AU headcanons: I ordered a fancy custom cake with something really weird on it and you're the baker AU for the rarepair of your choice?
woke up this morning to this little headcanon list in the notes app on my phone and i only vaguely remember writing it lmao. i took out the typos but other than that, here's 1am-me's thoughts on this au:
alex and willie run a bakery together and they do a ton of custom cake designs. reggie is their taste tester and he also designed a handy little form for on their website that customers can fill out with custom cake info
bobby lives relatively nearby with luke, his infuriating best friend who is obsessed with alex and willie’s cakes. whenever bobby has a message he really wants to get across, he’ll have them put it on a cake. also, he likes the cakes too
sometimes the messages are serious (if you don't stop leaving dirty socks on the floor i'm kicking you out) and sometimes they're just as much of the bee movie script as can fit in the box on the form
alex and willie haven’t met bobby beyond when he’s picking up the cakes and because it’s usually so crowded in the bakery, they haven’t had the opportunity to ask about any of them. they’re both fascinated by bobby’s random messages, a little scared of the aggressiveness in some, and also find the whole cake messages as a way of communication to be kind of very adorable
they also just find bobby cute
they put notes on the cake box to thank bobby for his orders and stuff. bobby replies to them in his reviews of their bakery. there's an entire thread of theories about the good place scattered between cakes, cake boxes, and the reviews
one day, bobby orders a cake that requests them to put the lyrics to rick astley’s never gonna give you up on it. it’ll be a cake-shaped rickroll
but he forgot to fill in what flavour the cake should be, which gives willie and alex the opportunity to call him (the phone number is included on the form but they’ve never had a proper reason to call and they’re Professionals who wouldn’t abuse such knowledge), and of course, before they say anything, willie plays the song over speaker to rickroll bobby
the cake will be chocolate chip. alex and willie will deliver it right before they pick up bobby for their first date
send me an au and i’ll give you 5+ headcanons about it!












