Book recommendation: When the World Tips Over, by Jandy Nelson
This is a YA book in the sense that most of the main characters are older teens. But if you're not reading YA books because you think you're too old and they have nothing to say to you, you're seriously missing out. I (re)started reading YA fiction in the mid-2010s to vet books for my kid when they were a young teen, and I was floored at how amazing it had gotten in the 30ish years since I'd read it for myself. So I haven't stopped.
This story is told through rotating points of view between each of three siblings (and also their mother through some unsent letters), and a mysterious stranger who has met each of them separately at important times.
Some of the themes are: art (in various forms), connection, destiny, unusual people who are maybe a little bit magic. It's set in the real world but at the edge of fantasy. There are things that are so sad in this book: mistakes, regrets, lost time, lost people. But then there's so much love: family, friends, soulmates. Love for life, love for books and stories and music.
I read novels, no, not read, I tear them open and crawl inside them and hide in between the words.
-- Jandy Nelson, When the World Tips Over
All of the characters are fascinating, and there are so many things to figure out about them, what happened to this person, what is driving that person. I never wanted to stop reading because I had to see what would happen next, and it was usually surprising and yet made complete sense.
Lots of CWs, which might get a bit spoilery: rape, neglectful parenting and abandonment, mental illness of a parent, underaged driving, emotional and physical child abuse (in a family story), homophobia (in a family story), death and suspected murder (in a family story), ghosts, alcohol abuse, drugs, car vs. statue, car vs. pedestrian, hospital, coma. I'm sure I'm missing some.
If I have a criticism, it's that the story doesn't have an epilogue. It ends right at the point where you start to believe things are going to be okay, but there's still at lot left up in the air. I'm pretty okay with that, all I really demand from an ending is that it's hopeful, but it would be nice to know more. I fell in love with these characters and care about what happens to them.
I do believe now that when the world tips over, joy spills out with all the sorrow.
But you have to look for it.
-- Jandy Nelson, When the World Tips Over
Also by Jandy Nelson: I'll Give You the Sun and The Sky Is Everywhere. I've read both but I don't remember The Sky is Everywhere that well. I'll Give You the Sun is breathtaking, and very similar in its themes and the emotions that it stirs up, also recommend very much.