butcher reassuring hughie "i gave you no choice" and "i wasn't gonna stop" when he WAS RELEASING THE TRIGGER because he doesn't want hughie to feel bad stop it stop it NOW
Reader who could have a chihuahua, labrador, or great dane and still be treating them each like kings, regadress of size. Her dog, Riley, is an irish setter and the prettiest girl ever. Reader firmly believes that the diet she feeds her is the reason why her coat is so shiny and silky.
So when she moves to a new town, she has to find a new butcher that's willing to give her the cheap pieces that couldn't sell. The one in her last city was a kind woman who also had a dog and understood. She always put her scraps together for Reader every couple nights.
So she has three options, a commercial butcher company, a mom and pop shop, and another simple one located beside a deli and bakery.
The last one is the closest, and she knew she could use the bakery pretty often as well. So it was settled. On thursday evening she walked into the shop, maybe twenty five minutes from closing.
The butcher wasnt infront of the counter when she walked in, so she looked around to see what his selling meat looked like. A couple of minutes later, Simon clears his throat to get her attention.
"O-oh Hello!"
The man was huge. Like a bodybuilder wearing an apron covered in blood. He was sorta scary, and she was very much regretting choosing this shop.
"Uhm. Im not sure if you'll have what i need, actually. Thanks!!" She tries to cover her ass and walk away, but the butcher laughs loudly.
"Well, you've got to tell me what you need, birdie." His voice was deep and raspy, gruff like he didn't use it much. "Got lotsa stuff in the back i keep for my... special customers"
She would blush and turn back around, nervously walking back to the counter. "Uh i just moved here, from wales, so i needed a new regular butcher because i have a generally weird request." Ramble ramble ramble.
Simon would raise his brow and look inpatient at first but got a smirk on his face after he realized how nervous she was.
"Spit it out, birdie."
"I uh, I need some scrap meats for my dog. She gets fed completely human food, and i need to have a place i can go to regularly to rely on."
It wasn't even the weirdest request he's gotten before. He's been asked if he could cook the meat for people or if he sold carcasses, so scraps for your dog? That's nothing.
"Easy peasy love. Let me get some things together for you." And she just beamed at him, all the anxiety running away from her body in favor of graditude.
He'd ask her what her puppies' favorite meats were as he was grabbing selling containers. She'd tell him that Riley wasn't fussy, as long as she got her meat. And Simon froze.
"Riley, huh?" He'd laugh. "Me and your girl got matching names" and she'd crack a smile. He wasnt so scary after all.
After a few minutes of Simon being in his back room, he came back with four containers of chopped meat. Each container had a title on it like 'beef: tounge, heart' 'organs: liver, kidney,' etc.
"Thank you so much. This will be perfect. How much do i owe you?" Simon smirked.
"Nah, dont need nothing love wasnt gonna sell this anyway. Just promise to come back next time that puppy needs some meat, aye?"
!The Boys overhear you having sex with (Character).
Butcher
You two barely made it through the door. His lips were on yours instantly, nipping at your lower lip with that sharp hunger that always left you dizzy. Before you could even catch your breath, Butcher had you pinned against the bed, hands rough and greedy—tugging at clothes, gripping your hips, sliding up your thighs like he couldn’t get you bare fast enough.
The old bed creaked loudly beneath you as he slowly lowered himself into you, thick and unrelenting. You gasped sharply, mouth falling open in a perfect, silent O, eyes fluttering shut at the stretch. He eased in inch by inch, deliberate and deep, a low, guttural groan rumbling from his chest the whole way. No words. Just the wet, slick sound of him sinking into you, your shaky exhale, and the way your nails dug into his back as you braced yourself.
In the next room, the boys were trying—very, very hard—to pretend they weren’t hearing every single second of it.
Hughie’s face burned scarlet, eyes glued to the floor like it might split open and swallow him whole. MM rubbed his temples hard, jaw clenched tight, muttering under his breath about “goddamn animals.” Frenchie leaned back with a smirk, cigarette dangling from his lips, one eyebrow raised in quiet amusement. Kimiko tilted her head, watching the wall with calm, fascinated curiosity, like she was listening to a particularly interesting song.
Another loud, broken moan ripped from your throat—high and desperate—as Butcher hit that perfect spot deep inside you, making your toes curl tight. The bedframe slammed harder against the wall now, rhythmic and violent. His grunts turned rougher, deeper, almost animalistic snarls every time you clenched around him, the wet slap of skin on skin growing louder.
“Christ,” MM finally hissed, voice low and strained. “They’re not even trying to be quiet.”
Frenchie exhaled a slow curl of smoke, soft laugh slipping out. “I do not think they remember we exist right now.”
