romantiisme:
it’s a lovely speech. would have been quite moving at another time, he’s sure, with another person. overlooked, disregarded, cast aside– no better words could she have chosen to pull at his historically neglected heartstrings, on a normal day. one where they were not so recently snipped down the middle.
we need each other, she says, and elias smiles obligingly. falls into the expression easy as anything, considering it’s the same one he’s practiced everyday for years, the natural countenance of a good steward, the one that says: i am calm. i am content. i am inoffensive in every way. “oh, i’m not pushing you out,” he replies, polite as if reciting a menu. tilts his head a touch as he blinks up at her above him. “you’ve got the whole scene backwards, dear. i was the one beside you when half the ship called you mad, and the other called you demonic. you’re the one who left. and without a word of farewell, too– goodness.”
( this tone. this voice. it comes from his own mouth, and yet he doesn’t recognize it. and yet he can’t quite make it stop. )
“so i’d consider this entire production–” a wave towards her, and her general state, “– a bit late to the party. i’m glad to hear you can ‘heal on your own’. impressed at your verve, and all that. but as for myself– i’ve rather lost faith in such ideas. no energy left to spare for them. so, if that’s everything…”
he clears his throat. lets out a little cough he’s never heard before, and knits his hands together over his stomach. breathes in deep for the final rejection, the kick out the door, when he notices:
she’s wearing his trousers.
he stops. frowns, because he has no idea when she could have taken them, hadn’t even known they were missing, but their ownership is undeniable: not only are they absurdly long on her frame, cuffs rolled up nearly to where his knees would normally be, but he recognizes the unmistakable dark green shape near the left pocket– a small leaf embroidered by a london friend, early in his time in the navy. can still taste the gin on his tongue from the evening she’d handed them over, laughing– so you’ll always know what’s yours, even with all you boys dressed the same, the friend had said, and the love had been like a splinter in his throat.
with the memory, the last reserve keeping him going– keeping this act alive– crumples, leveled like a shout.
the only outward sign of it comes with a small gasp, hardly more than a breath outwards. he slides a hand over his mouth, eyes round with horror, and from between his fingers, with the sort of desperation usually reserved for the dying, he begs: “i just– i really think you should leave, emma.”
Elias smiles but it does not sit right. The gesture spreads on his face like arctic fog rolling over frozen hills. Well, actually, more than that, it reminds her of a tundra apparition. Dangerous. Disturbing. Untrustworthy.
She inhales at his words, a sharp and painful action. When did her romantic learn how to cut into hearts like this? Who is this person? Plucking fond memories from the past and sharpening them for weaponry. Is the same being who waxed poetry with her, whose touch is more familiar than her own hand?
And then, and then, to push the blade deeper, he waves her off and says, ‘this entire production--’. Production! As if she was capable of pretending, as if their entire friendship was not founded in the authenticity of two known souls.
I crossed the ocean for you, she wants to scream. I faced my demons for you. I went back to the womb of all my nightmares and hauntings, to keep you safe. To keep the Silent One at bay. And you want to tell me that this is all production? Her features twist, brows knitting together and mouth in ugly downturn. Her bottom lip quivers.
Emma’s vision blurs, tears starting as he dismisses her one last time. And yet, she does not do as she is told. She cannot.
“If I leave now...I will never come back to you,” A tear drags down her face, falling from the mere thought, “We will never return to each other again. Elias, please. Can we not just talk this out?” She places a gentle hand on his knee.
“It was supposed to be a secret. And we never planned to stay for more than a night on the island. At the time, there was no reason to say goodbye. And even so, I did say a sort of goodbye...I wrote you a letter, to read if I didn’t return––You have to understand, Elias. I––I didn’t go to the island to abandon you. I did it to save you, to spare you from the same fate as the Agathe. ...I’ve lost so many friends, Eli. So many people I will never get back.” Gabriel, Eloise, Jaime... “I know you can’t fully understand but if you were in my shoes, if you experienced what I have, wouldn’t you do the same? Wouldn’t you do everything in your power to save someone you loved? Even if they didn’t like what you did.”











