House of Wolves - sub!Tyler X Reader (Request)
requested by @crimson-claus : could you do house of wolves by mcr where the pairing is tyler x reader? preferably with subby tyler and a fem dom reader. thx sm i appreciate it!!
havenât written a one-shot in agessss so hereâs whatâs probably just a shitty attempt⊠anyway i hope you like it p.s. the formatting is weird but itâs currently 1:22am and i have to get up at six so iâm not fixing itÂ
You watched him like a predator, waiting for exactly the right moment to strike. He sang with so much passion, his full lips giving life to words of songs that otherwise were void of meaning to you.Â
Tyler Joseph was the head choir boy of the local church, the church that your father invested his heart, soul and much of his life into. Heâd had you attending Sunday services since before you could remember, the pastorâs little angel. When you were younger youâd only come under the promise of cookies and attention from kind, old ladies that would slip a lollipop into your hand whilst your parents werenât looking. Now though, the only thing that brought you back to this place each week, a place that held about as much meaning to you as any hymn not being sung by Tyler Joseph was the innocent, untainted, adorably naive  brunette with a voice that could make a grown man cry.
You glanced over at your father, sitting in a pew behind the alter, wiping a tear from half way down his cheek. He wished you were more like Tyler, held the undying faith that his star pupil did. Youâd probaby enviously despise the boy if he wasnât so goddamn pretty.
Returning your gaze to Tyler, a smirk pulled at your lips as you caught him looking right back at you. His eyes shifted away in panic, but the damage had already been done. A blush of crimson flooded his cheeks  as his voice cracked. It was only slight, but you noticed it, and the thought of him getting wound up over you began playing at your mind again, as you continued watching his mouth.
After the service was over, you sat in a pew watching your parents gush over how amazing he was.
âThat was wonderful Tyler, honestly, just beautiful.â Your mother beamed, her sweet tone making your stomach turn.
âThank you Mrs y/l/n, but the pleasure is all mine. itâs always an honour to sing in a place of such faith.â He spoke, his words like thick honey.
âItâs an honour to have you sing, my boy.â Your father smiled sincerely, patting Tyler on the back in a manner than annoyed you.
âThank you sir."Â
"Thank you Tyler. Y/n! Come over here.â
You got up slowly, walking over at a lazy pace and twirling a piece of hair between your fingers. He stared at the floor, scared to even look up incase he met your eyes again. It was cute. But dirty in a way that no one else could understand. âYes.â You spoke, directing  your words to Tyler, who had now gathered the courage to raise his head, but still refused to make eye contact with you.
âWe were just telling Tyler how wonderfully he sang today. Wasnât he wonderful?â You father stared at you expectedly.
âWonderful.â You mocked. âHowever, Iâd much prefer to see his mouth doing something else.â The line was terrible, but it was worth it to see the way he gulped, his breath audibly catching in his throat, making him cough gently. You smiled.
âY/n.â You could feel your parents stern, cold eyes boring into the side of your head, horrified by the statement they thought was an insult, but blissfully unaware of itâs true meaning.
âItâs a compliment, I swear.â You smiled innocently.
âI apologise for my daughter Tyler, she obviously canât recognise true beauty.â
âOh believe me father, I can.â You kept your attention focused of the brunette, silently daring him to look at you, a smirk on your lips.
âWell, to show your gratitude to Tyler for putting so much of his time into his faith and our church, you can stay and help him clean up.â
âYes father.â You spoke innocently, watching Tyler squirm.
Your parents left, leaving you and Tyler alone. You returned to your seat in the pew, crossing your legs and watching the boy scuttle around nervously. âYou did look awfully pretty up there Ty.â You said, seeing the way he jumped when he heard you speak.
âT-thank you.â He stuttered, still not turning to face you.
You got up, bored of his nerves, and walked over to the alter, where was straightening the carpet on the steps. You propped yourself up on the small table next to him and studied him at a closer proximity. He was still blushing, chewing on his lip until he drew blood.
âYou donât need to be so shy you know. You can look at me⊠you can do more than look if youâd like.â
He looked at you for a few moments, stunned and nervous, blinking like a deer in headlights and quickly lowering his gaze again.
âYouâre not used to girls, are you Ty? Youâve got innocence for days. I bet youâve never been touched, not even by yourself, right?â
He coughed again, his hands were shaking. âI-I donât think we should be talking about that here .â
A smirk pulled at your lips. âNo⊠of course not. Come with me.â You pushed yourself away from the table and took his shaking hand, leading him towards you fatherâs office.
