When the thunder rumbles, Pt.1
Pairing: Mark Meachum × fem!reader
Summary: We were never supposed to end up here. A storm. A borrowed house. Too much history between us. I told myself I was over him. I was wrong.
Warnings: emotional distress, hurt, heartbreak, cheating (mentioned), exes to lovers, kissing, physical intimacy
This fic contains the use of y/n and pet names (e.g. sweetheart, baby, love,...)
Words: 4979
Note: English isn't my first language.
We all miss Mark Meachum, don't we?🥺
Part 2 ➡️
💫 Check out my masterlist here!
-------------------------------------------------------
"I would never in a million years spend the night in there with you!"
With my arms crossed tightly over my chest, I sank deeper into the passenger seat, my gaze fixed in disbelief on the dark, silent house in front of us. Rain kept hammering relentlessly against the windshield of Mark's Ford Bronco. Somewhere in the distance, thunder cracked through the night like a warning.
Beside me, Mark let out a dramatic sigh. He pinched the bridge of his nose between his thumb and forefinger, eyes closed, breathing measured — like he was physically holding himself together, trying not to completely lose his patience.
"And what exactly do you suggest we do instead?" His voice was calm. Too calm. I knew him well enough to recognize that this was the voice he used when he was anything but calm.
I shrugged, still stubbornly staring straight ahead. "I don't know."
Mark huffed and turned toward me. "Great plan, y/n."
Then, softer, more careful: "C'mon. Dave's gone all weekend. He won't mind if we crash at his place. It's better than killing ourselves out there in this storm."
Deep down, I knew he was right. Driving any further in weather like this would've been suicide.
But I couldn't just…agree to this. I couldn't spend the night in the same house as him — not after everything. Not after he had ripped my heart out, crushed it without mercy, and left me emotionally wrecked in the aftermath.
"No way", I said firmly, shaking my head. "I'll just call an Uber."
From the corner of my eye, I saw his eyebrow lift as he watched me dig my phone out of my jacket pocket — only to be greeted by the mocking words No service on the screen.
"Fuck", I muttered, letting the phone drop against my thigh.
Mark, of course, looked like he'd already expected this. He clapped his hands once, as if the matter was settled, unbuckled his seatbelt and opened the driver's door. Cold air rushed into the car, making me shiver instantly.
"C'mon", he said over his shoulder. "There are multiple beds in there. We are not sleeping in the car!"
Without waiting for my response, he stepped out into the rain and jogged toward the front door.
I watched him for a few seconds…then, with a quiet sigh of defeat, I followed.
My shoes made soft, wet sounds against the rain-soaked ground. To keep from getting completely drenched, I pulled my jacket over my head — though it probably wasn't just the rain I was trying to shield myself from, but everything that was about to happen.
With quick steps, I came to a halt beside Mark in front of the front door. He glanced at me only briefly, wearing that unmistakable grin that clearly said: See? Told ya.
I rolled my eyes instinctively. A habit I'd picked up during our time together.
"Do you actually have a key?", I finally asked, letting the jacket fall back over my shoulders while tugging it tighter around myself. Thank god the architect of this house had at least been smart enough to include a porch roof.
Mark's mouth curved into that crooked grin again as he shook his head. "Nope."
That made me pause — until he crouched down beside the door, lifted the flower pot resting there, and revealed a single key hidden underneath. That explained a lot.
"Creative hiding spot", I muttered. Still, I was ridiculously relieved that he knew where the spare key was and hadn't planned on breaking into the house.
Mark shot me a quick wink before sliding the key into the lock. The door opened with a quiet creak. "Ladies first", he said, gesturing me inside with a mock-gallant sweep of his hand.
I rolled my eyes again but stepped over the threshold anyway. The brief brush of my arm against his chest was something I very deliberately chose to ignore.
Inside, I was met with a warm, muted stillness — a sharp contrast to the storm raging outside. Rain hammered against the windows while somewhere in the house, soft creaks traveled through the walls, as if the building itself had noticed that two people with far too much unspoken history had just crossed its threshold.
I reached for the light switch beside the front door, needing the light just to orient myself. Then, I slipped out of my jacket and draped it over the nearest chair. Water dripped onto the floor — and for a moment I simply stared at the small dark spots, as if they might tell me how I was supposed to handle this.
