Sorry if I sounded condescending. It's just I'm in high school and most of my friends love it when the teacher points them out so I was pretty confused. Thanks for explaining it to me! 😄
Okay I’m glad, because I was like oh shiiiiit when I saw that. Thanks for being nice about it!
It isn’t that I dislike being praised (who doesn’t like being praised?), it’s that I’m rightfully uncomfortable to be put in the spotlight by a teacher without my permission. If he had even just said (and some teachers have in the past), “Do you mind if I use your essay as an example?” that would be a different situation, and I would have the opportunity to say “That’s fine, but I would rather it be anonymous.”
Teachers in my experience have done similar things too; they’ll post example past essays, but they usually get rid of the name of the student. Grades aren’t taboo, and lots of people within the classroom readily share them so we can either commiserate or celebrate with them, but that should be the person’s conscious choice.
It’s like if at a meeting, an employer jumped up and announced, “Edye does an AMAZING job! Out of all of you guys, she gets a raise of $20! If she can perform that well and get that high of a raise you guys should too!” I mean, how are people not supposed to kind of resent me?
The way that my prof presented it too had very strong undertones of Edye is better than all of you, and you are all stupid and need to work harder. Your goal in this class is now to compete with this single student, whose grades I am sharing with all of you. So, that’s why I consider it inappropriate, and why the administration of schools I’ve attended generally frown upon that kind of behavior.
(Also, somebody just commented on the original post saying that if they were a student in the class they would feel jealous and resentful and sad. Which is one of my main points.)









