elegantvamp replied to your post: it frustrates me how some confuse SU’s message of...
Putting genocide and slavery on the same level as mistakes….
look. you probably get your opinions hand-delivered, hot from the su crit youtube & tumblr presses, so nothing i say is really going to matter here. i accept that. we can disagree. but i did make an entire video going over white diamond’s character and how gem society works. which is uh. not exactly how you put it.
every gem within that system is expected to stay within the strict roles of homeworld. including the diamonds themselves! everyone’s roles exist to perpetuate the system and create more gems - not just the lower classes.
remember the scenes in the extraction chambers? the sauna and bath? those weren’t there for relaxation. they’re there to collect the essence of the diamonds, which is then used to create more gems. the diamonds are always working towards that collective goal. as pearl basically confirms, they don’t have weekends or off-days. they live for their purpose. same as all gems.
and. like. they’re literally a parasitic species. they can’t reproduce without taking what already exists in the universe. they don’t care about life on other planets, that is true... but they don’t seek out killing them, either. they don’t think about it. that’s just the “byproduct” of their invasion, to them. they take those resources to create gemkind, and they just... don’t care how that impacts the planet.
once new gems have emerged, that kindergarten is out of sight, out of mind.
and that’s bad! it’s bad for everyone who isn’t gemkind or a fan of the system, yes. it’s very bad - that’s why homeworld needed to change!
but if that’s the status quo of your society, you’re a parasitic species and that’s how you create life, you’re indifferent to the life on those planets because you prioritize your own species (as you see it), and you consider yourself someone who exists only for your duty (the perpetuation of gemkind), same as everyone else, then... that’s pretty far from being “genocidal”.
it’s like... a “who, you? i’m a predator species. i don’t care as long as i get my food & materials to build a nest” attitude. not a “i’m gonna deliberately set out to kill you, because i hate you/your group” attitude.












