12 Monkeys Theories
Under the cut cause it’s long and with spoilers for last night’s episode.
Okay, so where to start?? Last night’s episode gave me a lot to chew on.
New Theory: Cassie and Cole’s baby is Cassie’s mother or father.
This wouldn’t be the first time we have hints of people creating themselves. I believe the messengers were created because the messenger who survived the 1944 paradox is probably the same woman Dr. Krischner took egg samples from to create the messengers in the first place.
It would make sense why so many things in this episode seemed inevitable. When Cassie found the house she realized something wasn’t right almost immediately. Even after recognizing the room with the clock and concluding that the army of the 12 monkeys and the witness knew about this place, she started to put the brakes on the whole thing, but conveniently forgets about it 20 minutes later.
However, there are some problems with this theory since it seemed like most of the events in 1957-59 hadn’t happened in the future yet (first time this loop is happening??). Why wasn’t Cassie’s and Cole’s research about the factory already in the hotel in 2016 and on? In 2044, Zeit scouted and did not find Titan (and I believe it didn’t exist) until both Cassie and Cole are at the house together. So…Whoever is born from Cassie and Cole’s union is instrumental in the existence of Titan.
I think Cassie and Cole’s union produces Cassie’s mother or father (and yet at the same time is Cassie’s child! And thus she and Cole are her grandparents!!!! That’s a mind-blowing statement right there lol). Therefore, time is all jacked up because that is a major paradox!!
Their child certainly could be the witness, but that doesn’t explain how they can time travel. My main thought is that basically this all had to happen otherwise Cassie doesn’t exist.
Theory 2: Sam is the witness.
I’m not ready to give up on this theory yet. I feel like the writers were building up his story too much to not have him still play an integral role. The witness seems to have super powers. Why? All the test subjects that came back in ‘Meltdown’ were horribly disfigured from the time stream, yet Sam goes back to who knows where and when completely unscathed. I think this is because the time stream didn’t mess him up physically, but it did take a piece of his consciousness. This could explain why the witness can time travel with his mind.
Wherever Sam went, someone was waiting him. That means this definitely isn’t the first loop. Also, only Sam knows where he ended up. I think in the original loop, Sam discovers that he can time travel with his mind, heck, he could have created the ancient time travel religion himself. He goes to the future with his mind and orchestrates something for someone to come back and get him.
And here’s the big question for the witness, what is the motivation behind destroying time? I feel none of the characters that we’ve interacted with so far have a clear reason for going that far, but I like to think Sam fits best. When Sam’s mother dies, we barely see Sam grieve for her. How did he deal with her death, especially when his father shows up and then promptly disappears again for years? When Ramse finally does return, Sam finds out that Ramse was “helping the bad guys” because of him and is understandably distressed by this.
When we first meet Sam, he lives at Spearhead-humanity’s last hope against the virus, but another group (our time travelers) come in and wreck everything and slaughter people to steal the core for the equally just cause of time travel (humanity’s alternative last hope). When Sam gets splintered back to wherever, the future was looking very bleak and time traveling wasn’t working…
From a childlike perspective, how does everybody get what they want?
So I think Sam is just playing a giant game of Go with the universe to break and fix everything at the same time.
It is equally ironic for Ramse, to lose his son because of his own actions. This parallels the Pharoah of Egypt in the bible (Pharaoh Ramses is one of the possibilities of the Pharoah in Exodus), who loses his first born because of his hard heart. And Ramse has certainly hardened his heart!
Also, how sick of a reveal would it be, as Ramse lay dying on the ground, the witness takes off his mask to reveal his one and only son (perhaps even older than he last saw him)??!











