Could I ask you something? What made you choose to do a PhD in English lit despite all the problems with jobs in academia? I’m honestly asking because I’m in the position where I need to chose where I want to go for masters, and I’m lost. 😣😔
Well first of all, I’m actually not getting my PhD in English Lit - my PhD is in American Studies and I actually am much more closely affiliated with African-American Studies. Second of all, I am working class and Irish and first gen and disabled and femme and bi and all of the things that make it so this next part might seem ridiculous but... a PhD IS a job. I currently HAVE a job in academia. If I wasn’t doing this I would have to do something else and I would almost certainly like it less. So why not do a job I like for five years? Plenty of rich people do things they enjoy without the expectation of taking it further. With that being said, I do intend to take it further if I can. I am an excellent scholar. My work is timely and important and beautiful. There might not be a lot of jobs out there but there will always be SOME. I am also working in a field that is actually expanding and hiring more people rather than contracting. I think there is a general and lamentable movement to paint the humanities as obsolete/the least “useful” of subjects but this just isn’t something I engage with because, to me, it is so obviously flawed and false. I am pretty confident I will get some kind of job after my degree, even if it’s not a teaching job, and it will be a job that is much better than what I could have got without it. You can do lots of things with a PhD other than teach.
TL:DR: Basically, I think people who tell working class people that “there are no jobs in academia” miss three crucial facts:
1. A PhD IS a job in academia
2. Working class people are allowed to do things for fun just like rich people and not everything has to have a capitalistic “purpose”
3. The reality is that you will get a better job with a PhD than without one and anyone who says otherwise lives in a privileged dream world where they were already in contact with the right people and in line for the right jobs and have a MUCH higher ceiling for an “acceptable” or “good” salary than someone like me who grew up in poverty has
(my insta is @phdoingmydamnbest and I talk about all this and more on there if you’re interested)
















