Hey look its some poly!Erasermic headcanons that nobody asked for :3c
If Yamada is the energy in the relationship, then Aizawa is surely the sensibility. He easily balances out most mischief you and Yamada might get yourselves in, if only because he doesn’t want the two of you to get yourselves into any definite trouble--he already has enough to deal with when it comes to his own students.
The majority of the time, Yamada is the more physically affectionate of the two of them, often more than happy to kiss, hug or hold you even if he’s at work. Aizawa is a little more reserved in public displays of affection, but he’s not cold. He often makes little remarks to both you and Yamada, but he means it only in jest. “The two of you act like lovestruck high schoolers.” Plot twist: Aikawa often feels like a lovestruck high schooler when he sees either of you, even if he isn’t the most audible about those feelings.
Due to Aizawa’s more subtle approach to the relationships, there’s a long period of time where his students actually think that you’re having an affair with him--after all, Yamada is far more open about being with you, so what does that make Aizawa? It isn’t until one of them (IIda) brings it to the attention of the principle that, hilariously, he has to explain to the class that he’s in a relationship with both you and Yamada.
It takes like a week for them to get over it. On at least three occasions they asked if you three were going to get married. While you personally enjoyed the student’s positive enthusiasm for their teacher’s loving relationship, it only put Aizawa in a sour mood for a few days, if only because he didn’t like so much attention put on it. God forbid he actually start wearing a wedding band in class, he’d never be able to get a lesson in without the entirety of the student body in class 1-A trying to ask about it and learn more about you.
In terms of being romantic, both of the men are rather equally matched, though they show their romantic nature in different ways. While Yamada is far less ashamed or bothered by social correctness or being embarrassed by going all-out to surprise you with a gift, Aizawa is much fonder about subtle, private moments between the three of you. Secret vacations and quiet dinners are much more his style of things, especially since it means there’s a far less chance that the three of you will impromptu get yanked into taking in a villain they encountered somewhere in the city, knowing their luck.














