i would generally agree w/ you (ppl should always be transparent about this sort of thing just as a good rule of thumb) there’s some complication with the etsy pages that folks might not know about. on etsy you basically have to mark something as either vintage or handmade. so just primarily, no one should ever be doing dropshipping on etsy at all. people still do it, but it’s fucked up and they should stop--it basically wrecks etsy’s whole purpose as a marketplace full of different, unique stuff you can’t find elsewhere. i’ve not seen her etsy pages but if she’s selling dropshipped items on there as well she should really stop. it’s something she could get reported for and her shop taken down.
there’s another bit of weirdness, though: etsy has instated a weird measure for adding your manufacturers to your page but you have to go through a detailed process of registering them which is something that they need to go through on their end as well. they also currently ONLY accept manufacturers within the US and canada, so if you’re a seller outside of north america you are pretty much forced into a lie, or if you ever ship your stuff out for any reason. and etsy can shut down your shop if it finds out you haven’t registered your shit, as well. the guidelines that they have listed for manufacturers are obviously good ones (no child labor, safe disposal of chemical waste, etc) BUT i don’t even know a local mom&pop embroidery shop in the tiny town i live in that would take the time to go through etsy’s form system for one client. or when you start getting into much larger manufacturers, like if you were someone who gets your stuff done w/ print all over me or someone like zazzle where their operation is HUGE. no one’s going to do that for you, it’s just bonkers.
i know etsy is trying to 1. say that all it’s shit is ethical (which y’all might already know my issues with all that as a concept vis a vis feasibility) which is a good goal and all but a lot harder in practice and 2. set up this network where anyone online could go through a big network of manufacturers to get their stuff made to sell it but like it’s something that is a lot easier said than done. and like, punishing your user base (where u make all yr money!) for not being able to get these companies to sit down to fill out an etsy form seems like a real garbage solution.
i agree tho, overall. there’s no transparency on her site about what is original and what isn’t, and what is manufactured versus handmade (which i think is helpful info to know just for pricing purposes) and the fact that i saw several people in their complaints talking about how the shop says it’s based in the US but nothing came from the US is just like, all general transparency issues. giving folks basic information and building trust w/ your customer base is essential!