I’ve been thinking about the whole “earned death” thing the writers talked about. Initially I was thinking there is no way a good person can earn a death, but I think I was wrong.
I think if the plot calls for a cathartic release, a hero death can be “earned.”
I think regarding Lincoln the writers tried really quickly to build a link between Lincoln and Hive with Lincoln’s desperation to save Daisy and Hive goading him at the missile base. But, regarding Lincoln, it wasn’t enough of a build up to feel earned.
The grand romantic gesture can only serve as catharsis if the viewers buy in to the relationship, and static quake (while I love them both) had not had the build up to land that emotional devistation for the whole fandom to experience.
The thing was, there were characters that this would have been cathartic. An earned death. If it had been Coulson who was obsessed with taking out Ward, killed Ward and let Hive into our world. Or May, who was very focused on killing ward, when she say Hive saw it as an opportunity to kill Ward and who had Hive kill her husband in 3.20. Daisy would have been revenge for what he did in the dark turn, plus be a closing of the chapter in ending him after she blamed herself for not letting him die in season 1. Simmons killing him would have been her keeping her promise that has been echoing for seasons. Fitz killing him to save Simmons would have really played the tragic romance card plus allowed for revenge for the pod in season 1. Hunter was desperate to end Ward in 3a. His ending that plot by ending Hive would have felt earned.
Having Lincoln take out Hive makes all of this feel like dropped plotlines. I mean I have heard this was supposed to be the closing of a chapter, but having it not have that catharsis makes it feel incomplete...tragic because a good character died, but incomplete