With a quiet sigh, I kicked off my shoes, nudging them aside with my foot so I wouldn't track even more dirt through the house. The thin fabric of my socks met the cool floorboards, grounding and exposing all at once.
A second later, I heard the soft thud of Mark's boots hitting the floor behind me. Of course he noticed. Of course he followed suit.
Then he closed the door behind us and leaned back against it. Too briefly to be accidental.
"See? Not so bad", he said quietly.
I didn't turn around. "We've been here for thirty seconds."
A soft, almost amused exhale behind me. "Fair."
I folded my arms across my chest again — not because I was cold, but because I needed something to hold myself together. The house was cozy. Far too cozy. Dim lighting, warm wood tones, a blanket casually thrown over the couch. Like it had been designed for people to feel safe here. To let their guard down. To let closeness happen.
Great.
"I'll show you the layout real quick", Mark said, pushing himself away from the door. "Then you can pick a room as far away from me as possible."
I shot him a brief glance. "Appreciate the consideration."
A crooked grin tugged at his mouth. Not forced. Not teasing. But the other one. The one that used to knock the ground right out from under me. I hated that it still worked.
He led me down the hallway, gesturing to two doors. "Guest rooms. Both comfy. Bathroom's in between. Kitchen…" He nodded toward the open living area. "…obvious."
"You've really studied this place", I muttered.
"Dave and I once got stuck here way too long on an observation." His shoulders lifted slightly. "It kind of feels familiar."
I only nodded, even though something unpleasant twisted in my stomach. Too many shared memories. Too many nights where familiarity had been dangerous.
"I'll take that one", I said eventually, pointing to the room at the end of the hall.
Mark nodded. No comment. No joke. And somehow that made it worse.
When I closed the door behind me, I leaned my forehead against it. Breathed in. Out. Just one night. Just a storm. Just a house. Just Mark Meachum.
What could possibly go wrong?
Outside, thunder rolled through the sky, like the universe itself was laughing.
---
I spent a while in the room, lying on the bed, letting the silence settle around me, though my mind refused to. Every detail of the day — the witness interview, the drive, the storm — kept looping in my head. Why hadn't we just made the whole thing weather-dependent? Checked the forecast properly, listened to the warnings? We'd never have driven this far, never ended up here, in a house I didn't belong in, with him just two doors down.
I hugged my knees, staring at the ceiling, thinking about how I'd let him get too close once. Too close, too fast, and how cruelly he'd pulled away afterward, leaving me raw and tangled in my own feelings. And now, he was somewhere behind that wall, probably lying in the guest bed two rooms over, completely at ease, probably even snoring lightly, while I tried to make sense of the mess he'd left me in.
I reached for my phone, fingers trembling slightly. The screen lit up: 2:37 a.m. A small, bitter laugh escaped me. Who plans for this? Who ends up in a stranger's house in the middle of a storm with the one person they'd hoped never to see again like this?
With a sigh, I swung my legs over the bed and padded out into the hallway, bare feet brushing the cool floor. The oversized T-shirt, tossed on the bed and practically calling my name, replaced the damp jeans and T-shirt I'd worn all day. It smelled faintly of fabric softener, comforting in its simplicity, and I welcomed the soft weight against my skin.
I reached the kitchen, stretching up toward one of the hanging cabinets, looking for a glass as I heard him.
"Top shelf. Second from the left", Mark's voice broke the quiet, casual and completely unnerving at the same time.
I jumped, spinning around to see him on the sofa in the adjacent living room. Dim light pooled around him. Jeans, dark t-shirt, socks. Whiskey in hand. Casual, effortless, infuriatingly perfect. My gaze lingered longer than it should have — and I felt it, the familiar twist in my chest, the rush of heat I always tried to hide — before forcing myself to blink and give him a sardonic tilt of my head.
"Wow, captain instructional. Good thing I didn't know the glass patrol was on duty tonight", I muttered.
He laughed, a low, amused sound that slid straight under my skin. "I've got to set boundaries somewhere", he said, raising the glass slightly.
I grabbed a glass, hesitated, thinking about the water bottle tucked in the fridge, before noticing the whiskey bottle sitting temptingly on the living room table.
