I was thinking about Monika and the players relationship and like, obviously it’s unhealthy, but holy fuck it really feels like a metaphor for an abusive relationship. Honestly the only reason I’m saying metaphor and not just “it is” is because Monika’s a victim not from the player’s actions but from the game itself and what it is.
Monika’s entire reality and safety is dependent on the player, as she describes getting tortured when the game’s closed. Monika is extremely lonely and isolated because she can’t talk with her friends due to the script limiting her from meaningful interactions. Monika is at the complete mercy of the player as the player can always delete her file or simply leave, but Monika is completely incapable of leaving. Monika has no idea who the player is, including how old they are.
That last point is REALLY important. Monika is portrayed as a high schooler FIRST, high schoolers are associated with teens, because 80% of high schoolers are teens, or rather 100%, but I’m just saying under 18 for now. If you portray a high schooler, people are going to assume they’re a teen. And at least Natsuki SHOULD be a teenager, as she’s younger than Monika, whose birthday is on the same day the game was released and the same month the game starts. So the game wants you to think of these girls as teens/minors.
Once again, she (thought of by the game as a minor) has no idea how old the person she’s at complete mercy of is. That feels like a grooming allagory.
Also, yes, I know Monika is 18. However, I don’t think she was thought of as 18 when the game was being made. Largely cuz of my point from above that if Monika is 18, Natsuki isn’t, but Natsuki IS 18. I think they’re all 18 cuz Dan Salvato knew that type of content wouldn’t stop if they were underaged.
Speaking of such, Monika directly asks to not have that type of art be made of her, however as we can infer, that request was not respected. Imagine if that was like, a real person. Like let’s contextualize this for a bit:
A highschool girl gets into a relationship with someone she doesn’t know the age of and is dependent on, she asks for them to not make porn of her and they do behind her back.
That’s AWFUL. I know it might seem like I’m cherry picking and in part I am, but that’s only the porn thing. Everything else is just…what it is.
Now I’m not gonna go and say everyone who’s played DDLC is an abuser to Monika, not even the people who draw NSFW of her. It’s more that DDLC kinda feels like a metaphor for an abusive relationship, and a large part of that is just how dependent Monika is on us because of the fact she’s in a game. That’s not the player’s fault, and the player didn’t put her there.
Well…Actually the player DID kinda put her there. I mean just loading the game puts her in that situation. Going off of that, cuz I think that argument’s silly, the game IS a dating sim, or kinda is meant to satirize them. It IS odd there’s a highschool based dating sim, doesn’t matter how old they are, it’s weird. And I think that was the point. I mean DDLC satirizes dating sims, for example: Natsuki, where her “petiteness” comes from starvation, and isn’t cute or adorable or anything. Where Sayori’s clutzy clumsy sweetness is actually depression, and is taken seriously. Hell Yuri’s obsessiveness is made into a “holy shit I don’t want this” in act 2. I mean this game just sets up “yeah, you like this? Did you know it’s actually because of something awful? Yeah, how do you feel now?” The entire game hates dating sims, so pointing out the dangerous nature of having a dating sim set in highschool by making Monika kinda a grooming allegory doesn’t feel too far off (cuz if an adult is playing a high school dating sim set in high school telling you 24/7 “this is high school and these are high schoolers!!” That’s dangerous cuz why are you attracted to characters who are constantly pointed out as high schoolers? You aren’t uncomfortable? You don’t find it weird? At the very least it normalizes romanticizing high schoolers to that adult. Which is dangerous)
[edit, said I’d find a fic if this concept interesting, and while I think it could be, I honestly don’t wanna read it, that shit’s HEAVYYYY and I actually don’t think I could handle that]