The Ley Theory
or, “50 shades of Ley”: Real canon facts on what is actually going on with "Ronan N. Lynch"
brought to you by The Crying Club™️
A/N: Maggie if you're seeing this no you aren’t <3
---
It all started - as many things do - with a catholicism joke in the crying club discord server.
At that point, Mister Impossible (or as we affectionately call it, Miss Imp) had only been out a couple weeks, and we were all pretty bowled over, and wildly speculating about backstories. One of these speculations included wondering, if the sky book was the first dream Ronan remembers, what was Ronan’s very first dream?
A wise Parrishwife, at the time still blissfully unburdened with what has become known as The Ley Theory, once said: "what if his first dream is….. himself?” aka Ronan dreaming himself into life via Aurora, à la immaculate conception. Maggiekin out, Jesuskin in.
This innocent joke about Ronan being Jesus-adjacent, however, planted the seed of what would become a full blown theory.
Before we get into that though, let's revisit The Dream Thieves. Remember when Cabeswater said that there are many thieves, but only one Greywaren? Yeah.
This led us to wondering: “Why is Ronan not a thief? Is he just taking back from part of himself? Is he some kind of ley line entity?”
What the damn hell is a Greywaren even??? Does anyone have an idea what Greywaren actually is? Of course Ronan needed his I'm not like other girls dreamers moment, but why do we still not know what exactly a Greywaren is and how it relates to the ley lines, its forests and beings?
Could it be that Cabeswater is so enamoured with the Greywaren because the Greywaren is what sustains it?
Oh. Right. That's literally canon.
Thus, without further ado, the thesis statement:
RONAN IS A WHOLE ASS LEY LINE
…. and the hypotheses:
Greywaren (aka "Ronan") is actually a ley line and/or an ancient magical forest.
Greywaren dreamt (manifested) itself in the shape of Ronan Lynch.
Let's backtrack a bit and review the evidence, shall we?
(A/N: we DID make a powerpoint and present it on a zoom panel. It was 55 slides long and was called - you guessed it - “50 Slides of Ley”, because we are DELIGHTFUL <3)
PART 1: YOU ARE MADE OF DREAMS AND THIS WORLD IS NOT FOR YOU
Ronan being Greywaren aka a ley energy being might seem like a stretch at first, but actually, it makes a whole lot of pieces click into place.
So we all remember how Hennessy did a reverse Adam and put the ley line to sleep in MI, causing dreams all over the state to fall asleep (Bryde has a sweetmetal, so he awakens despite the ley line being completely zapped out; Jordan presumably created her own sweetmetal and she's awake by the end of the book; Matthew doesn't have a sweetmetal and he falls asleep, as do some of the Moderators). Ronan is (allegedly) not a dream, and he was asleep dreaming himself, but once Hennessy zaps the line, he doesn’t wake up. Why?
One option could be that Ronan is a dream himself, but if that were the case, the one person who could have dreamt him was Niall, and Niall’s been dead a long time. This doesn’t track. However, there’s another option here: Hennessy didn't stop Ronan's energy source. She stopped him. In other words: Ronan is the Virginia ley line, and he just got de-powered/put to sleep by Hennessy.
This, incidentally, would give a whole new meaning to Bryde’s insistence that “there are not two of you”. At first, we all interpreted it as Bryde being woefully wrong - yes there are two of Ronan, he can be both human and magical, shut up Bryce! And, well… that could still be true (more on that later). But what if, on a very base level, Bryde was right? What if Ronan has never been fully human in the first place? What if he was a ley line all along?
Remember, as well, that Bryde is A) Lindenmere made human (“dangerous things can protect themselves”) in the shape of the mentor figure Ronan needs, and B) Ronan himself, or at least a manifestation of his subconscious. But what exactly is Ronan's subconscious?
Bryde also says to Hennessy that he is “older than Ronan imagines”. Now, this could (and likely does) mean that he’s as old as Lindenmere. But there’s another layer here, because later, Hennessy thinks of that same phrasing - older than he imagines - about Ronan himself:
So… what if the implication here is that Ronan himself is much older than Ronan imagines? What if he’s not actually 19 at all, but an ancient sentient magical entity?
Yet more evidence from Mister Impossible: Bryde keeps trying to get Ronan to feel the presence of the ley line, but Ronan can’t until the very end, while we know that other dreamers (Hennessy) and psychics (Adam, Maura, Persephone) can feel it easily. Why is that? Simple: because Ronan is the ley line. How do you feel something is always in you and around you? How do you feel something that is simply a part of yourself? That would be like a human being acutely feeling the presence of their limbs - it’s not something we do, we’d have to actively make a conscious effort.
