Hello, I hope you are well. I recently read a piece of fanfiction that featured Ciel gouging out his contract eye; thereby nullifying the contract. Although I personally do not think the story will go in that direction, I wonder what WOULD happen if a contract mark was forcibly removed through means such as this. What is your opinion on this?
Dear Ihaveathingforlegs (I myself have a thing for legs too),
I’m doing fine, just quite busy, hence my late response. My apologies for that. I hope you are doing fine too!
Ah, I think Ciel gouging his eye out to escape the contract is a bit similar to the starting premise of season II; surely an interesting thing to think about!
While interesting and even kind of a delicious thought, LOGICALLY I myself don’t think physically removing the body part on which the contract sign is engraved would allow anyone to escape the Faustian bond. That would make it quite easy for any party within the contract to just cheap-skate their way out of it. Instead of a battle of wits with deadly stakes, it’d become a battle of who’s had HAD it first. I think most humans at least would rather lose a body part than a prospect worse than going to hell for eternity, after all.
In short, IF O!Ciel were to actually gouge his eye out in the contract, I think the contact will just remain. I think it’d just result in a raised eyebrow and a round of ridicule from Sebastian.
Since you asked this-person-who-can’t-do-short, let us look at a hypothetical case where Faustian-lawfully, opting out of a contract is possible through physical removal of the contract sign.
Under normal circumstances if a human wanted to form a Faustian contract, they’d have to know what “ingredients” to put in to summon a demon. That is to say that they’d probably know 1. a great sacrifice is needed for the ferry fee, and 2. their own soul as service fee.
Knowing this, it means that a human needs to be determined that whatever it is they want from the demon (even if a pedantic one were not to fuck them over immediately), their sacrifice and soul are worth the bargain. If someone is willing to sacrifice their very soul for this bargain, then choosing to lose a body part instead is USUALLY less big a deal. Why capable of giving up your soul but not - say - an eye or a leg? There are plenty humans living their lives without an eye or a leg, and they didn’t even “buy” supernatural services with it.
So IF it were possible to just physically remove the contract sign after you’ve enjoyed all the services from the demon, then that’s a damn good bargain! It’d be like buying a house, stay in the house, and rip the contract that makes you pay the mortgage.
Apparently demons can choose where to carve the contract sign with at least some liberty. If physical removal of the contract sign can free the contractor from paying their end of the bargain, then surely a demon would choose to carve the sign onto a vital body part. Humans can survive surgeries, so if I were a demon under such Faustian laws, I’d obligate the human to let me operate on them and carve the sign onto their heart or lungs. (Of course if the carving on vitals can be done magically I’d just do that) Otherwise I’d eat them instantly or do something else unspeakably horrible to them within the Faustian laws.
Sure, then the contract sign is not very conspicuous and therefore less controllable/powerful, but I am not sure that’s automatically a bad thing. It surely is better than being scammed out of a contract.
Besides, contract sign or not, good luck escaping this ↓
Well, though the premise of physically removing a contract sign is super interesting, this is my take on it ^^ I hope you found it interesting.