i understand other people’s experiences are different, and some people legit have changed genders
but personally i was never a girl. when talking about baby!me i use they pronouns now. except for like, the years i was 16-18. i was not a girl then, but i was trying to be a girl, so it feels right to respect that and use she pronouns for her.
i said this in the tags of a post some time this week but like. as young as 4 i was aware i was not a girl. i, being four, assumed this was because of misogyny. girls get a raw deal, so clearly it was only sensible to wish i was born a boy.
like honestly i don’t think i had a clear sense of gender at all until like, last year. (inasmuch as “whatever makes you, the viewer, the gayest” can be considered a clear sense of gender, lmao)
idk when i need to make clear that i am talking about a past experience i had because other people around me believed i was a girl, i just...say that. they treated me like a girl. they thought i was a girl. i was trying to be a girl.
i never was a girl. other people perceiving me as a girl doesn’t change that. hell, like i said, me trying to be a girl didn’t actually change that. seventeen year old ani was not a girl any more than thirty-one year old ani, but she was trying to inhabit girlhood in a way i would never bother with now (at least, not for longer than a few hours)
given how disparate people’s experiences of gender are, the correct thing to do is...ask people. like if you’re talking to a trans person about their past, ask what language to use. even if you are trans. i know some of my trans friends feel very strongly that they were their assigned gender, at least when they were kids. i feel very strongly that i never was. neither of us is wrong, we’re just different people.