. . • ☆ . ° .• °:. *₊ ° . ☆
“you might’ve loved them, but you didn’t like them.”
rafe cameron x actuallyawkward!reader , sarah cameron x actuallyawkward!reader !
tw: confrontation, arguing, canon!rafe, reader finally accepting themselves for who they are (yay), mentions of depressive behaviors/episodes, rafe’s canonical daddy issues and drug abuse… sarah being an absolute angel to reader <3
the word spread fast— like a winter cold that confines you to the bed. rafe cameron fucked up. and he fucked up bad. well, to those who didn’t fall for the propaganda of a perfect cameron heir. desperate finance bros still held rafe in the highest regard, and sorority girls flocked to him since he was freshly available. yet, rafe didn’t seem interested in either cluster of groupies. he didn’t seem interested in anything at all.
rafe’s confined in his connected bathroom, hunching over the counter like he’s about to throw up. there’s this itch, this tantalizing sensation of spiders crawling up his legs and fusing together beneath the tanned skin. his hands shake, a weak attempt to reach for the knob and run his face under the cold water. waterboarding seems like a viable option, yet rafe knows he couldn’t do it himself. too much time, too much effort. he doubles back to what he’s familiar with; another little packet of white residue that makes it all go away. he doesn’t even remember your name, or the way your fingertips traced his collarbones when you laid together. you’re just another failure on his long list of disappointments.
you, however, seem to be healing. forever the awkward homebody, you don’t make appearances often, but it still shocks the young adult population on the island. there are no excessive under eye circles, or hair that frays from the slightest touch. you aren’t rafe cameron’s little pet any longer, just a cross between a ghost and a survivor. how on earth did you make it out? you don’t have a clue. stroke of luck, guardian angel, or whatever else the kids want to conjure up. you’ve always been you.
your parents, albeit annoyed that you’ve returned home so quickly, are somewhat relieved. the cameron family is infamous around the island, they don’t want you mixed up with something like that. even if it means dealing with your presence again. you know you’ve never been the favorite kid, but it still stings. you feel the same way about rafe. sure, he sucked and everyone could see it, yet you couldn’t find yourself splitting away from him. like how the muscle still works once the limb is gone. there’s remnants of him everywhere, and there isn’t much to do about it. the only way through is to outlive it.
“hey.” going to a kegger at the boneyard wasn’t your greatest choice, but there wasn’t anything new on the history channel and your parents seemed annoyed that you were even existing outside of your room. so, when sarah cameron waltzed up, you knew you fucked yourself. sarah notices the way your shoulders immediately tense, and how your eyes scan the beach for any sign of him. she offered a smile, “d-don’t worry, he’s not here. pretty sure he’s on a coke binge.” the middle cameron’s always been the easygoing one— the kook princess who could charm her way through anything. you consistently wondered if it ever got exhausting, to be so accessible at all times. it wasn’t until you got with rafe that you got a snippet of that feeling; that icy numbness covering you like a jacket that doesn’t fit anymore. uncomfortable, feeling like you don’t fit in your own skin.
“sarah, i don’t mean to be harsh, but… there’s no reason for you to talk to me. ‘m not with rafe anymore so we can just, i dunno, go back to being strangers? not cut out for either side of this dumbass turf war anyway.” you say. sarah’s left hand twitches, sloshing cheap beer onto the sand and trailing down her forearm. she’s wearing a tiffany ring, only in gold because that’s just what cameron’s wore.
sarah thought that no one could ever know rafe like she did. like their dad did. his irritation that blossomed when he was just a kid, the yearning for ward to do anything with him. then, the drugs once he got to junior year. just cheap shit at first, molly and a little bit of K. after? cocaine, experimenting with dealers like barry who owned way more spoons than the average american. then, you came along.
the awkward, afraid-to-move-wrong you. it seemed like you could walk on eggshells just fine, and that’s what rafe was. what rafe is. there isn’t any light left in him, sarah believes. but, you made it seem like there was— even if it was just the fluorescence that follows you in the dentist office or in the grocery store.
