Li Tianxi: A (Disorganized, Messy) Rant on How She's An Eternal Victim of Misogyny, and Is Not An Equal To Anyone In Her Life Ever. Not Even Her Brother.
ok listen i don't even know how much sense this makes because im exhausted and spent five hours stuck in a hospital but i have been burning with the need to say: do you ever, in kavi @blackwaves's words, think about li tianxi and just feel so upset.
truly i think that reducing the twins to "tragedy" is a disservice to them. because yes, they're a horrible awful terrible tragedy from start to the rapidly incoming finish. they're twins, siblings, tied together since birth, but not once have they been a team nor have they ever been a united unit. tianchen killed their father and tianxi was a tool in it — they did not kill him together. they never killed anyone together. tianchen did the dirty work and shielded xiaoxi's eyes and kept everything from her and used her as a tool. he loves her more than anything and he wanted to keep her safe. he does. he still loves her and is furious and heartbroken. but he is a product of the home he was raised in the way xiaoxi in that: he's acting on learned violence and what he's learned is what is like to be a man.
he hated his father and maybe he's glad that his father is gone and suffered so much while he was alive but you can't tell me you haven't seen the similarities there. xiaoxi and liu lan were shrunk and kept quiet and refused to pry. willful ignorance. while tianchen and li fan did all the work. the difference is that li fan willingly and knowingly abused his wife out of petty jealousy while tianchen genuinely believes he's doing a good thing by keeping xiaoxi in the dark! he loves her more than anything and he's using her as a tool and he's patriarchy-ing her and he's the only person xiaoxi had left in this world!
the fact that they do not have equal agency is such an important part of their dynamic. he's not a good big brother but he is to xiaoxi in many ways because he's the only one who's ever been kind to her and loved her when it wasn't her mother. her mother told her to never speak of it again when she was scared and afraid her parents would separate and she's old enough to know that her father hurts her mother on a near-daily basis and she stopped speaking forever and never learned how to start again until the last possible moment!
like — it's tragic and heartbreaking, how she chooses to stop speaking. because when you're left out and your eyes and ears are covered up by the same person who protects you from it all and never tells you anything and you getting in the way only causes trouble you learn to stay out of the way and shut the fuck up and fold yourself, shrink yourself, until you're not an inconvenience anymore. and even then it's not enough because why does nobody listen even when you're quiet and listening to them? why are you still being ignored when you're quiet and out of the way? why are your feelings never considered? why does no one ever ask?
tianchen tells himself he's fighting for her. that he's protecting her. but they're never ever ever a unit or a team because xiaoxi is the tool that he uses to commit that violence and not once does he ask her how she feels about it. they're not on equal ground because what she wants, what she thinks, is never factored into anything he does. can you imagine, being xiaoxi, giving up her power for tianchen because he and qian jin made an agreement without once asking if she even wants to do it?
do you ever think about what it must be like to be xiaoxi and being adopted by the man who picked them up the night her brother killed both their parents, whether accidentally or not, and then that man is just like her father in less violent ways but just as demeaning — she's the mute, she's the girl who's just the tool her brother will use. her brother will never ask for her opinion on anything just because she smiles through her tears and pretends she's okay with it and qian jin will never consider her anything more than the fun extension that came with his new murder-weapon-slash-projection-toy functionally useful only for keeping tianchen in line and making their plots easier. and she still feels an odd sense of gratefulness to him — why wouldn't she? he doesn't consider her a real person but he took her in anyway, didn't he? and your brother doesn't ask what you want and plays along with qian jin and you go along with it because what you want is not relevant here. i just. augh. xiaoxi makes me so so upset forever.
liu xiao is the exact opposite of anything xiaoxi ever wanted for the both of them, because she just wanted to go home and not wake up feeling like she's smaller than the whole world. the opposite of what is objectively right for them, because what is liu xiao telling tianchen? to be more like a hunter. to pick out targets. to kill. to grab what he wants. and when is xiaoxi ever factored into this? we don't talk about the possible theories of him intending for xiaoxi to die because they're so nebulous and personally eye believe it would make the angst so much more delicious and painful and also aughhhh xiaochen you make me insane i miss them have no real proof as of right now beyond like. prometheus' pv. but regardless: in tianchen's pursuit of doing what liu xiao wanted — and it's ambiguous but i'm leaning towards a yes on whether he ordered tianchen to kill his brother, liu min — xiaoxi was the tool. she was the metaphorical shield tianchen used in his miserably painful and bloody life. it's against literally the one (1) thing she asked of him.
the point being — tianchen will tell himself it's about protecting her because he loves her but she's the excuse he uses to perpetrate the violence and unleash the anger and spill blood and reenacts the violence he learned from his father as he rages at the world for his unfair and harsh life.
and it is so, so deeply unfair and harsh. this is what you call cycles of abuse: this is what happens when children never learn any better and grow up to become the products of the worst of their childhoods. this is what happens when there's no one to protect them the way they deserve. what happens when there's no one to teach them any better. it ends like this: his sister is the tool he uses.
and he is keeping his sister from knowing anything. using his sister's agency to meet his own ends. they didn't kill anyone together; they watched their mother die together. it's so gendered, and intentionally so. link click very purposely draws gender roles into naked view through these stories and just...how do you ignore all of that and just mark them down as the tragedy of the pink twins?
he never listened to her until she died in front of him. they didn't kill anybody together much less their father because she didn't know what was happening until it was over and they watched their mother die together and was immediately thrust into shadow afterwards. li tianxi is a tragedy from start to finish, even after death, even as the (metaphorical or not) ghost she will be as season 3 begins to air. he never listened to her until she died and even then what does he proceed to do? reject the one thing she asked of him and go with liu xiao. he loves her and he's horrible to her. do you understand that? do you understand that he loves her and he's a horrible older brother?
he chooses violence again. she's his excuse for exacting revenge. again. and again. even in death.
this is why i honestly believe that it's impossible to illustrate the tragedy of the pink twins without touching upon the patriarchy-ing and misogyny and the liu xiao and qian jin of it all. she's been denied of agency her whole life and isn't granted that even in death. god. xiaoxi. she makes me so upset.