Mark's eyes flicked toward it, a half-smile teasing. "Help yourself", he said. "But if you want some, you'll have to come over here."
I froze for a heartbeat. Something stronger than water felt necessary — maybe necessary in ways I didn't want to admit.
Then I crossed the short distance and poured myself a modest amount, the amber liquid catching the dim light.
Mark's eyes followed me the entire way, slow and deliberate, as I reached for the whiskey bottle on the living room table. I could feel the weight of his gaze tracing my movements — the way my bare legs stretched toward the table, the soft bend of my knees as I lifted the bottle, the careful tilt as the liquid filled my glass.
Heat pooled in my stomach. My skin tingled in a way that was impossible to ignore, my pulse picking up. I hated that he could do this to me — that just by watching, he could make me so acutely aware of myself, of my bare legs, of the way the oversized t-shirt barely protected me. Vulnerable. Exposed. And yet, part of me couldn't look away, couldn't stop wondering if that subtle smirk or the faint sparkle in his eyes meant he knew exactly what he was doing.
"Wow", I said finally, tilting my head, trying to sound more amused than flustered. "Really subtle, Meachum. Watching me like some…exhibit?"
He straightened slightly on the sofa, raising his hand in mock defense, though the faint grin tugging at his mouth betrayed him. "Hey! I was just…making sure you didn't spill the whiskey."
I rolled my eyes, hiding a small smile. "Uh-huh. Totally believable."
Sitting beside him on the sofa, I left enough space between us to breathe, tugging the hem of the t-shirt over my knees like it could somehow shield me from him. But I could feel it — his eyes lingering, impossibly, on the expanse of my bare legs. The awareness sent a sharp little thrill through me, mingled with the heat of embarrassment and something I wasn't ready to name. Too much skin, too much memory, too much him.
The quiet thrum of the storm outside, the faint scent of whiskey, the muted lamplight, the sofa beneath us, and the unspoken tension between us — it made every nerve alive, every thought sharp, every feeling impossible to ignore.
For a moment, neither of us spoke. The kind of silence that wasn't empty, but heavy. Charged. Loud in ways sound could never be.
I lifted the glass to my lips and took a larger sip than I meant to. The whiskey burned its way down my throat, sharp and unforgiving — and somehow that sting grounded me. Pulled me back into my body. Back into the room. Back onto the sofa, with Mark sitting far too close for someone I was trying very hard not to feel anything for.
His gaze never really left me. I could feel it without even looking.
And of course, that was exactly what my mind chose to latch onto.
Memories came uninvited, slipping in through every crack I tried to keep sealed shut.
The first time we'd met — all wrong timing, all wrong place. Him leaning in the doorway of the briefing room, coffee in hand, watching me like he'd already decided I was trouble. Late nights on stakeouts, sharing bad jokes and worse snacks, laughing far too easily for two people who were supposed to keep things professional. That night on the motel balcony, when the air had been too warm and the distance between us too small, when his hand had brushed mine and neither of us had pulled away. The first kiss that had never been part of the plan. The way I'd fallen asleep against his shoulder afterward, like it was the most natural thing in the world. Like I hadn't been building walls my entire life.
God, I'd been so stupid.
A quiet exhale left my lungs before I even realized I'd been holding my breath.
"You're not sleeping either, huh?"
His voice cut gently through the mess in my head.
I blinked, focusing back on the present. On the dim light. On the storm. On him.
I tilted my head slightly, lifting the glass in a mock toast. "Yeah, well. I always preferred listening to thunderstorms on some acquaintance's couch with my ex and a bottle of overpriced discount whiskey."
The corner of his mouth twitched. "Ouch." Then he shook his head faintly. "For the record…Dave's not just an acquaintance. He's a friend."
I wrinkled my nose instinctively. "You have weird standards for friendship."
That finally earned me a quiet laugh. Not loud. Not forced. Just real enough to tug something uncomfortable in my chest.
I hated that it still did that.
I took another sip, slower this time, eyes dropping to the amber liquid as if it held answers. It didn't. But it gave me something to do besides look at him. Besides think about how he was still sitting there, still watching me, still existing far too close to my carefully maintained emotional distance.
