Hey Pals! I’m Mod Liyah and I love history, queer and black history specifically. As such I feel I need to put somethings to rest. Recently on tumblr.com there has been some discourse around the terms butch and femme. There has also been discourse around the terms doe, tomcat and stag.
We have received some asks telling us to look into the history of wlw and that’s what I’m here to do. So let’s get into it.
Firstly, from a historical standpoint the terms butch and femme have been used by ALL LGBTQ+ people. Especially the term femme.
I got some sources from a few queer news sources here, here and here that are specifically about the use of the word femme and how different queer people feel about the term.
Here and here are some sources about the history of the word butch and how different queer people feel about the term.
I encourage you to read the articles and watch the videos (because they are really good and very thorough) they are also very good explanations of how, yes these terms have deep roots in the lesbian community (specifically working class lesbian communities) but how other LGBTQ+ people have popularly used them to describe their relationships with gender and sexuality.
Also there has always been controversy around the use of them.
At one time, during the rise of feminism, these terms were considered to play into the gender binary and were thought of as being counter productive to both the advancement of women’s rights and also the advancement of LGBTQ+people.
As we all know these terms DO NOT do this and have since then come back into popularity and queer people continually use them.
With all this in mind it is important to remember that the discourse we are seeing now isn’t new or unique to tumblr or even the LGBTQ+ community as a whole.
Now that we have the history laid out. Let’s get into what this means for bi people and specifically bi women.
In the crafting of this post I aimed to look up the history of the terms doe, tomcat, stag and the other bi terms that we are currently using.
And here’s the thing. There is no history. because history implies the past and we are not the past, we are the present.
Bi people are making history right now by making these terms for ourselves and we deserve to. Not because we need to divorce ourselves for a history that clearly involves us but because we want to find solidarity in our own community.
I think a lot of people are angry about these terms because they find them to be divisive but they aren’t.
Honestly, my point here is that although all queer people have a history with the terms butch and femme i think we have to also understand that lesbians very specifically have a connection with the word and that’s okay.
I think, (and I mean me specifically mod liyah’s opinion) we have to honor our collective history by not gatekeeping words that we all have a history with and maybe letting people identify and find solace in the words that they feel comfortable using.
Whether those terms are doe, tomcat, stag, femme or butch, we all have a on-going, ever evolving history with them and maybe we should just be mindful and respectful of that.
Sharing is Caring and at the end of the day we’re all queer here.