oh you weren't kidding when you said Wentworth writers can't concieve (and write) Joan as anything but a cartoonish sketch thrown from one extreme to another... the soap I was prepared for, but I'm not sure what was more frustrating - the failed attempt at adding nuance (??) to her character, or the fact that they put things I've wanted to see in her actual self in the mouth of this version of her
Legit, it’s awful, right? It’s really clear that they can’t conceive of her as a whole person with multiple facets, somebody who simultaneously has vulnerability and also an enormous capacity for cruelty. I feel like it really speaks to a buried lesbophobic element in the show’s writing (which also comes blazing to life in how Juice is written), with how deliberately and explicitly Joan is written as a lesbian predator (I know I’ve kind of ranted about this before but the way her characterization incorporates elements from serial killer popular mythology really makes for a compelling argument that she is “male-coded”, which in a way just means “lesbian”) as well as a hatred of certain kinds of mental illness--the show can handle and try to be sensitive to depression, i.e. in Bea’s storyline, but can’t deal with more stigmatized things like OCD, hallucinations, and psychosis. In fact I remember having a conversation a very long time ago with other fans about how for us, Joan’s mental illness was a humanizing element of her character which made us identify more with her, whereas the show’s writers used her disorder to dehumanize and other her. And now they’re trying to backtrack and retroactively embed a sympathy for the character that’s never before existed in the text (outside of probably a few individual moments in s2 and s3) because they’ve realized that she’s one of the most, if not the most interesting on the show and the reason viewers are coming back lol