Hughie made a strangled little noise and yanked his hoodie up over his head like that could possibly block out the sounds—your whimpers climbing higher, Butcher’s heavy, ragged breathing, the relentless creak and thud of the bed.
Back in the room, your legs were trembling violently around his waist, voice cracking into soft, needy whimpers as he fucked you through it, hips snapping with raw, primal force. His breathing was harsh and uneven against your neck, each thrust punctuated by a deep, guttural groan that vibrated through your chest.
One last, wrecked “fuck” tore from him—low and desperate—right as you shattered. Your high, trembling moan spilled out, raw and broken, mixing perfectly with his deep, satisfied growl as pleasure crashed through both of you. The bed finally stilled, the only sounds left being your shared, panting breaths.
Silence—blessed, mortifying silence—settled for half a second.
Then Frenchie’s voice drifted through the thin wall, dry as bone:
“…Well. At least someone’s having a good night.”
You buried your burning face in Butcher’s sweat-slick shoulder, half-laughing, half-mortified at how loud you’d been. He just chuckled darkly against your hair, the sound rough and smug, arms tightening around you possessively.
“Let ‘em listen, love,” he murmured, voice gravelly and low. “Let the whole fuckin’ world hear what you sound like when I ruin you.”
Soldier Boy
The team had only been back at the safehouse for twenty minutes when the noises started.
At first they figured Soldier Boy was just being his usual destructive self—pacing, throwing shit, whatever. But then the bedframe started slamming against the wall in a steady, filthy rhythm. Loud. Unmistakable.
“What the hell is he doing now?” MM muttered, already heading toward the hallway.
Then it hit them: a sharp, breathy gasp—feminine, surprised, melting quickly into a soft, needy moan as the creaking intensified.
The room went dead quiet.
Hughie blinked hard. “Wait… there’s a girl in there with him?”
Another moan slipped through the thin walls, higher this time, raw and trembling. The wet slap of skin on skin grew louder, faster, paired with deep, guttural grunts from Soldier Boy—low and arrogant, the kind that said he was enjoying every second of wrecking whoever was under him.
Kimiko tilted her head, listening with quiet curiosity as your voice cracked into a desperate whimper, the bed thudding harder.
MM stopped outside the door, hand raised like he was about to knock and tell the asshole to keep it down—until another broken moan rang out, clearer this time.
That voice.
MM froze.
Hughie’s face went pale. “That… that sounded like—”
Your moan cut him off, loud and shattered, as Soldier Boy hit that spot that made your toes curl and your back arch. The rhythm turned brutal—bedframe cracking against the wall, your high, needy cries mixing with his rough, animalistic groans. No words. Just pure filth: the slick, wet sounds of him pounding into you, your legs shaking, voice climbing higher and more desperate with every thrust.
Frenchie’s cigarette nearly dropped from his lips. “Non… no way. That’s not—”
But it was. The next moan was unmistakable—your voice, raw and trembling, cracking beautifully as you tried and failed to stay quiet.
Hughie looked like he was about to be sick. “Oh my god. That’s… that’s her.
MM’s hand dropped to his side, eyes wide with pure shock. “You’ve gotta be fucking kidding me.”
The pace inside grew frantic. Your whimpers turned into frantic little sobs of pleasure, body jolting with every deep, punishing snap of Soldier Boy’s hips. His grunts got louder, rougher—almost snarls—cocky and satisfied as he fucked you , the headboard slamming like it might break.
Your voice broke on a long, high, trembling cry as you came hard, legs shaking violently around him. Soldier Boy followed with a deep groan, hips stuttering once, twice, before the bed finally went still.
Heavy, ragged breathing filled the sudden silence.
The boys stood frozen in the hallway, stunned into complete silence.
Frenchie was the first to speak, voice hushed and disbelieving. “Putain… it’s really her. With him.”
Hughie pulled his hoodie up over his head like it could erase the last five minutes. “I’m never going to be able to look at her again. Or him. Or… anyone.”
MM just stared at the door, rubbing his temples hard, muttering, “Of all the people… Soldier Boy? What the fuck is she thinking?”
Kimiko’s lips twitched with quiet amusement, shrugging one shoulder as if to say surprise.
Inside the room, you were still catching your breath, face buried against Soldier Boy’s sweat-slick chest, a soft embarrassed laugh bubbling up. He smirked down at you, one big hand lazily stroking your spine, voice low and smug.
“Sounds like the peanut gallery finally figured it out, sweetheart.”
Hughie
You and Hughie had waited until the safehouse felt dead quiet.
