(Mike) I have to begin by stating that I have not been a rider on the Arcade Fire bandwagon since the beginning. I did buy their first three releases – almost out of a sense of obligation to their importance as a ‘Canadian’ band on the world scene.
But I have never completely warmed up to "Funeral", "Neon Bible" or "The Suburbs". To me, all three were interesting releases but were missing ‘a warmth’ that I craved. I loved what Arcade Fire was doing in their videos, taking that art form to a new, interactive level. But the songs often left me with a cold, empty feeling. I guess you could say I paid my fare but didn't jump on for the ride.
Having said that, ‘Reflektor,’ though not full of that warmth, is breaking new ground for me as a listener to this band. Their musicianship seems to have reached Talking Heads-like quality, exhibiting a willingness to take new chances with rhythms, instrumentation, and lyricism – as shown in Regine Chassagne singing in French throughout this song.
It's propelled by a dark, driving beat that, even without a chance to watch the intriguing video (or to participate in the interactive version) gives you a feeling of watching a David Lynch film. This is a moody, foreboding song about life and death, and the connections in between those two worlds. Has the route to heaven been found, or is it just a reflection? I have already warmed up to this track in a way I have not previously been able to with this band.
Much has been said already about the influence of a trip to Haiti taken by Win Butler and by Regine Chassagne (who is of Haitian lineage.) I don't particularly hear that in this track. But what I do hear is David Bowie's influence.
Bowie has admitted that he provided backing vocals on ‘Reflektor,’ and though it is difficult to pick out his voice, you can certainly hear a blast of his 80s inspiration. In fact, Alexis Petridis of The Guardian writes that the new disc is obviously a tribute to Bowie's Scary Monsters album. And Chris Richards of The Washington Post refers to Win Butler "pulling on David Byrne's oversized blazer" on another song on the CD.
Hmm. David Bowie... Talking Heads… Two ultra-80's comparisons for a very modern rock band. What do you make of that, AJ?
(AJ) I’ll take your eighties observances and trump you with a seventies card. And I’m not just talking about the mirrored disco ball that lights Arcade Fire’s way through a fascinating fun video.
When you asked me what we should talk about next on Cold Fade, I suggested ‘Reflektor’ qualifying my choice with a sheepish “because I don’t really know what I think about this song yet.” Even after a couple of listens and jotting down a few notes, I am still not sure. I am hoping that the process of writing this post will help me explore my ambivalence and allow me to get back to my more usual decisive self.
I’m not sure how this song makes me feel.
And before I could tell anyone what song you and I would be exploring next, I had three people including Kerry (my wife) suggest that we give ‘Reflecktor’ a spin because all of them really liked it. (Interestingly, none of these people were big Arcade Fire fans before ‘Reflektor.’ Again, it wasn’t a hate-thing. It was just that, despite the Grammy win, the band wasn’t on their musical radar.)
It would seem that you and I were rocking the same musical boat (as opposed to being on the Arcade Fire bandwagon) when it came to what this Canadian ‘supergroup’ from Montreal had produced in the past. Sadly, you could probably play almost anything from these guys for me and I might not be able to tell you who they were. That feels embarrassing to admit. I feel like I should turn in my passport and move to Buffalo. (There is one exception to my moronic rule: I really did enjoy “Keep the Car Running’ from ‘Neon Bible.’ I suppose I am being too cliché when I said that the song had a style and a rhythm that kept me going for the entire 3:29 but so be it.)
I do like ‘Reflektor’s’ big full sound. Right from the beginning, there is no doubt that Win and company are not messing around and that they have a story to share. Rhythmically, the song immediately catches you with subtle genre-shifting changes and soaring ethereal vocals. I too couldn’t help but reflect a little after hearing their “If this is heaven…” line. And in the end, after listening to the song and watching the video and hearing and reading what others have to say – I have the upmost respect for the big talents and supreme artistic attitudes that make up this group and create such a complete cohesive sound. But I still don’t fell a personal emotional connection to the song.
Is it that the song sounds too big? No. I don’t think so. On the contrary, I think I might be disappointed by anything less from these guys. Even at seven-plus minutes, I don’t feel the need or desire to fast forward and skip to the end. The song stays fresh minutes past what could have been its expiry date. As a matter of fact, I love the ‘to be continued’ kind of feel to the end of ‘Reflektor.’ It makes me think there is more to say and that’s a good thing.
But it’s taken a lot of listens to train my cluttered brain to even recall the tuneful chorus.
(Mike) It is a BIG song, even taking into account that little 7-note piano-plinking motif that takes over just past the half-way point. Perhaps this ‘bigness’ is the reason why the band has now stirred up some controversy over their directive that fans dress formally at their shows. The request seems to have ticked some people off. I mean, an arena is not really the place you want to go dressed formally these days. Apparently, Win Butler has said the fancy clothes will improve the chances of Arcade Fire's fans getting laid! Somehow, I have never equated Arcade Fire's music with an increased chance of that, but maybe I've been missing something. I'll have to throw on my old baby-blue tux and slip on the whole CD to see if this works for me tonight.
As for you not recognizing the music of this Canadian ‘supergroup’ on early listens, it brings to mind a point that has irked me a bit since they hit the big time. Yes, I know they "formed" in Montreal, and they bought an old church in Quebec to record in. And yes, Regine Chassagne is Canadian and grew up in La Belle Province. But is this band really, truly Canadian?
Its principal songwriter, lyricist and de-facto band leader Win Butler, was born in Texas and raised in New Hampshire. His brother shares that background and is another member of Arcade Fire. I guess its okay to take them on as our own, and to be proud of their success on the world stage, but it all rings a little less true to me.
Anyway, back to the song. The more I listen to it, the more I love it. In fact, I got in the car this morning on my way to work and stumbled upon the song about two minutes in. I realized instantly that this is one of those tunes that I can recognize at any point and enjoy thoroughly no matter where or when I joined in.
And it's one of those songs whose hook will stay with me for the rest of the day – no matter what else I listen to between then and when I retire for the evening. I know when I lay my head on that pillow tonight, I will be singing "It's just a reflector…" to myself over and over and over. It's musical candy for me.
(AJ) You’ll have to let me know how the whole “tux” experiment worked. On the other hand… don’t.
My lack of ‘love’ for the song also places it in the “musical candy” category for me. And I agree that the minute you hear even a little bit of ‘Reflektor,’ you can instantly stand-up at the top of Mt. Robson and yell “That’s Arcade Fire! I know it is!” But candy is sweet and eventually dissolves to nothing. Even the sugar rush wears off in the end leaving you with not-a-lot to show for the treat. And that’s why ‘Reflektor’ is still a ‘like’ and not a ‘love’ for me.
One of the three who recommended that we talk about ‘Reflektor’ suggested that what I need to do is listen to the entire album. I agree. I miss those days of listening to a CD or a cassette (especially when I was driving in my “running” car) or even an LP from beginning to end; and taking-in the band’s science of flow and order. To me, Arcade Fire is more than the songs they produce. Their work harkens back to a day when concepts and themes were a bigger part of the greater scheme of things.
So for now, while you sit comfortably on the Arcade Fire bandwagon, I’ll continue to walk along side wearing a giant papier-mâché head listening to Bowie and Byrne on my iPhone.