I think the Long Walk movie portrays Barkovitch so so so much better and sort of makes it sadder. There are definitely some more scenes he’s in in the book, but the movie takes away his comradery, which is a big point of the story.
I’ve thought so so much about this and I won’t keep it too long, but in the book, Barkovitch has certain moments of comradery with the others, like when he yelled alongside everyone for the watermelon, or when he joined in the forty-six man raspberry. Also, when they ask him about Scramm’s wife. These times may have been the only times he felt any comradery in the book, but it’s still something.
In the movie, he has NOTHING. Even if he walks in proximity to everyone, he is left out in every scenario. The few bigger moments of comradery in the movie is when everyone joins in to comment on Ray’s mom, when everyone is yelling “fuck the Long Walk,” and when they all discuss Hank’s wife.
Everyone but Barkovitch. Barkovitch is dead silent for all 3 of these scenes. Where all of the other boys are laughing or crying, all a family in some way, Barkovitch is completely left out. And the thing is, he could have joined. But I think he was too scared of the rejection in joining just normal conversations, he couldn’t get even a little of the comradery.
In the book, at least he got watermelon and enjoyed it with everyone else. At least he was asked to join in the group raspberry. He was even asked to help out Scramm's wife, Ray consciously chose to ask him. He is a part of the family, even if everyone hates him, I think. This is also kinda like how there are many musketeers, not just the four, and the musketeers change and grow.
He’s not in the family at all in the movie. There is less of a family in general, there are just less characters, less group efforts, less screen time I guess. It just makes everything so much sadder. “Step into it brothers-“ what brothers? Barkovitch, you really tried, I’m so so sorry it had to be like that.