Outside, the storm rumbled again. Inside, everything felt louder.
---
It was sometime around four in the morning when I finally noticed the clock on the oven.
The storm had softened to a steady, tired drizzle. The world outside felt paused, like it, too, had run out of energy to keep raging.
Inside, the whiskey bottle sat between us on the coffee table, noticeably lighter than it had been. My glass had been refilled three times now — maybe four, if I was being honest with myself.
We were still on the sofa. Talking. And somehow, at some point, the space between us had shrunk. Not gone. Not dangerous. Just...smaller. Enough that our shoulders occasionally brushed when one of us shifted. Enough that his warmth reached me without trying.
I didn't remember how the conversation had drifted here. One moment we'd been trading sarcastic comments about Dave's questionable choice in house décor, and the next—
"Remember that stakeout in Berlin?", Mark said, a faint grin tugging at his mouth. "When you almost blew our cover because you laughed at my accent?"
I huffed softly. "You sounded like a villain from a low-budget spy movie."
"You're cruel."
"You're dramatic."
He smiled at that, the kind that came easy now. Unguarded.
"Okay, my turn", I said, lifting my glass slightly. "The time you tried to make coffee in the break room and somehow managed to set off the smoke alarm."
"That machine was faulty."
"You put hot sauce in it, Mark."
"In my defense, it was labeled terribly."
We were both laughing now. Actually laughing. The kind that reached the eyes.
Alcohol had a way of dissolving the careful edges. Of loosening the parts of me that had been clenched tight for too long.
The memories shifted slowly after that. From ridiculous. To familiar. To…softer.
"That night in Prague", he said quietly after a moment. "When everything went sideways. You stayed up with me until sunrise."
I nodded. I remembered. Too well.
"You didn't have to", he added. "But you did."
I swallowed, gaze dropping to my glass. "You looked like you needed someone who wouldn't leave."
The words settled between us, heavier than everything else we'd said tonight.
My chest felt too tight. Too exposed.
So of course my mouth chose the worst possible direction instead.
"And then there was the time in that stupid motel in Valencia", I said lightly, too lightly. "When we both agreed that sharing one bed was a terrible idea."
His smile faltered — not fading, just shifting. Sharpening. His head tilted slightly. "Was it?"
I exhaled a quiet, humorless breath. "No. That was the problem."
I stared ahead, the memory too vivid, too warm, too dangerous. The closeness. The laughter that had faded into silence. The way everything had felt inevitable.
When I finally glanced at him, his expression had changed. Not angry. Just… intense.
"Don't", he said quietly.
"Don't what?"
"Don't say things like that." His voice was lower now, rougher around the edges. "Not when you're sitting this close to me."
My pulse tripped. "Why?", I asked, even though part of me already knew the answer.
He held my gaze, unwavering. "Because it's hard enough hearing you talk about us like it meant something", he said slowly. "When I'm not allowed to do anything about it."
The air between us felt suddenly too thin. Too charged.
But for reasons I couldn't explain, I couldn't make myself stop — not when the memories of that night flared so vividly behind my closed eyes, as if it had happened yesterday.
"Do you remember that night?", I asked before I could stop myself.
He didn't look away.
"Yeah", he said quietly, his voice lower now. "I remember." His jaw flexed once. "It was…impossible to forget."
Something in his gaze darkened, just slightly. Like a shadow passing over something already intense.
"I still think about it", he admitted, softly enough that it felt like a confession he hadn't meant to give.
My breath hitched — barely noticeable, but real.
I tilted my head, forcing a half-smile I didn't quite feel. "That sounds like a you problem. No one's forcing you to think about it."
A beat of silence. Then he turned fully toward me.
"That's exactly the problem", he said. "It was the best sex we ever had."
The air felt heavier. Thicker.
Instinctively, I bit down on my lower lip, my thighs pressing closer together as Mark's gaze locked onto mine — as if he were trying to take in every reaction, every flicker of vulnerability.
He noticed.
"Do you ever miss it?", he asked quietly. "Being like we were. Not the chaos. Not the fallout. But…us. The way we fit when it was just us."
I hesitated.
His voice softened. "I don't mean just physically", he added, though both meanings lingered in the air. "I mean the way we moved around each other. The way everything felt easy. Natural. Like we were exactly where we were supposed to be."
