Hey guys, I am trying to figure out a villager list for my Undertale themed Animal Crossing island. I have a pretty set list except for my last villager.
I have 3 villagers per town, 3 for Snowdin, 3 for Waterfall and 3 for Hotland, and 1 who is a special character.
However, I recently found Lucky in my campsite. He is perfect for an Undertale Island because he’s one of the only monster-like themed villagers! However, the only empty space I have is in Waterfall, and I really wanted a duck or a frog villager there who has a blue house. The entire area is blue and purple themed and his black house really stands out. I thought he would be good to represent Napstablook but now I’m not so sure.
I also really need Nook Mile Tickets because I want to find my last two villagers (Phoebe and Julian!) so I was considering selling him on Nookazon, but then I would be passing up on a really cool villager.
I could move him to Snowdin, but all three of my villagers I had already committed to and are heavily gifted villagers so I couldn’t sell them. I don’t want to sell Hopkins because he looks just like the Nice Cream Guy, Sprinkle is heavily gifted and probably can’t sell for anything on Nookazon and Marshal is also heavily gifted.
Marshal makes the most sense to exchange for, but he is one of my favorite villagers and I was really excited to find him and I’ve been giving him lots of gifts. I’ve only given him clothes though, I’m not sure if that matters? But overall, I don’t think anyone wants to get a gifted villager. I also really don’t want to give him up.
Should I keep Lucky in Waterfall? Should I move out a Snowdin villager? Or should I move out Lucky and find a duck or frog villager for Waterfall?