At the end of the book, however, Ronan can finally feel the ley line, and Bryde is ecstatic. This is because he views this as Ronan getting in touch with a lost part of himself, finally gaining awareness of his power and who/what he is. This is a direct parallel with the continuous efforts to remove energy blockages from the ley lines so they can flow freely and regain full power again.
If we follow this theory, then Bryde’s continuous “us vs them” rhetoric is more than simply shitty cult tactics to isolate him from his support network (though it is that too). His insistence on Ronan being a different species than anyone else (e.g. wolves vs humans) is quite literal: he wants Ronan to realise that he is in fact completely other, and he made himself human as a conscious decision:
Ronan wants his world to be smaller because he made himself human shaped. And in fact, Maggie told us this at the very start of the book:
Something that lay / in the shape of a man. The same way Ronan thinks of Cabeswater/Lindenmere as wearing a “forest shaped suit”, he himself is simply wearing a human shaped suit.
But the evidence for this theory doesn’t stop at Mister Impossible. In fact, looking back, we found several clues pointing to this as far back as The Raven Cycle:
Ronan is the only dreamer who can speak the language of dreams (and of Cabeswater/Opal/etc); neither Kavinsky nor Niall nor Hennessy are able to. That’s because it is in fact his native language - the ley line language.
However, he can’t speak the dream language when he’s awake, because in waking life, burdened with his human consciousness, he does not realise he’s a ley line - similar to how he cannot feel the ley line in Mister Impossible. There aren’t two of Ronan, but Ronan has somehow made himself two (again, very Jesus-adjacent in that “God making himself human” way… I know I know more Catholicism jokes but LISTEN THE EVIDENCE SUPPORTS IT)
More evidence in the shape of off-handed, throwaway foreshadowing: in The Raven King, we find out Blue is literally half tree. And if Ronan himself is a forest… well. That would certainly make them “the same impossible stuff” (it also means Adam’s type is literally trees but that’s a different story).
Okay, let’s talk about the Nightwash. Ronan gets worse Nightwash, it seems, than any other dreamer, when he’s away from the ley line. He gets it more quickly, more often, and more severely. Why? Well, at a first glance, it may seem like he just has Protagonist Problems. But think back: when was the first time we saw anything similar to the thick black ooze of the Nightwash? Yep, that’s right: The Raven King, while the demon is unmaking Ronan.
● Think about that word, “unmaking”. Ronan being away from the ley line results in, essentially, Ronan himself being unmade. That’s because he’s part of the ley line, and being away from it is something akin to dismemberment. To unmaking. In other words: “You are made of dreams, and this world is not for you.”)
PART 2: KING AND SHEPHERD BOTH
So, if Ronan is an ancient ley line forest, or indeed a whole-ass ley line, how did he come to to be connected with Niall Lynch? They key to all that is in the part of Miss Imp where we meet Ilidorin. For some reason, during our first frantic reading, we all kind of assumed Ilidorin was the name of the forest that got cut down.
But that’s not accurate: Ilidorin is the name of just that one tree.
In fact, when Ronan asks Bryde for the name of the forest, Bryde - who is visibly pleased with the question - replies “This tree’s name is Ilidorin”. Now, why would Bryde avoid answering the question… unless the answer is a Big McHuge Spoiler?
Here’s what we do know about the forest:
Ilidorin’s forest was like Lindenmere, but belonged to a different dreamer.
Its dreamer died “not long ago”
After the dreamer died, there was no one to protect the forest
However, the ley line of that forest is “pure, quiet, strong”, and “if that dam didn’t exist, it would be perfect”
Additionally: Ronan thinks that Ilidorin is a name that sounds like “it belongs with Greywaren”.
Can you tell where this is going?
THESIS: Greywaren was the ley line forest Ilidorin belonged to… and it was dreamt by Niall.
According to this thesis, then Greywaren was Niall’s forest in the same way that Cabeswater, and later Lindenmere, are Ronan’s. When Niall died, there was no one to protect his dream forest (nor, arguably, his children). What is a forest without its dreamer? Cabeswater was being unmade at the same time Ronan was; and so, perhaps, the true essence of Greywaren fell dormant when Niall died, and the forest was destroyed except for Ilidorin.
However, there is an extra step here. Something that makes (the) Greywaren more special than either Cabeswater or Lindenmere. It’s entirely possible that Ronan is not “just” the ley line forest of Greywaren, but the very core of the ley line that gives it life. In the excerpt above, Bryde refers to Ilidorin as being “old and hard of hearing”. Which leads us to this:
The dreams - the forests - are supposed to hear Ronan. Without Ronan, there are no dream forests. Why does Bryde, in his rallying of dreamers, constantly emphasise that Ronan is the most important? Well, because Ronan is the Greywaren: king and shepherd. Whatever dream energy is made of, Ronan is the lynchpin (ha ha).
