Adored the new m9 episode, and was especially tickled by getting to see Caleb's backstory animated, mostly because it doesn't sugarcoat the fact that teenaged Caleb was fully evil.
Often when I see his backstory discussed in fandom, it's viewed in a very tragic light: he was just a poor child manipulated by an evil man :( it wasn't his fault :( poor Caleb carrying all that trauma :(. What this point of view fails to acknowledge is that, though he was young, he was old enough to have agency over his own choices and actions. He is no more innocent of the acts of torture and murder he committed than any real life teenager seduced into radicalized ideologies. He wasn't mind controlled or even threatened into doing any of that. He believed in it. Ultimately, yes, Trent is the one at fault for preying on vulnerable teenagers, and his students were very much abused under his care (that scene with the residuum is gonna stay with me, man), but Caleb, Astrid, and Eadwulf were not innocent in their actions.
And it's especially beautiful when paralleled with Essek! Others have already pointed out the delicious parallel of Caleb betraying family for the sake of his nation, while Essek betrayed his nation for the sake of family, but it's more than that (to me). From corners of fandom that really hate Essek and view him as irredeemable but who still like Caleb, I've seen the sentiment that while Caleb considers himself and Essek very similar, to these viewers Caleb was innocent (due to his young age and Trent's manipulation) in a way Essek was not. But Caleb wasn't innocent. He was a young man seduced by nationalistic propaganda and power into committing atrocities. Seeing his and Essek's stories played out on screen in detail, this becomes undeniable. And it's delicious.


