“i jus’ wanted to see how you’re doing. and that i’m really happy that you left. i know he had his good moments, but he’s not a good guy. you shouldn’t have been caught up in hurricane rafe. and i feel like i let you.” she speaks quickly, as if daring to utter his name will summon him from the depths of hell. you aren’t incredibly sure, because if anyone could find a way, it’d be him. it’s nice, almost endearing to know that sarah takes blame for allowing the relationship to happen. you both know it’s not true, yet you don’t rush to correct her. there’s a silence that plagues the two of you— managing to drown out the noise of blaring music and boisterous laughter.
you don’t how to answer the question of “how are you doing?” you’re straddling the fence of past and present, only a few skips away from the future. but you can’t get down. there’s still a little bit of hope in you. that maybe he didn’t mean all the things he said that night, or even all the other mornings, noons, and nights. the worst part? you know it’s not true. no matter how big of a gap between yesterday and today. he’s controlling, and he’s arrogant, and he doesn’t care about anyone. not himself, and certainly not you.
sarah realizes how your eyes aren’t as narrow now, softening as you stare at her. your arms fall to your sides, there’s no need to protect yourself from anything. “i’m just… here. i’m here a-and i’m healthy and uh, i’m outta the hurricane. that’s enough for me. for right now.” you finally respond, voice trembling like a ripple in the sea. it’s an eerie moment, how the seconds it took for you answer sarah’s question felt like hours. the way miller lite clung to the air and made it difficult to breathe. she pauses, before she nods at you slowly. in one swift move, her red solo cup is tossed carelessly to the ground— in true cameron fashion. then? sarah’s arms stretch out towards you, and you can’t find it in yourself to hold back. sarah, you notice, is warm-blooded. it’s comforting, even with her chin digging into your shoulder and her tight grip. at least it’s real, and that’s more than you ever got with him.
like the news of the breakup, sarah cameron’s unexpected hug was the shot heard around the world. rafe, of course, is the first to know. he’s got eyes and ears scattered around the island; and the fact that his own sister would dare approach you is baffling. it’s just rafe and sarah at tannyhill— ward at a business meeting on the mainland, rose and wheezie busying themselves with upcoming events for back-to-school. she’s in the kitchen once he finally lays eyes on her, humming a song he doesn’t know while making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. her favorite since they were kids.
“you, uh, wanna explain to me why you were talkin’ to my ex? ‘cus i really don’t think it’s your place to play nancy drew and find out what happened between us.” rafe asks, rubbing at his nose with his fingers. he’s been using too much; the nosebleeds and the sleepless nights are haunting his life. sarah let out a huff, the butter knife clattering down on the countertop. she shrugged, “i can talk to whoever i want. and we didn’t even talk about you, so… i dunno what you want me to say.”
there’s a sharp pang in his chest, was sarah serious? surely, you must’ve talked about him. what else was there? you were too well-off for the pogues, too poor for the kooks. a freak of nature, he believed. rafe scoffs— clicking his tongue in disbelief. “nah, nah, don’t lie to me, sare. what did you fuckin’ say to them, huh? that they were stupid to even get with me? t-that i’m the worst person alive and i would’ve drained them dry?!”
sarah notices the way her brother starts to whip his head around, searching for an anchor who’s not there anymore. you’re gone, long gone and he chose it. not you. the lines and the partying and the drinking all come back to him; rafe cameron and his inexplicable thirst for something, for anything. when she fails to answer, rafe laughs as if he couldn’t fathom what was going on. “what’d they tell you, hmm? that i treated them like fuckin’ dirt? well, they fuckin’ let me, so i dunno what the animosity is about. i gave them everything, every damn thing i could and they were too scared to say thanks! i loved them better than anyone ever could.”
she never thought he’d admit the quiet part out loud. rafe cameron picked you because he knew no one else would ever make you feel loved. not even the only people you had, your parents. sarah inches towards the plate, her eyes never leaving rafe’s face. he’s red in his cheeks, skin peeling around his nose and sarah knows what that means. he’s losing it, and she’s not sure when he’ll hit the bottom.
“you might’ve loved them, but you didn’t like them. that’s why they left, rafe. it’s not anyone’s problem but yours.” sarah’s voice cut through the air, and stopped rafe in his tracks. he doesn’t move to crack his knuckles, or run a hand through his greasy hair. rafe stands still, like one of the little action figures you always talked about before. they were your dad’s, you weren’t allowed to move them. rafe couldn’t imagine what that felt like, until now.
all rafe can hear are sarah’s footsteps up the stairs and the ringing in his ears. is it true? was that how people saw you and him? like an obsessive doll collector and his new favorite piece? no, no, that couldn’t be it, there was no way! rafe loves you, even if you basically damned him to hell and left without any goodbye. his baby, his sweetheart who tried. you tried so hard, and he didn’t even notice. didn’t care to notice. what did it matter now?
. . • ☆ . ° .• °:. *₊ ° . ☆
hi! this is sorta part two to the first rafe and actuallyawkward!reader, but it’s more focused on reader following the fallout. and i wanted to incorporate sarah in some fashion bc you KNOW that she hated how rafe treated reader but couldn’t do much :(((