META TO ME ABOUT JON AND YGRITTE AND THAT LAST MOMENT THEY SAW EACH OTHER BEFORE SOMEONE DIED. FULL COURSE. CHILD, JON ACCEPTING FATE, BROKEN TRUST, THE WHOLE SHEBANG
this is a cruel thing to do, Melody. but in this house we’re not cowards and we die like wolves, so let me grab my ASOIAF books and get started. and get started by mentioning a fact that should be obvious, and yet the fandom sometimes ignores it far too easily: Ygritte is an essential pillar in Jon Snow’s character development. she’s the one who makes him start challenging and questioning his beliefs about the free folk but also about the world in general, and her points of view have such impact that, in almost every chapter after her death (and especially after he’s elected as lord commander, aka when he starts making decisions), Jon reminisces about her and wonders what she would have thought of what he’s doing. he clearly values her opinions and perspectives, even when he does not agree with them.
which, granted, is obnoxiously downplayed in the show, where Ygritte is little more than the crazy ex trope. yes, even in the books their relationship had a shaky start and the lines of consent were blurred on occasion — Jon literally had to start sleeping with Ghost to prevent her from sneaking under his furs overnight. the way i personally see it, however, i don’t believe this was because he did not want her or did not feel attracted to her — on the contrary, because he was well aware of his potential reactions and, at that point, he was still determined to live through Mance’s camp without breaking a single vow; hence, wanting to keep her as far away as possible, as to not be tempted. all this to say that book!Ygritte is SO much more than just Jon’s love interest. she’s clever, she’s courageous, she’s honorable in the free folk way, she’s strong, she’s willful, she’s funny, she’s spirited, she’s bold. but she is also sweet and nurturing and caring, and let’s not forget that, when eagle!Orell knocked Jon down his garron, Ygritte immediately stepped in and stood in front of him to protect him from further harm. yes, she’s no damsel in distress and she’s not a proper lady AND she doesn’t need to be.
but all of this was a little introduction for context, also because everyone knows at this point i ramble a lot i my metas. their last moments were done slightly differently in show and books, and this is one of those times i don’t really have a favorite between the two versions — the show had Jon watching it live for shock value, as usual, but i don’t think it ruined it in the slightest, this time. i only lament they had to resort to Olly, once more, as sacrificial lamb and plot device, but i won’t digress. one thing is common to both versions, and it is the fact Jon felt terrible with himself for what he had to do. which, again, is also why he tried so hard not to get involved with Ygritte, because he knew there would be no future for them; he knew that, no matter how much he loved her (and, boy, if he did — Jon is canonically described by Sam by not smiling again after Ygritte’s death), he would always end up picking his duty over her — over his own happiness and self-interest. which is why i believe, in the show version, he was 100% ready to die during this moment, and would actually welcome it for thinking Ygritte had the right to take his life, after his betrayal. and props to Kit, because he’s an amazing actor and D&D rarely give him chance to prove this, because have you seen the little smile he pulls? do you see how bittersweet it is, how relieved in a way? how this smile basically tells her: go ahead and do it, it’s meant to be.
in the books, on the other hand, Jon doesn’t watch it happen, but the guilt component is the same — it’s actually a lot more explicit because, obviously, books allow for much more introspection.
the arrow was black, Jon saw, but it was fletched with white duck feathers. not mine, he told himself, not one of mine. but he felt as it were.
what does this tell us? that, as soon as he found Ygritte after Styr’s attack on Castle Black, the immediate thing he did was to check the arrow in her chest, to see if it was his — to see if he’d killed her himself. and, even when he rationally realized it couldn’t have been him, that does nothing to change the guilt. because, if it wasn’t for him, if he’d not met her and grown close to her and fallen in love with her, she might not have to die; she might never have climbed the Wall, she might never have fallen in battle. wrong to love her, wrong to leave her. he did what he did for the sake of his duty, for the sake of his black brothers (the same brothers who rewarded him with at least four daggers in the dark but, again, i digress), and still he can’t help but feel guilty for the death of the woman he loved.
what do we see during those last moments, then? a whole big lot of ambivalence, a whole big lot of anguish and despair. he knows he had no choice, he knows he did his duty, he knows she’s technically an enemy, he knows that dying in battle is a suitable death for a spearwife — but he’s just a human being, and he breaks and shatters all the same. he desperately does not want Ygritte to die, he’s willing to go and beg maester Aemon to heal a wildling back to health, and even the vows and honor be damned for a moment — because he tells her they’ll go back to that cave, and with this he means that none of what they lived together was a mistake and none of it was a lie, despite his own lying. he did love her, he did want to be with her, but alas this isn’t always enough and much less in Westeros. and she dies in his arms, and returns in his dreams a couple times in future chapters, where it is always him killing her. because that’s what it felt like. because, in the end, he still knows nothing.
ps — just a final little remark about how i believe Ygritte was pregnant when she died. first, because it is canon, in the books, that they had sex at least half a hundred times before even the iconic cave scene — and, unless Jon was extremely skilled at pulling out, this is more than enough chances to conceive a baby. yes, Ygritte could have easily gotten moon tea to drink if she wanted — however, we have zero information about this as far as i am aware, thus it’s a 50-50 chance whether she did it or not. and, of course, there’s Jon’s dream soon after returning to Castle Black, about himself and Ygritte making love in the pools of warm water (ideal metaphor for a womb imo) by the weirwood in Winterfell, and how she eventually dissolved into a pool of blood — which, if we consider GRRM’s love for prophecies and foreshadowing, can plausibly be taken as symbolism for the loss of a baby, in the case through the mother’s own death.