To add to the mindfuckery, Bryde is a manifestation of Ronan, so his mission is both Lindenmere’s and Ronan’s mission: almost as if Ronan himself subconsciously knew his mission is to protect magic and the ley line forests.
Of course, Ronan’s mission at the start was simply to protect himself from NIghtwash and the moderators… but turns out those two goals might just be the same:
The first step to saving the ley lines, is to save Ilidorin’s ley line. Which means, to save Greywaren’s ley line; to save the Greywaren; to save Ronan.
Ronan, the Greywaren, is the shepherd of ley lines, and as a ley line himself, he is pure and strong… or he would be, if it weren’t for that pesky dam. Which, yes, means the literal dam blocking the ley line of course, but also… Ronan’s humanity. According to Bryde, the human shape that Ronan chose to inhabit - his human family, his human lover - is what is blocking him from remembering himself and be pure and strong. That’s why Bryde tries his best to isolate Ronan from Declan and Adam, his two truest connections to humanity (Matthew being a dream, and Ronan’s two other friends being out of the picture).
In the excerpt above, Bryde says that Ilidorin might help Ronan remember what he wants. Or, at least, what Bryde thinks Ronan wants; as Bryde says in MI, Lindenmere - aka Bryde himself - is “guessing what you want. Auto-filling, and we all know how that goes. That’s when shit starts to go wrong.” But regardless, he thinks Ilidorin will remind Ronan of what his purpose is. And with that in mind, it’s no coincidence that Ronan thinks back to being curled up inside Ilidorin while he’s severing his tie to Adam - his last link to humanity.
PART 3: THE FATHER, THE SON, AND THE HOLY FOREST
So Ronan is a ley line - more than that, he’s THEE ley line made human. But how did it happen, and what was Niall’s part in it? What role did Aurora play? There are a few options to explore.
Option one: Aurora was instrumental in birthing Ronan. This could either mean that Niall dreamt Aurora and then impregnated her (shudder) which… somehow, through mixing human and dream genetics created Ronan, “son of a dream and son of a dreamer”. This is the explanation that seemed most plausible prior to The Ley Theory™.
Option two: similar to the above, except Niall dreamt Aurora up already pregnant with Ronan, aka the essence of the Greywaren ley line, limiting Niall’s involvement in Ronan’s genetics. This is debatable due to the fact Ronan looks exactly like Niall, but there could be an explanation for that - more on it later.
Option three: Aurora had nothing to do with Ronan’s birth, and she was simply dreamt up after the fact as a copy of Mor o Corra, Declan’s birth mother, to be essentially the perfect caretaker/wife/mother to Niall’s (alleged) children.
(NB: All three of this options assume that Aurora came out of Niall’s Greywaren dreamspace-forest, making her… somehow Ronan’s sibling? Also if she was instrumental in creating the Greywaren but she was created out of Greywaren… is Ronan his own mom? Some conundrums are best left unpondered.)
We don’t know enough yet to provide an answer to the question of how Ronan came into being. We did, however, have other questions, such as: did Niall create Greywaren on purpose, for his own reasons? Niall Lynch being the selfish narcissist he was, manifesting a super-powerful ley line in his own image sounds like the ultimate ego trip.
Or rather... did the ley line/forest/Greywaren ask Niall to be manifested? This option seems to fit the theme of the books better - the idea of choosing to exist, and choosing in what shape to do so. It’s also possible that if the Greywaren is the “prime” ley line, the shepherd of the other dormant ley lines, it realised that it would need a human shape to awaken them, and thus asked Niall to help it become human.
Whichever way the events unfolded, this potentially explains the mystery of why Ronan looks exactly like Niall. It is not simply dream genetics and Aurora not having a DNA (though dream genetics are a mystery regardless - see the dubious existence of Matthew’s internal organs; however, Matthew and Bryde don’t look exactly like Ronan, so there is more to this).
Rather, it is reminiscent of when Cabeswater sacrificed itself to rebuild Gansey at the end of The Raven King: the book states Cabeswater needs to “remember what humans are like” (you could also say, make itself human-shaped). To do that, it “borrows” heavily from the other members of the Gangsey: it takes Blue’s sadness, Ronan’s wonder, Adam’s humanity.
So… is it possible that Greywaren did the same thing, when it made itself “Ronan Lynch shaped”? Did it borrow Niall’s likeness, and basically xerox its human dreamer, while keeping dreamstuff and magic on the inside? In the shape of a man - but not quite a man?
And while we’re at it: is this tied into why Ronan so desperately idolizes Niall - because he literally modeled himself on him? Did Greywaren love its dreamer in the same way Cabeswater loved Ronan?
