I have a theory about the Fell God. I’d always thought they were an Outer God, because of the way in which we see them appear within the Fire Giant. It’s an otherworldly body-snatch kind of influence. Similar to the Elden Ring’s/Elden Beasts inhabitation of Marika/Radagon.
What if it wasn’t an Outer God, but a God like Marika was. A Hornsent who achieved Godly power via the Divine Gate through destruction and ruin - slaughtering the original hornsent ancestors of Rauh as its own sacrifice to the Divine Gate to achieve its godhood. The reason why the Fell God has dominion over the Fire Giants now is because they too once had giant peoples in Rauh (as evidenced by the giant hornsent specimens in the Specimen Storehouse.)
This could be further evidenced by how the Fell God haunts the sagas of the hornsent. As maybe being their ‘mistake’ that nearly led to their entire peoples ruin. And the way the Furnace Icon depicts the Fell God in its Hornsent styled mask, with eight curving (see tangled) horns all around the head. Like a mane of a lion (one of the potential divine beasts of old Rauh.) This could also be evidenced by how the Hornsent reject the Flame of Frenzy completely. It would make sense that they would lead an inquisition against anyone using the power of Flame, if they as a people barely survived the Fell God’s emergence. And the Flame of Frenzy was even more dangerous as it not only destroyed people but also Spirits which at the time of Death Worship were seen as eternal.
Maybe anyone who destroys, or even just interacts with, the Fell God becomes cursed by it. Hence Marika becoming ‘cursed’ with Radagon’s red hair. That’s actually the influence of the Fell God coming through themselves and trying to find purchase.
If you leave this influence long enough, like with the Fire Giants, maybe the Fell God begins a process of conversion. The Fire Giants all supposedly had the second face in their stomachs, which were largely carved out seemingly. Perhaps, given enough time, the Fell God would be reborn through one of them in full. Even the Trolls have their own internals carved out, and a strange stone stake/stone tablet inside them. Perhaps that stake is Marika’s version of Miquella’s needle? But instead of being capable of stopping the influence of an Outer God, it stops the emergence of an influential God.
Marika is said to have slain the Fell God after all. But if she had removed the Rune of Death by that point in time from her Order, would that not grant a potentially mortal God with the ability to avoid Death?
Perhaps thats the real reason why Marika becomes afeared of the Flame again, to the point she seals Messmer away, and Melina is already bodiless and scarred by flame before we meet her.
All this to say. Imagine if we had’ve got a second Elden Ring DLC that focused on the reemergence of the Fell God after Marika’s defeat, and we die in battle against it initially, and are forced into the Spirit Realm of the Helphen to fight our way back to life, following the Lamplight of the Lampwood in place of Grace. A realm that the Fell God had made its own while in its pursuit of reemergence within the physical realm of the Lands Between, and whose influence is everywhere.
Imagine if we got to hear the other side of the story from a cognisant Fire Giant who isn’t anguished by isolation and torturous duty. Imagine if we got to interact with the actual Gloam Eyed Queen, or got to fight her Darklurker style as a secret boss, because of course she’s present in the realm of Death. Imagine if we got to encounter old friends who succumbed to Death, like Rogier, Darian and Fia. Imagine if we got to encounter the Prince of Death Godwyn in all his mermaid glory!!!
Oh what could have been….













