What's your opinion on Sonic Omens and the whole drama surrounding the game's Patreon? Something I haven't seen brought up yet in this discussion are comparisons to doujin circles and how lax Japan is towards monetization of "fan" projects compared to other countries. Do you believe there to be a risk of SEGA reversing their fairly lax stance on Sonic fan games up until this point?
The last time this happened, when ArcForged was crowdfunding Sonic Smackdown, I got in to a heated argument with them on Twitter that I believe ended in them blocking me because I told them to knock it off.
I was riled up enough that I started rolling around doing a video about why monetizing fan games was a bad idea, and by the time those ideas were gelling together in my head enough for me to start writing, ArcForged announced they were ending Smackdown's crowdfunding.
It seemed mean to go forward with a video where I drag them through the mud after they eventually did the right thing, so I never wrote that script.
Now definitely seems like a good time to dust those ideas off again, though.
Japan’s doujin scene is a complicated one, because it’s important to remember that a lot of us don’t live there, and aren’t exposed to the finer points of contention surrounding it. We see “somebody is selling fan comics!” without necessarily digesting what that actually means. There’s a density to Japan that lets niches fly under the radar but also thrive in ways they wouldn’t in America.
Also keep in mind that if selling “doujin games” were actually totally legal and accepted, Japan would be awash with unofficial versions of anything that was popular. Look at Touhou -- that was a franchise sort of born in the doujin scene, it thrived in the doujin scene, and people have made careers there. Touhou is everywhere and everything. Novels and comics and games, hundreds and hundreds.
Did that ever happen with Mario? Can you remember the last time a Mario fan game was sold for money? Or Mega Man? What about Dragon Quest? Are you aware of any Dragon Quest doujin that, one: aren’t porn, and two: were long running and widely distributed?
I mean, you’re more likely to find a Touhou parody of this stuff than legitimate doujin games. There are still laws that will be enforced if you step on the wrong toes.
Which means that yes, I do believe Sega will start going after people if they continue to be disrespected like this. Sega and the community has an understanding, and it’s lead to a kind of ceasefire. If people take advantage of that for their own personal gain, then it threatens the whole system. Why risk bringing the fire down on everyone? Its ignorance at best, and selfish greed at worst.