The team was supposed to be out for hours, so the second the door clicked shut behind the last person, Hughie had pulled you into his room with that shy, eager grin. Clothes came off fast—his hands a little clumsy with nerves, your laughter soft against his mouth as you tumbled onto the bed together.
He eased into you slowly, careful like always, and the old mattress creaked under you both. You let out a quiet gasp, mouth falling open, fingers digging gently into his shoulders. Hughie answered with a low, shaky groan, burying his face in your neck as he started to move.
No talking. Just soft, breathy sounds—your little moans growing sweeter and higher every time he rolled his hips, his own quiet, desperate grunts mixing with the rhythmic creak of the bed. It felt safe. Private. You didn’t hold back, letting yourself get louder as pleasure built, your voice turning into needy whimpers that made Hughie’s breathing hitch.
The bedframe started knocking gently against the wall. Then harder.
You were both so lost in it—your legs wrapped around his waist, his thrusts getting a little faster, a little deeper—that neither of you heard the front door open.
In the living room, the team had just walked in.
Frenchie stopped mid-step, eyebrows shooting up. MM’s expression shifted from tired to confused. Kimiko tilted her head. Butcher leaned against the wall with a slow, shit-eating grin.
Then your moan floated down the hallway—soft at first, then louder, higher, cracking beautifully as Hughie hit that spot that made your toes curl. The bed was really creaking now, steady and unmistakable, paired with Hughie’s low, embarrassed little grunts that somehow still sounded desperate.
Hughie froze for half a second when he heard voices, but you clenched around him and he couldn’t stop—his hips stuttered, a choked groan slipping out as he kept going, both of you too far gone to quiet down.
“Oh fuck…” Hughie whispered against your skin, mortified, but his body betrayed him with another deep thrust that pulled a high, trembling whimper from your throat.
In the living room, the silence was deafening.
Frenchie’s smirk grew. “Well, well. Little Hughie is not so little after all.”
MM rubbed his face with both hands. “Jesus Christ. They thought we were gone.”
Butcher chuckled darkly, voice carrying just enough. “Sounds like the kid’s finally getting some. About time.”
Your moan peaked—loud, broken, and completely unaware—right as Hughie’s rhythm turned frantic and uneven. His quiet, ragged groans mixed with your shaky cries until you both fell apart together: your high, trembling voice and his deeper, embarrassed moan echoing through the thin walls as the bed finally stilled.
The sudden silence was brutal.
You buried your burning face in Hughie’s chest, whispering a horrified “Oh my god…” while he looked ready to die on the spot, cheeks flaming red.
From the living room came Frenchie’s amused voice, loud and clear:
“Don’t stop on our account, mes amis! We can wait!”
Hughie groaned again—this time purely from embarrassment—and pulled the pillow over both your heads like it could hide you from the entire team.
You could still hear Butcher’s low laugh and MM muttering something about “kids these days” as your heart hammered with pure mortification.
Hughie peeked out from under the pillow, voice small and mortified. “…We are never living this down.”
Frenchie
The safehouse was supposed to be empty tonight — just you and Frenchie. The rest of the team had left for a lead that would supposedly keep them gone until morning. So when Frenchie pulled you into the dimly lit living room instead of his bedroom, you didn’t argue.
He had you bent over the back of the old couch before you could even catch your breath, skirt shoved up around your waist, his jeans barely pushed down his thighs. No slow buildup this time. He slid into you in one smooth thrust, deep and confident, pulling a surprised, breathy moan from your throat.
The couch creaked loudly under the force of that first thrust. You gripped the cushions tight, mouth falling open in a silent cry as he started moving — steady, rolling hips that quickly turned hungry. Soft, needy sounds spilled out of you with every push: little gasps turning into higher, trembling moans that you couldn’t hold back. Frenchie answered with low, raspy groans, the occasional whispered French curse slipping out like a prayer.
No real talking. Just the wet, filthy slap of skin, the rhythmic creak of the couch, and the way your voice kept climbing — broken and desperate every time he angled his hips just right and hit that spot that made your knees weak.
You were so lost in it that neither of you heard the van pull up outside.
The front door opened quietly. The team stepped in, expecting silence… and walked straight into the soundtrack of Frenchie fucking you over the couch.
Your moan rang out — high, raw, and unmistakable — right as he drove in harder. The couch was really moving now, scraping against the floor with every thrust. Frenchie’s breathing had turned rough and primal, deep grunts mixing with your whimpering cries, the wet sounds echoing obscenely in the open room.
Frenchie froze mid-thrust when he heard the footsteps, but his body betrayed him — hips giving one last involuntary roll that pulled a loud, shattered whimper from you.
