@beautifulsmilewiththosesadeyes reblogged your post and added:
I don’t think she knows honestly… if that is the treasure of T.I. and she knows its location, then the book doesn’t make any sense!
@jadedbirch replied to your post “yasae replied to your post “My thoughts on 4x01”...”
She might be lying. Please let her be lying.
@bal-lantine reblogged your post and added:
#or ya know #what if silver didn’t tell her?#what if she’s just saying so because she thinks he’s gone#and wants to cement her position within the group?#she may have no clue#she’s a tactician like the rest of them (via @thewalruscaptain)
Oh, man, I’d LOVE this^^ because it’d be so damn clever and also signifies that despite her grief, Madi’s going to fight the fuck on.
But if John really did tell her the location, I’m not sure if I read that as a betrayal of Flint. I can see John, in the early days of the alliance with the maroon camp, deciding that it was the smart thing to do to cement trust between he and Madi.
#though there is the question that he didn't tell Flint he'd told her...
@char7 reblogged your post and added:
There’s also the possibility that Madi was lying. She doesn’t like or trust Flint, she sees Flint is about to reclaim power by reminding that only he knows where the cache is, so she bluffs and claims she knows, too. It also diffuses the argument between Billy and Flint. Smart move from a smart lady.
@ moonykink reblogged your post and added:
Tbh, I don’t think Silver actually said Madi the location. That seems too big? Ok they’re together but there are still too personal stuff. And betray the trust of others as simply… I think she bluffs.
Yeah the more I’m thinking about it, the more I agree that she was buffling. It actually seems out of character for me that Silver would tell Madi without telling Flint, not when he was that worried about the previous night about his relationship with him and about them being equals.
Regarding TI, I don’t know, I think the location of the treasure has to be changed at some point bc otherwise why would Silver need a map in TI, also that apparently in TI Flint buried the treasure with 6 others and then killed those others. Though given the case, why would he give the map to fucking Billy of all people, unless does a Peter Ashe and lies trough his teeth and Flint never gave him the map inwhich case... lallalalalala Treasure Island what is treasure island never heard of that, you meant oranges, right, oranges
but yeah i’m more and more convinced that Madi lied to get an advantage, to have power fo the situation bc silver was the glue that kept all of them together and omg that was a beautiful thing to write. also i’m bringing in @coldwarcynicide because we discussed a lot about it.