âI-I have chores to-.â
âDonât worry, this wonât take long.ââŠâSit on the desk for me Ty.â You spoke, pushing the door shut and locking it. You turned round to see him sat awkwardly exactly where youâd told him to. âRelax. Nothing will happen if you donât want it to. I just wanna talk to you.â You said gently, walking over and sitting down next to him on your fatherâs desk. âWhy are you so scared of me?â
âI-Iâm not scared.â He insisted.
âNo? Then why wonât you look at me?â You asked, your voice a breathy almost-whisper.
He gulped, shaking his head, his fingers playing with a frayed thread on his jeans.
âCome on Ty, itâs okay.â
He took a deep breath, laying his palms flat against his thighs. âY-you make me think things⊠Things I shouldnât think.â
âWhat kinda things?â âD-dirty things.â He whispered, ashamed of his words. âSinful things?â You offered, a smirk on your lips.â "Y-yes.â He stuttered, keeping his eyes down. âDo you think of me on my knees? On my knees for you?â He inhaled sharply, his finger tips white from gripping his legs. After a while he nodded, the movement was barely there, but it was enough for you to see what you were doing to him. âI wanna hear you say it baby.â You spoke gently, getting up from the desk and standing infront of him.
ââŠYes.â He replied, finally lifting his eyes to look at you.
That was enough for you, and you offered him your hand, leading him to the arm-chair behind the desk and pushing him lightly into it, dropping to your knees in front of him. âLike this?â You asked, looking up at him.
âYes.â He spoke breathlessly, biting his lip again, blood making a quick appearance, the skin already raw. You leant forward slightly and swiped your thumb across his bottom lip, collecting the blood before bring it to your lips and sucking it from your skin, watching his eyelids flutter in disbelief.
âWhat do I do next?â
âI-I canât tell you.â
âWhy not baby?â
âI donât wanna go to Hell.â
You sighed. âNot even for a little while?â
He stared at you, afraid to open his mouth. After a few moments of silence you spoke. âFine.â You pushed yourself up on his knees and began walking towards the door.
âW-where are you going?â He asked, flustered.
âNot to Hell apparently.â You smiled sweetly, unlocking the door.
âN-no. Y/n.â He began, scrambling to get up and stop you. âWait. I want- I want⊠Please.â
âWhat do you want Tyler?â You spoke sternly.
He stood awkwardly, shifting his weight from foot to foot. âI- I want you to⊠I want your m-mouth⊠I want you on your knees and your mouth on my- myâŠâ
âOkay. Okay Ty.â You bit your lip, pausing momentarily. âStrip.â
âH-here?â
âDid I tell you to?â
He nodded, immediately starting to tug at his tie and the buttons on his shirt, pulling the material from his body and getting to work on his belt buckle.
âItâs okay. Iâll do the rest.â You walked back towards him, dropping to your knees again and pulling his belt from the loops, unbuttoning his jeans and pulling them down, letting them drop to his ankles. You could see how hard he was through his boxers, the outline of his dick pressed against the thin, black material. âDo you touch yourself when you think of me like this?â You asked softly.
âIâve neverâŠâ He started, trailing off as the familiar blush attacked his cheeks once more.
You smiled. âThatâs okay. Just try to hold out for me alright. Donât cum until I say you can.â
âO-okay.â
âGood boy.â You took the hem of his boxers between your fingertips and pulled them down, getting an eyeful of his erection, red with pressure, his stomach slick with pre-cum. He gasped softly as the air hit his skin, his cock twitching ever so slightly.
âSit.â You told him, moving in between his legs and he sat down in the arm chair again, too needy to question you. âYou ready?â
âP-please.â He sighed.
You obliged, placing your index finger on the tip of his dick and swiping up a drop of pre-cum from his slit, using the wetness to slide your finger delicately down his shaft. He whimpered at the first contact, writhing around in the seat as you toyed with him.
âLook at you.â You cooed, continuing with your teasing. âIâve barely even touched you and already youâre a mess for me.â
He whimpered again, his head lulling to the side as he squeezed his eyes shut.
âYou want more baby boy?â
His breaths were erratic, occasional whimpering moans falling from his lips. He nodded lazily, opening his eyes to look at you with a pleading stare.
âAnd how do you ask?â
âA-ah. Please⊠please.â He whined, rutting again the most gentle of touches, desperate for more.
You smirked, pressing his cock against his stomach and leaning forward, slowly licking a strip up the underside of his shaft. He let out a serious of short moans, gasping as you repeated the action. When you finally took him into your mouth the noise he made was feral, mouth agape as he threw his head back, gripping the leather arms of the chair.