Butcher stopped dead in the doorway, eyebrows shooting up. “Well, fuck. Didn’t expect a live show in the living room.”
MM turned his head away fast, muttering, “Jesus Christ, Frenchie…”
Hughie looked like he wanted the floor to swallow him. “Oh god… that’s… they’re right there.”
Kimiko tilted her head, a small amused smile tugging at her lips as another desperate moan escaped you — your voice cracking beautifully as Frenchie couldn’t stop himself from giving one more deep thrust.
Frenchie’s face burned, but he stayed buried inside you, one hand still gripping your hip. He let out a breathless, embarrassed laugh against your back.
“Mon dieu… we thought you were gone until morning,” he called out, voice hoarse and thick with accent, trying to sound casual even while he was still pulsing inside you.
Your cheeks were on fire. You hid your face in the couch cushion, mortified, body still trembling around him.
Butcher chuckled low and dirty. “Clearly. Carry on, then. Don’t let us interrupt the romance.”
Frenchie groaned — half embarrassment, half lingering pleasure — and pressed his forehead to your shoulder. He whispered softly against your skin, only for you to hear, “I should have taken you to the roof, chérie…”
The team started awkwardly dispersing toward the kitchen, muttering and laughing under their breath, while you stayed bent over the couch, heart racing, Frenchie still buried deep and trying and failing to stay still.
The embarrassment was overwhelming… but the way he twitched inside you told you he wasn’t entirely sorry.
Homelander
The boys were out chasing another lead, leaving the safehouse quiet for once.
You knew you were making a terrible mistake. You were supposed to be helping them take him down — feeding them intel, staying on the inside. But somewhere along the way the lines had blurred completely. One secret meeting turned into stolen nights, and now here you were: heart racing as “John” slipped through the back door in civilian clothes, no cape, no suit, just that dangerously soft smile that made your stomach flip.
He didn’t waste time. The second the bedroom door clicked shut behind you both, his hands were on you — surprisingly gentle at first, then hungry. He had you on the bed in seconds, clothes pushed aside just enough. When he finally pushed inside you, slow and deep, your head fell back with a shaky gasp, mouth forming a perfect O.
No loud talking. Just breathy, intimate sounds.
Your soft moans filled the small room as he moved — deep, rolling thrusts that made the bed creak steadily beneath you. He groaned low in his throat, the sound almost vulnerable, every time you clenched around him. Your fingers dug into his shoulders, legs wrapping tighter around his waist as the rhythm slowly built.
You were so lost in him — in the way he felt, in the way he whispered your name like a secret — that neither of you noticed the front door opening.
The team had come back early.
They stepped inside quietly, expecting an empty safehouse… until your voice drifted down the hallway.
A soft, needy moan. Then another, higher, trembling.
MM froze. Hughie’s eyes went wide. Frenchie tilted his head, cigarette halfway to his lips. Butcher’s expression darkened instantly.
Then it came — clear, unmistakable, wrapped in a broken whimper:
“John…”
The entire room went ice-cold.
Butcher’s jaw clenched so hard it looked painful. “Did she just—?”
Another moan from you, louder this time, cracking beautifully as Homelander hit that perfect spot deep inside. The bedframe started slamming harder against the wall, the wet, rhythmic slap of skin on skin growing filthier. Your voice kept slipping out — soft cries turning desperate, repeating that name like a prayer:
“John… John—”
Homelander answered with a low, possessive growl, hips snapping faster, the sounds turning primal and urgent. Just raw need as he fucked you deeper, your moans climbing higher and more wrecked with every thrust.
Frenchie exhaled slowly, voice hushed. “Putain… she’s with him. She called him John.”
Hughie looked sick. “She’s supposed to be helping us… and she’s — oh god.”
MM rubbed his face, voice tight with betrayal. “We trusted her.”
Butcher’s eyes were murderous, but he didn’t move — just stood there listening as your high, trembling moan peaked, voice breaking on “John” one last time as you came hard around him. Homelander followed with a deep, satisfied groan, hips stuttering before the bed finally went still.
Silence crashed down.
Then Butcher’s voice cut through the wall, low and dangerous:
“Well, well. Looks like our little mole’s been playing both sides… and enjoying it.”
Inside the bedroom you froze, face buried in Homelander’s neck, horror flooding through you as reality slammed back in. He just smirked against your hair, voice soft and smug, barely above a whisper:
“They heard you moan my name, darling. My real name.”
Your heart hammered with panic and lingering pleasure. The boys were right outside — and they knew everything now.
I'm thinking of expanding the homelander story. She sees him behind their backs vibes.
Update 4/8/26 - Story has been posted (No More Secrets)
