Just wanted to let you know that your blog (mainly the great essays on why Sly 4 was a sexist mess) is what lured me back to Tumblr after abandoning it over a year ago due to the toxicity of the userbase. I wrote essays and drew parody comics to illustrate my problems with Sly 4 back when the game was new. And a lot of folks who disagreed with me couldn't do so without also lobbing personal attacks. It's a relief to see that the fandom has calmed down on that front and blogs like yours exist
Oh hey! You’re the one who drew that great two-panel comic comparing Sly lecturing Tsao about Respecting Women to how he and Bentley force Carmelita into degrading herself. I love that, it so concisely and sharply shows how drastic the change is
I’d say that after almost six years, opinion has shifted. I’m honestly glad I wasn’t active in the fandom in 2013, because the earliest arguments are always the most vicious. Fans are often resistant to admitting the flaws of a hyped-up release (coughPhantomMenacecough). Nowadays, Sly 4 is still kind of an open wound, with people loving it or hating it or falling somewhere in between.
But when I set up shop here and began complaining, no-one attacked me on a personal level. There was a few months of posts going up like “I wish people wouldn’t be so critical of Thieves in Time :///”, and considering the size of the fandom, I am 100% sure I’m the ‘people’ that caused those posts. And the idea I was treading on someone’s favourite game didn’t feel nice, but it wasn’t a direct confrontation. More defensive than offensive.
And every time I criticize this game for its sexism, I get a chorus of agreement.
Again, that ties in to what I’ve been saying lately about not wanting to leave Tumblr! Here I can say the basic, inarguable, true fact “Sly 4 does not treat its female characters well”, and responses range from “yes!!!!!!!!!!!” to “Well, that’s true, but…” There’s a basic level of agreement that, like, the bellydance scene and the Penelope twist etc were bad ideas
if i use the words “sexism” and “video games” in the same breath on twitter i will be shot on sight by the brave heroes of gamergate