The British Empire: Is Ignorance Bliss?
Virtually a lifelong New Yorker, Anil Jethmal lived in India for four years, studying at Bombay’s Campion School. When he resumed his studies in New York, he was struck by the very different lens through which history was taught.
When a young Anil Jethmal first heard of the British empire and Winston Churchill spoken of in glowing terms in his New York school, he thought that he had misheard. After, all, he was well aware of the evil atrocities that the British had committed in colonial India. Anil learned in his Indian school days that a poverty-stricken England arrived on India’s shores in 1757 when India was one of the richest countries in the world. By the time Britain was driven out some 200 years later, 90% of Indians were living below the poverty line, the average life expectancy was 27 years old and the population had a 17% literacy rate.
The reason, Anil Jethmal was taught, was that England governed India simply for their own self-interest. During that shameful two centuries, through violence, racism and looting, Britain extracted, in today’s real terms, tens of trillions of dollars from India. In fact, the Hindi noun “loot” meaning wealth was bastardized into a verb by the British, meaning to steal other’s wealth.
And after Britain destroyed India’s dominant industries such as textiles, steel and shipbuilding by maiming workers, destroying the tools of their crafts and imposing tariffs and duties, they were able to impoverish over 30 million. Having no other choice than to starve to death, these 30 million Indians worked, virtually as slaves, in indentured servitude in the UK and its far-off colonies.
Simultaneously, another 35 million Indians died in British induced famines (the British claim the number is between 15-29 million). In fact, Winston Churchill, who tellingly said “I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion” showed his hatred for Indians in a manner that draws comparisons to Hitler, Stalin and Mao. In 1943, Churchill seized food supplies from Bengal leaving 4.3 million people to die from starvation. The seizure of these essential supplies was simply to add to reserve stockpiles for Churchill’s future planned invasion of Greece and Yugoslavia after World War II ended. When informed that million of Indians were literally dying on the street as a direct result of his actions, Churchill callously replied “It’s their own fault anyway for breeding like rabbits”. He added, “The starvation of anyway underfed Bengalis matters much less than that of sturdy tommies”.
Yet, to this day, Anil Jethmal hears Brits ignorantly sing the praises of Winston Churchill and of the British empire. The reason is very simple. Just as a communist or fascist country suppresses and alters its shameful behavior for public consumption, so too has the UK. Even to this day, the British do not teach unvarnished colonial history in its schools. In fact, one can study “A” levels at the most prestigious universities in the country and not learn a line of colonial history. What is more, in London, a city that is littered with museums, there is not a single museum dedicated to British colonial history. In fact, those very same museums, veritable thieves’ markets (chor bazaar in Hindi), proudly display their purloined loot without any mention of how and from where those items were stolen.
To this point, former schoolmate, Shashi Tharoor, quipped at a debate at the Oxford Union, “No wonder the sun never set on the British empire….because even God couldn’t trust the English in the dark”.
Humor aside, for Anil Jethmal, the UK needs to finally step out of the dark, needs to stop living in the shadows and needs to acknowledge, teach and disseminate the evil atrocities of the British empire past. Only then can they, with a straight face, lay claim to the virtues of being a true democracy going forward.











