Christmas Themed Nalu Fanfictions:
Christmas Wish by Layna Panda
T, Romance & Humor, chapters: 1 (complete)
Summary: "You know what I want for Christmas? I want a—uh—a boyfriend! A boyfriend with... err, pink hair! Yeah, cause, you know, pink hair is the bomb. And a cute grin and an awesome personality! I want him to be obsessed dragons and fighting and eating! He'll be almost six foot and he'll be built and tan and he'll be the best out there. Yeah, that's what I want for Christmas." —Natsu&Lucy
Big Tree Dreams by LoneStorm
T, Humor & Romance, chapters: 1 (complete)
Summary: In which little and ridiculously ginormous Christmas dreams come true. Nalu Christmas tree farm AU. For joannya in the Secret Santa Fairy Tail fic exchange.
One Night by HawkofNavarre
T, Romance & Friendship, chapters: 1 (complete)
Summary: If you fail to catch that train on Christmas Eve, it was probably the dragon slayer's fault. Natsu x Lucy (Dedicated to all my readers.)
Miss Santa by Layna Panda
M, Romance & Humor, chapters: 1 (complete)
Summary: On Christmas, Natsu writes to Santa as a joke that he wants Miss Santa to take his virginity away but, when Christmas night comes and somebody claiming to be Miss Santa comes visit him to fulfill his wish, he knew he was going to be writing to Santa every year. —Natsu&Lucy
Strangers before Christmas by Aky-san
K, Romance & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 1 (complete)
Summary: Two strangers go out shopping for presents, unaware that their lives are about to merge. Follow along a story about two different people trying to find their own gifts, but finding something else instead. Two people, two lives, two stories, and one look in the eyes that forever changes strangers to lovers. A story about a very special Christmas - NaLu Christmas Story Oneshot
Deck the Halls, Bitches by Rivendell101
M, Romance & Humor, chapters: 8 (complete)
Summary: One week before Christmas Lucy realizes she has a problem. In her frustration, she may or may not have told her entire extended family she was bringing a date to Christmas. She lied. Cana's solution? A Craigslist Ad posted by one Natsu Dragneel. Too much whiskey, crazy family members, and a multitude of awkward situations only serve as obstacles. There will be casualties.
The Twelve Days of Fairy Tail by riverofmemories
T, chapters: 1 (complete)
Summary: "Every year, we do a little Christmas tradition that we call the Twelve Days of Fairy Tail. From the fourteenth of December until the twenty-fifth, one person will get on the nearest table at around ten in the morning and blurt out the song lyrics they've made for the song as well as the last set." In which Lucy experiences her first real Christmas in years and a guild tradition.
A Very Fairy Christmas by CalaveraCandiedSkull
T, Humor & Romance, chapters: 2 (complete)
Summary: AU. In which the high school secretary, Mirajane Strauss, decides that the only way to see her co-workers together in time for Christmas is the employment of dirty tricks. Or in this case, Secret Santa. /Christmas fic! Lots of pairings! No, really. NaLu, GaLe, Gruvia, Jerza, MiFri, ElfEver, Bixanna, Baccana, RoWen, AlBi.
A Lucy Doll For Christmas by HoneyFlower15
K+, Romance & Humor, chapters: 1 (complete)
Summary: It's Christmas time at Fairy Tail and while everyone is enjoying the holiday Lucy is stuck inside a doll. The girls try to help her but Happy steals the doll and gives it to Natsu. Lucy soon learns a few interest things about Natsu on this Christmas. Nalu
The Twelve Days of Christmas by Grizzly98
T, Romance & Humor, chapters: 12 (complete)
Summary: It's twelve days until Christmas eve and Lucy finds a package. In the package is a bracelet and a note signed by a Secret Santa. Lucy must take the twelve days, notes, and gifts and find out who it is. Will she figure it out or will she lose the one person who loves her more than all the stars in the sky? Co-op with XSteleAliniax. Loosely based on the movie.