colleagues and mentors of mine. The premise was simple: how many silly ways could I tightrope walk using only two chairs and a long piece of rope (Spoiler alert: this is currently a 7 minute piece in my show.)
During this workshoping stage, I was considering a lot of different options for the ending. I wanted to end on a success of some kind.
This is a popular way to end a clown routine; with some sort of impressive, and often counterintuitive, victory.
Several of my contemporaries (Many of whom had decades more experience than me) suggested I figure out a magical way of actually walking across the rope stretched between the two chairs. It sounds impossible, but we workshoped a few ways this could work. However, I ignored them all. Instead, I decided that I would flip the whole thing on its head, literally!
Now, as a finale to my routine, I perform the inverted tightrope walk. Where I handstand underneath the rope and tightrope walk upside down. Not only does this get a fantastic reaction, but it requires no setup, no expensive props, and Iāve gotten more positive feedback from audience members doing it this way, than any other way I tried. Sometimes, you just gotta stick with your gut, and do what feels right.
So, you shouldnāt always listen to adviceā¦
Except for when you shouldā¦
Unless you donāt want toā¦?
What am I even saying at this point?
Part Three: The Uncomfortable Middle
The annoying truth is that both of these things are true at the same time.
Listening matters. So does wandering off on your own.
The balance isnāt neat. It changes depending on where you are, what youāre making, and how much experience you have. Early on, listening keeps you safe. Later, listening too much can keep you small. At some point, the question stops being āWho should I listen to?ā and becomes āWhen do I stop listening and try this anyway?ā
What I keep coming back to is intention. Learn with purpose. Experiment with commitment. Take in advice as information, not instruction manuals. Let it inform you, not replace you. Circus thrives when artists absorb what came before and then make a mess with it. This is true for all creative endeavors
Youāre not here to perfectly execute someone elseās idea of your work. Youāre here to test, adjust, fall down, try again, and slowly build something that looks suspiciously like your own voice.
In the end, Iām happy I listened to my mentor when I was told how to do a better handstand. And Iām happy IĀ didnātĀ listen when I was told how my clown tightrope routine should end. I donāt think there is a black and white answer to this dilemma. All I can say is: listen long enough to understand whatās being offered, then decide whether it belongs to you. Some advice is a handrail. Some is a suggestion. Some is just someone else explaining howĀ theyĀ survived their own learning curve. Circus, like most creative work, lives in that uncomfortable space between respect and rebellion. You take what keeps you safe, discard what keeps you small, and occasionally learn the hard way which was which.
If nothing else, try to avoid dislocating anything in the process. But no promises.









