I guess, sometimes, the seers Rose and Terezi think how Rosali's classpect isn't a seer or a witch (before her identity as witch of doom revealed), because her predictions are accurate as their seer powers.
(( Oooooooh yeah xD There's definitely some characters that can't help but feel suspicious about the accuracy of Rosali's classpect...... it doesn't help that for a long time, Rosali still has no memories of the planet she ended up on during Sgrub, especially considering the overall physical state she was in after ascending to God Tier and reuniting with everyone))
Rosali:*standing behind Tavros as she uses her Sylph powers to heal a wound on the back of his head* Aaaaaaand..... There! ^v^ Good as new~
Tavros:*smiles, rubbing his head* Heh, thanks, Rosali....... Thats the last time I trust Vriska to let me kick a football instead of letting me fall.....
Rosali:*nods* I know you and Vriska are slowly starting to get on better terms, but be careful when playing any games with her, okay? You know how she is with whatever games she likes to play.
Tavros: Yeah..... true....... heh, I can see why you never wanted to play any FLARP before when she was involved.... you know, back when she had to feed her Lusus........
Rosali: Yes, but...... that is in the past now. Just be careful, okay, Tavros? I don't want you to get seriously hurt.
Tavros: I know..... *smiles a little* Thanks, Rosali.....
*Meanwhile, from afar, Rose and Terezi were keeping an eye on both Rosali and Tavros from a table they're sitting at, both of them having somewhat suspicious looks on their faces*
Rose:....... I don't get it........ I mean..... if her becoming a Sylph had something to do with her desire to help everyone, and considering how much of a loving person she is, maybe her being the Sylph Of Heart makes sense, but....... she is still a witch...... and she's always been able to accurately predict the future using Tarot, right? So..... why is she a Sylph, and not a Seer, or a Witch class?
Terezi:......... I've been asking myself that same question ever since we all got on this meteor.......
Rose: Hm........ Terezi....... Do you or anyone know at all what her Sburb quest entailed? What challenges she faced, what kind of planet she ended up being assigned?
Terezi:........... None of us know the answer to that. Not even Rosali.
Rose: ?...... What do you mean?
Terezi:...... When we all landed on this meteor, Rosali was....... Well....... Somehow she had lost all memory of the 3 weeks we were all stuck in that game....... and as far as I know, in all the time we've been here, she hasn't been able to recall a single thing, still...... it's..... I don't know, maybe she just suffered severe head trauma, but....... the whole situation just feels..... wrong....... Not to mention the physical state she was in when we all reunited here.
Terezi: I mean, obviously, I couldn't see her actual physical state at that point, but........ I did smell her. She was all covered in dirt, in a bunch of tiny scratches....... not to mention she had this..... aura, I guess, around her that just told me something really fucking bad happened to her........... then out of nowhere, she starts speaking this language that none of us could understand, although, after looking a little into it, I think it was what you humans would call Latin......
Rose: Why...... Why would she know Latin, when you had all just created Earth at that point? Unless on Alternia, Latin was an entirely different language altogether.......
Terezi: I don't know, whatever she said, it honestly didn't seem like she was all there at the time...... then, she passed out, and Kanaya and Aradia took her to the med bay. *pauses, contemplating something for a moment*......... Rose?
Terezi: I'm going to be real with you about something, Seer to Seer...... but what I'm about to tell you stays between us. You'd better fucking swear not to tell anyone, got it?
Rose: Of course. I'm good at keeping secrets, you can tell me.
Terezi:..........*turns her head around, sniffing the air to make sure no one is close enough to listen to them*.........*turns her head to face Rose again* You know that I can accurately tell a Troll's blood color if I'm close enough to smell them..... its how I figured out Karkat's blood color before he told anyone else about it. That said...... when Rosali had that episode of hers, I was close enough to get a good whiff of her, especially considering all the cuts that were on her body...... *pauses*......... And again, don't you dare fucking repeat this to anyone...... but she's not a Burgundy blood.
Rose: ?....... Are you.... saying she might be a mutant? Like Karkat?
Terezi:............ I don't even know if I would put her on the same level as Karkat......... Mutants have the warmest blood and body temperature out of any Troll. But........... Rosali's blood smelled so...... *shudders* Cold..........
Rose:....... Cold? Like Blueblood cold? Purple cold?
Terezi: More than that.... Hell, I've smelled Feferi's blood once........ No one else here has blood that smells as cold as Rosali's..... If anything, she...... smelled like death.......
Rose:*at this point, her face morphs into a look of confusion*.......... Well.... whats her blood color then?
Terezi:.......... Dark, inky smelling pitch black......... *though its subtle, a slight shudder goes through her body*
*Suddenly, Terezi and Rose are startled as 2 teacups are placed in front of them, Rosali having suddenly appeared next to them with a teapot in hand*
Rosali: Oh! Sorry, I didn't mean to startle you two ^v^ I just thought maybe you'd both like some tea? It's Earl Grey~
Rose:........*puts on her signature* Thank you, Rosali, we would love some.
Terezi:..................
Rosali: ? Terezi? Is everything alright?
Terezi: !!!!!!!! Sorry, I spaced out..... Yeah! *puts on her smile too* I'll have a cup, thank you.
Rosali: Of course ^v^ *pours the tea for both Rose and Terezi* Enjoy~ *leaves the both of them alone to continue their talk*
Rose:.......... Terezi? Are you...... actually scared of Rosali?
Terezi:....... No? I mean..... *sighs* I don't know..... Look, I know she means us no harm. I mean shit, how can I suspect someone who spends every waking minute of her life looking after us? But..... I don't know........ when I smelled her blood that day....... when she..... had that whole episode...... *pauses*....... I don't know how to describe it, Rose......... something about Rosali just doesn't feel right........ it hasn't felt right ever since we all got on this meteor and she lost all her memories of the game. I mean...... why would a mutant Troll have such cold blood?....... Somehow colder than a seadweller's?
Rose:.............*not sure what to make of any of this, she turns to look towards the kitchen, where Rosali is seen chopping up some vegetables for a meal, staring at the black blooded Troll and wondering just what the deal with her is*
Terezi:...........*slowly looks in that same direction upon smelling the vegetables and hearing the sound of the knife tapping the cutting board*........ Rosali........ What are you?........
*In that moment, while chopping the vegetables, Rosali reaches up to open one of the cupboards, causing the sleeve of her cloak to slip down her arm..... this allows Rose for a moment to see the scar on Rosali's arm, the very same scar that Aradia saw when they all first got on the meteor, and which the others have probably seen a few times, that being the image of her sign, the Saturn symbol, carved in Rosali's arm*
Rose:*upon seeing that scar, her face morphs from a look of confusion, into something more horrified, as this is her first time seeing that scar, and she now finds herself wondering where that came from, and why her sign would be carved into her skin like that*..............