I like the HTTYD movies for the friendship between Hiccup and Toothless, and man, the ONLY thing people talk about is Hi/ccstrid and I hate it. I didn't come here for this, give me the friendship the entire plot of the first movie is about, not some romance. (Idk if it's ~abuse~, persay, but I still don't like the "punch then kiss" thing. It's mean, and you ((or whoever said it)) is right that there'd be an uproar if it were the other way around :/)
Me too!!! I mean, that was the magic that really dragged me kicking and screaming into the fandom in the first place all them years ago. And I wouldn’t say the only thing people talk about is that ship -- because if you find yourself in the right circles it’s great -- but you’re right in that its a very pervasive subject in the fandom as a whole. Here’s to hoping HTTYD3 will bring about some wholesome Hictooth again!! *chugs mead at 8 am*
Honestly the whole “This wouldn’t fly if it were flipped” situation doesn’t read to me, since I believe it would fly. Not only for their culture (hearty back slaps and shoulder punching) but because Astrid isn’t really hurting Hiccup when she punches him in the kiss-and-punch. She’s not socking him in the jaw or anything. Who knows, Astrid might be into it as well (this was a JOKE doodle btw!).
This is something I talk in depth about on This post. I’ve also talked about how their physical altercations before have no weight on their later relationship.
No, the thing that makes it ‘uncute’ for me is that Hiccup doesn’t seem to love it. He’s making a tolerance for what he knows she’s been raised to show as affection, but if she persists it shows she’s not really listening to him. That’s where it puts a sting on the relationship. It’s not a matter of ‘abuse’ (like damn, not by a long shot) it’s a matter of respect and listening.