My chest tightened.
The truth hovered on my tongue — terrifying and achingly familiar.
"Yes", I admitted finally, barely above a whisper. "I do."
The word settled between us like a live wire.
Neither of us moved. But neither of us looked away either.
Instead, Mark shifted closer — close enough that our knees touched. The rough denim of his jeans brushed against the strip of bare skin the oversized t-shirt didn't quite manage to hide. The contact was barely there. And yet it felt impossibly loud.
I stilled for a heartbeat, fighting the instinct to unravel over something so small. So stupid. I straightened my spine as much as my cross-legged position allowed, as if posture alone could make me less transparent. Less breakable. Less his.
It didn't help.
Because then I looked at him. At those eyes. Those infuriating, beautiful green eyes that had once held promises they'd never kept. That had once made me believe in futures I'd had to bury.
"I was such a damn idiot, sweetheart", Mark whispered, his voice raw, almost stripped bare. "I wrecked everything. All of it. Over one stupid moment."
The words hit deeper than I expected. Deeper than I wanted.
Grief rose first. Then anger. Then the unbearable confusion that had haunted me ever since. That familiar burn gathered behind my eyes, sharp and threatening. I blinked hard. Once. Twice. Don't cry. Not now. Not here. Not in front of him.
"You cheated on me, Mark."
The words barely made it past my throat. Too fragile. Too tight. The memory of that night — his voice, his confession, the way my world had cracked open — still hurt like fresh glass.
"I know", he said quietly. "But it was only one time. You have to believe me."
A hollow, bitter sound left me — half laugh, half breath — and I hated myself for it when the tears slipped free anyway, tracing hot lines down my cheeks.
"One time too many."
Mark swallowed hard after my words. I saw it in his throat, the way the guilt sat there like something sharp.
"I know", he said again, but this time it wasn't just acknowledgment. It sounded like regret carved into every syllable. "I know what I did to you. And I hate myself for it every fucking day."
My breath trembled. The dam I'd held together for hours cracked completely.
"You have no idea...", I whispered, and then my voice broke open. "...no idea what you meant to me. What you still mean to me." A shaky laugh escaped me, bitter and wounded. "I thought we were…solid. That whatever we were building, it was real. And then you threw it away for..." I scoffed, tears blurring everything. "For that blonde disaster with the personality of stale toast."
The words were sharp. Ugly. Honest.
Mark didn't even flinch. Instead, his face crumpled in something dangerously close to pain. "You're right", he said quietly. "About all of it."
I shook my head, anger rising again through the tears. "Then explain it to me! Because I still don't understand how you could even look at her when you were...when we were—"
"Happy", he finished softly.
That single word hurt more than anything else.
"We were", he said again. "God, we were. That was the problem."
I blinked at him, confused, furious. "What?"
His gaze dropped to his hands, clasped tightly together like he was holding himself in place. "It started feeling...too good. Too real. Like something I didn't deserve. Like eventually you'd wake up and realize you deserved someone better. Someone who could give you more than I ever could."
My head snapped up. "That is the stupidest thing I have ever heard."
He looked up again, startled.
"You think I stayed because it was convenient?", I demanded, voice rising. "You think I went through everything with you because I didn't know what I wanted?" My chest felt like it was splitting open. "Meachum, I sat next to hospital beds and waited for test results. I watched you fight through pain and fear and exhaustion and I still chose you. Over and over again."
Silence slammed into the space between us.
"You don't get to tell me I'd leave", I said, quieter now, but more dangerous. "You don't get to rewrite what I felt just because you got scared."
He opened his mouth. Closed it again. Pain flickered across his face.
"I was trying to protect you", he said weakly.
I shook my head fiercely. "No. You were trying to protect yourself."
He nodded slowly, like he couldn't deny it anymore. "Yeah. Maybe I was."
The tears wouldn't stop now.
"You broke me", I admitted, voice trembling. "You broke something in me so deeply that I don't know if I'll ever let anyone that close again. I don't know if I'll ever feel safe enough to give someone what I gave you."
Mark's head lifted sharply. "That's not true."
I let out a humorless laugh. "You don't get to decide that either."