âYou can touch me Tyler. Donât be shy.â You spoke, pulling away before his hands found the back of your head and you allowed him to guide you back down on to his cock. You wrapped a hand around the base, twisting back and forth as your lips met your fingers, your spit lubricating your fist. He was loud, noises on the verge of sobs leaving his mouth, and you could tell heâd cum soon if you let him.
Your suspicions were confirmed when a sentence formed around breathy moans let him tell you, âI-I think Iâm. Oh my-⊠Iâm close⊠Y/n⊠gonnaâŠcum.â
âNope.â You spoke curtly, halting any touch.
The look he gave you almost made your heart wrench as he sat there, thrusting up into nothing, whimpering desperately. You chuckled, getting to your feet. âDumb baby. You really thought I was gonna let you cum, without even working for it?â You walked over to the desk, pushing everything to one side. âCome on, up. Youâre gonna be my little fuck toy.â
He scrambled to his feet and sat on the edge of the desk in front of you. You unzipped your dress, letting it fall to the floor as you stepped out of your heels. He watched the material fall from your body, eager to drink in every part of you that he could. Next to go was your bra, leaving you stood topless in front him, unable to control the pulse you felt between your thighs as his tongue darted out to wet his bottom lip, visibly aroused even further by the sight. You pushed your panties down, kicking them off your feet and climbing on to the desk, straddling him as you began to kiss him. He was an inexperienced kisser, but he learnt quickly, copying you, occasionally catching your bottom lip between his teeth as he grew even more impatient.
You began to grind on his cock and he let out a high-pitched groan, your wetness making the movements slow and easy. You could tell how hard he was trying to be good for you, to do exactly as he was told, and that just made you want him more. âYou wanna fuck me Ty? Make me cum so you can get your reward?â You asked, keeping your movements steady.
âYes. P-please.â He replied.
You giggled darkly, positioning his erection at your entrance and slowly sliding down on to his cock, matching the moan that fell from his lips with one of your own. His mouth was opening and shutting repeatedly, his eyes squeezed shut as his face contorted from the pleasure of you riding him mixed with the pain of holding on to his orgasm. You took his hands and guided one up to cup your boob, feeling his fingers instinctively start to play with your nipple. You brought the other to your lips, sucking on two of his fingers before taking them down to the point that your bodies met. He opened his eyes to take the instruction, rubbing controlled circles on your clit as you guided him. You took your hands away, placing them on his tanned chest, enjoying his natural skill. âOh⊠Good boy. That feels so good baby.â You spoke breathlessly. He moaned at the praise, moving his fingers faster.
âYou close Ty?â You asked. He responded with a curt nod and a series of short grunts, biting down on his bottom lip to hold off as long as possible. The sight of him brought you closer to the edge, having him submit to you like this, obeying every command with absolute perfection, putting all his energy into getting you off. âThatâs perfect baby⊠R-right there⊠Iâm close Ty, donât stop.â He moved his fingers even faster somehow, doing his best to get as deep into you as he could. The new pressure had had you right on the edge, pushing you over as you came, grinding down on his cock and fingers.
You remove his hands from your body and pinned them down on either side of his head, still battling through your orgasm as you stuttered his permission. âY-you can cum now Ty. Cum for me.â He did so almost instantly, a breathy sob falling from his lips as your muscles tightened and contracted around him as you recovered, keeping your movements steady to help him ride out his high. You stayed that way for a while, basking in the post-orgasm haze, both moaning softly as your movements slowed to a halt.
You kissed him delicately on the lips and climbed off the desk. âThat was impressive.â You spoke honestly, watching him catch his breath, staring up at the ceiling.
âThank you.â He whispered, looking over at you, flashing you an innocent smile that made your stomach knot all over again.
You chuckled. âYou just lost your virginity in your church, on the pastorâs desk, with the pastorâs daughter. Think that makes you a man now choir boy.â
âYeah.â He sighed, pushing himself up to join you in putting your clothes back on. âIâm not sure how my next confession is gonna go though.â
âBless me father for I have sinned⊠I fucked your daughter.â You spoke casually, pulling your heels back on and stepping towards him. âYou, choir boy, just keep on being pretty. And everything will be okay.â
He giggled, a grin on his lips. âAre you gonna be here next week?â
âOh Iâll be here a lot more than once a week now Ty. But that was the easy part⊠youâre gonna have to try a lot harder from now on baby.â You smiled, kissing him on the cheek before walking towards the door, him hot on your trail. You opened the door to find a group of boys huddled outside, flustered expressions on their faces. You laughed and turned to face the boy behind you. âIâll leave you to deal with this one.â