It’s a lot to think about, we know.
So allow us to end on a somewhat lighter - yet tragic - epiphany: if Ronan and the fabled Greywaren are one and the same… and if Greywaren was Niall’s forest… then that means that Niall was not lying when he said he had a magical artifact called the Greywaren. Niall Lynch is a liar, so we all assumed that he used the Greywaren story to hide the fact that he was a dreamer. But as it turns out, that’s not quite the case.
Niall Lynch was getting all his stuff “from Greywaren”, the same way Ronan got his dream objects from Cabeswater - and he probably delighted in telling everyone (despite it putting Ronan directly in danger - because nobody would have a clue what he meant, ain’t that so clever :) Asshole and absolute madlad.
CONCLUSIONS: “THERE ARE NOT TWO OF YOU”
We have a few ideas about what could happen in the final book. Not anything specific, but more ideas related to the driving themes and concepts of the series.
One thing that could happen is that Ronan will stay asleep for as long as the ley lines are asleep (which is obviously not gonna be forever, because that would take all magic out of the world and sounds very overwhelming).
The good news: you know who’s really good at waking up ley lines? That’s right: one Adam Parrish (THIS IS HOW THE ADAM KING CAN STILL WIN). The bad news: ...of course the first time Adam woke up a ley line he had to do it through sacrificing his hands and his eyes, and waking up all ley lines would be a much larger undertaking, so uhhh. We are in danger dot jpg.
Another thing likely to happen is that Ronan will figure out the truth about himself - a dilemma he’s been struggling with since The Dream Thieves (“What am I, please God what am I?”) - and be tempted to live as a ley line being/god on earth. After all, Bryde has been complaining all along that “giving the world to humans” was a mistake (“We gave the world to them back before we knew any better”), which implies a master plan of reclaiming the world back for magic/nature/forests/ley lines.
However, as tempting as that may sound considering how rotten humans can be to the world, I doubt that the final message of the book will be “humans are the virus and we need to eradicate them”. Of course humanity has a place in the world: remember that this series, by Maggie’s own statement, is a metaphor for illness, creativity, and the way the two interact in artists. And Maggie has also said more than once that she considers herself a storyteller, not a writer: the difference is purely in the interaction with an audience.
What is a story without an audience to hear it? What is art, without people to look at it in wonder and be moved by it (think: Declan as the embodiment of this)? What is magic without humans to witness it and give it shape? By this token, magic is inherently human, and humanity is inherently magic.
This leads us to an important narrative parallel: part of the reason it makes so much sense for Ronan to not be human is that, quite simply… Adam is, and the two are sides of the same coin, desperately in love with each other. All through TRC and the Trilogy Adam is described as “real” and “human”; he is Ronan’s last link to the human world; he is even apparently “studying humanity” in school, whatever that means! He is literally named after the first man, and his surname references a gathering of people (though interestingly it used to be “Trinity”. No we won’t stop catholicshaming Maggie and ourselves).
In that light, Ronan’s desperate “please” to God upon seeing Adam for the first time in CDTH takes on a whole new layer of meaning: please let me be with him, or please let me be like him? That really is the crux of this whole story. Maggie said that at their core, the books of the Trilogy are about community. Ronan needs to find a community, badly - whether this means with other dreamers, with magic and ley lines, or with humans. So does everyone else in the book.
But the two poles - the two sides of the coin - that are in direct contrast are Ronan and Adam: the magical forest being who desperately wants to be human, and the human who’s desperately in love with magic. For Adam, finding community will mean having to accept that he can, and should, make “normal” human friends he can be honest with, while also not hiding the magical parts of himself anymore. After all, there are not two of him.
And for Ronan, well… it probably will have to mean embracing what he is while once again choosing to be “simply human, human, human”. Because, in the end, there are not two of him - what he is supposed to be and what he wants to be. Magic is human; humanity is magic. And Ronan can simply be whoever he chooses to be.
---
A/N: This post could not have happened without the amazing, supportive environment of the Crying Club server who went ham for like 8 hours on discord and sat through an actual symposium on this. @cryingclubs @parrishwife @faeparrish @adamparrishcryingclub @1989dean @sonboyadam @ellipsea @sulkybbarnes @fallingwaterr @orbmaster...y’all are the yees to my haw <3
Tagging a few more people who might be interested in this (please do ask to be removed if you’d like, or let me know if i forgot anyone!): @theamagician @balladofawellknowngun @emmerrr @parrishthieves @adamparrishes @countryboycas @thesongofakillme @papiliomachaon @vlindervin7 @bisexual-magician

