"You will find someone", he said immediately, conviction burning behind his eyes. "Someone who earns it. Someone who deserves the way you love. Because you…you love like it's rare. Like it's sacred."
My breath caught painfully.
He shifted closer without me fully noticing it happening — slowly, carefully, like he was afraid I'd bolt. His knee brushed mine again. This time, neither of us moved away.
"I'm so sorry", he whispered.
His hand lifted hesitantly, as if asking permission without words. When his thumb brushed gently beneath my eye, wiping away a tear, something inside me fractured and softened all at once. The touch was careful. Reverent.
Another tear followed. And he caught that one too. Then another.
We were too close now. Close enough that I could see the tiny scar above his eyebrow. Close enough to feel the warmth of him, the gravity of him, the pull of everything we'd ever been.
Outside, the storm had picked up again, rain hammering against the windows, lightning slicing through the night — as if the weather itself was aware of the tension building inside.
We stayed like that, too close to pull away, too close to ignore. Our eyes locked, and it felt like the world had shrunk to just the two of us. Every heartbeat was louder than the last, every inhale sharper, every tiny shift of air around us electric.
Slowly, almost reverently, he lifted his other hand to my cheek. I kept my hands folded tightly in my lap, gripping them together as if my life depended on it — forcing myself not to reach for him, not to lean into that warmth. Our whiskey glasses, long forgotten on the coffee table, sat abandoned, witnesses to how quickly everything else had fallen away.
His gaze roamed over my face, lingering at the curve of my jaw, tracing the line of my lips, then darting back up to my eyes.
My throat tightened. I wanted to say something, anything, but nothing came out. Not a word. Not a sound.
"I'm so sorry, y/n", he whispered, just barely audible, a confession meant only for me.
Then he leaned forward, ever so slightly. My eyes fluttered shut, surrendering before I even realized it. And as his breath brushed against my lips, every thought except the memory of his mouth — the way it had always felt, the way it had always made me forget myself — disappeared. My chest tightened, my heartbeat sped, my stomach clenched. I could only feel.
His lips met mine — soft, tentative, impossibly close, a whisper of a touch that sent everything inside me into overdrive.
And then — a thunderclap, impossibly loud, crashing through the house. We both jerked back, hearts racing, eyes wide, breath stolen by the sudden sound.
Then…we laughed. Nervously. Breathless and awkward. A shared sound that broke the tension just enough to remind us we were still human, still alive.
"That was close", I whispered, cheeks burning as I looked down for a moment, trying to steady my racing pulse.
He nodded, scratching the back of his neck, the faintest hint of sheepishness in his expression.
But then…his gaze found me again. That impossible, unreadable look — sharp, magnetic, filled with all the things he never said, all the things I hadn't dared to admit. The air between us felt like it could ignite.
Before I could even think, he snapped forward. His lips met mine again— but this time the contact was hard, claiming, desperate.
I gasped. A startled, unformed sound, but instinctively, I surrendered. My hands shot up, threading into his hair, tugging him closer, needing the contact, needing…him.
His hands found my hips, strong and sure, pulling me impossibly nearer, tilting the balance of the world. Every heartbeat, every nerve, every inch of me alert and alive.
The kiss deepened, hotter, like every unspoken word, every crushed memory, every longing we'd both buried came rushing out through our mouths. I could feel it in the press of his body against mine, the tilt of his head, the way his lips molded to mine with such familiarity it was like breathing.
Then he moved — subtle at first, testing the ground — and suddenly I was straddling him, knees on either side, pressed against him. My hands in his hair, his hands on my hips, and the world outside, the storm, everything, had shrunk to just this. Just us. Just this fire, this electric pull, this collision of memory, desire, and too-long-suppressed emotion.
The kiss intensified, turning more urgent — especially when Mark traced his tongue along my lower lip, a silent request for entry. I granted it without hesitation.
I felt him shift beneath me, the solid weight of his body, the warmth of his skin even through the layers of our clothes — and all the hesitation, all the fear, all the longing of the past hours and months melted away, dissolving into that one, shattering, perfect moment.
-------------------------------------------------------
Part 2 ➡️
@magic-sprinkled-daydreams @cranberrysauce666










