Why I Don’t Ship Wolfstar - A List
- The Marauders loved each other equally. They were there for each other thick and thin. They all would have died for each other. For Pete’s sake, they even loved Peter and he wasn’t nearly as good as them in so many ways. By making Sirius and Remus love each other romantically, it ruins their equal love.
- One of the best things about the Marauders is how they loved each other like girl best friends. We don’t see this often, but of course, when we do see affectionate and loyal male friends, they are shipped together and ruined. Because guys can’t love each other platonically???
- Sirius played that disgusting prank on Remus. Sirius knew that Remus already thought he was a monster. Imagine what would have happened if James hadn’t of stepped in. Remus would have become a murder and he wouldn’t have been able to live with himself.
- Even if Remus and Sirius had dated at Hogwarts, IT WOULD HAVE BEEN AWKWARD AS HELL. My best friend, who is literally Padfoot likes her, and my best friend who a mix of Prongs and Moony - and it is not fun. It’s really weird and awkward. The friendship that they have was weakened significantly. All the headcanons say that James is the No.1 Wolfstar shipper, but he’d hate it. Like just no.
- Remus and Sirius lived without each other four 12 years. 12 years of also thinking the other betrayed them. There’s no way that’s love. If they were in love, they wouldn’t have been able to accept it. They would have said it was Peter.
- They ruin Remus’ character. Remus is not some, dirty, thirsty seductive hot dude who confidently snogs Sirius in the Common Room. Remus was insecure, secretive and humble. The headcanons turn Remus into a nerdy Sirius.
- The downright disturbing headcanons where Remus takes advantage of Tonk’s metamorphism in the bedroom. It's just so wrong on so many levels.
- REMUS HAD A WIFE AND SON. No more information needed.