As mentioned a couple weeks back, I finally opened my copy of Buffalo Castle for a playthrough now that I have the rules. Let's check in and see how that's going... Our first band to dare the Castle's magic doors, which admit only one brave and foolish soul at a time: Dash, human warrior – killed by an evil warrior Double Daggers, hobbit rogue – turned to stone by a mystery woman Ampersand, human rogue – fell into a pit, too clumsy to climb out, killed by an ogre Pilcrow, dwarf warrior – killed by a troll Dash had the best go of it, defeating her first foe, "an evil looking character in leather armor," winning some treasure, and escaping the dungeon to buy better armor. Alas, on her second foray, she dared to battle the evil looking guy's older brother, and was slain. Eventually. One of Tunnels & Trolls' noted quirks is that battles between evenly matched opponents have a tendency to drag on... and on... and on. D&D's d20 roll to hit has a linear probability, so combat can be swingy, especially since armor's defensive value is abstracted into the chances to hit. By contrast, T&T uses a throw of multiple six-sided dice for combat and potential damage. If you beat your opponent(s) roll you score the amount over in damage. Since rolls of multiple dice tend to clump at the top of the probability curve, and armor in T&T soaks up damage from successful hits, well...some T&T fights drag on like the battles of Arthurian legend: "AND then thus they fought till it was past noon, and never would stint, till at the last they lacked wind both; and then they stood wagging and scattering, panting, blowing and bleeding, that all that beheld them for the most part wept for pity....Thus they endured till evensong time, that there was none that beheld them might know whether was like to win the battle." Only with a lot more dice rolling. But, getting back to brave Dash, finally, after an exhausting battle (and the introduction of cobbled together unofficial rules for spite damage), she was whittled down to a fatal point. RIP, Dash. Buffalo Castle session report #1 Liz Danforth, lettering and illustration Rick Loomis, text Buffalo Castle Sir Thomas Malory, text Le Morte d'Arthur