something i feel your argument fails to address is the fact that, ultimately, watcher lore is kind of whatever you make of it. it’s far out of the hands of true undeniable canon or themes or story because you the viewer (and one might even say….You, the Watcher) are the one making the canon and the themes and the story. You decide what it means. you string together a narrative that makes sense to you. and while obviously there is direct storytelling to draw from present in evo, a vast majority of watcher lore fans are fans of it purely from a fandom perspective and have never engaged with the source material; while this itself could be argued about and against, all of this is to say that, like, yeah, to some people it’s going to mean other things. to some people, it’s going to mean a little bit of fun and not much more. to some people, it means exactly what you believe it to mean, but they also want to see grian recover and thrive in spite of his hardship, however they might want to portray that. just something to chew on. the versatility of this stuff makes me crazy. IDK ur post got me thinking I Love your watcher thoughts they deeply fascinate and inspire me!!!
YEA VERY TRUE!
ik my post was kinda complaining about it but beyond personal pettiness i do very much like how versatile the meaning of 'watcher' is in the greater fandom. I'm always going to be a horror fanatic and crave to see things taken to the extreme, but that is just my own obsession, just like the more hopeful narratives are someone else's. i DO wish there was more proper horror about watchers, but that doesnt mean i want the other takes on them to not exist or get created. honestly while i dont really enjoy them i do find them very interesting from a meta standpoint.
like SO much of watcher fanon stuff is just trans allegories. and thats because a lot of the people who like fanon watchers are young trans people! to them watcher Grian is a way to put their own hardships into a form that is easier for them to grabble with. feeling alien in your body is confusing, and having your biology betray you is horrifying, and those feelings are so much easier to manage when you give those changes a form, something that is the cause instead of just abstract factors way outside of your control like puberty. and having that fictionalised version of your own pain, be told that THIS PAIN DOES NOT MAKE HIM EVIL, it doesnt mean he is broken or bad and that it will not be this painful forever is so valuable. having someone or something tell you that you will fucking get through this as a scared young person dealing with things that you have very little control over is genuinely life saving. I was one of those teens not too long ago, still am and I will never truly look down on these types of stories because of it. because frankly the comfort they can bring to people outweighs the literary critique i have with the stories themselves sometimes.
I have a habit of talking like my point is the only right one, and its something i do wish to work on because it just isn't what I mean when I write my long winded rants, but other people obviously do not know what goes on in my head lol. I kinda just vomit my thoughts out there and dont really think too hard about how it might seem like im judging when mostly i just tend to talk kinda aggresively when im excited. still! youre very right! i know i didnt adress too much of your points in this as i got once again side tracked, but I genuinely appriciate your input because it is good to kinda check how i adress stuff as my own posts do not in fact live in a vacuum just like anything else in the world lmao.
TY FOR THE ASK! I love talking with people about this stuff so I value every person who takes time out of their day to engage with my thoughts! evidently I do not run out of shit to talk about!

















