Makoto’s Fears and Quitting the SC in Middle School
Makoto in Free! S1 anime never directly said that he joined or quit the swimming club in middle school. He only kept mentioning Haru quitting but never himself (x).
Makoto only really revealed that he resigned from the swimming club with Haru in the S1 Novels.
I knew something happened but he won’t talk about it. I didn’t dig any deeper and just smiled and said “I quit.”
I’ve already said in this post before (x) that the reason Makoto quit the SC after Haru quit was because at that time Makoto was still pretty much afraid of water.
Despite the fact that he had already swam the relay with Ikuya and Asahi, it was only with Haru’s presence that MS Makoto was able to swim. Without Haru, MS Makoto couldn’t face his fears in the water.
High Speed 2 Chapter 9: Makoto talks to Natsuya about Ikuya
“If I were pushed away from Haru, if it would turn into that, I’m sure that I wouldn’t know what I should do anymore. Feeling disheartened, I might end up crying. I might blame Haru as to why it happened. ……I know very well that I’m depending on Haru, but…… but, because of that, I want to become a strong person who may be relied on by someone....”
High Speed 2 Chapter 10: Asahi, Ikuya and Makoto gather around Ikuya’s pictures and speak of their problems. Haru watches them.
“Sometimes, I become unable to swim, too.”Asahi and Ikuya direct their eyes towards Makoto. Raising his brows, Makoto was showing a good-natured smile.“I get hopelessly afraid of the water, and when that happens, I become unable to swim anymore.” Makoto’s hand leaves Asahi’s back, and he tightly grabs onto just the bottom edge of Haruka’s clothes.“You know, a little while ago, too, the rubber boat my siblings were riding in was carried away by the sea…… But, I was scared and couldn’t go save them……”Still smiling, Makoto’s grip gets stronger.“ In the end, Haru saved them for me. I can’t do anything unless Haru’s there.”
High Speed 2 Chapter 10: Makoto swims the 1500m Free
Makoto stares intently at the water’s surface. He hasn’t been able to completely wipe away his anxiety yet. However, it’s not that he was feeling a distinct unease. It’s not that he has a presentiment or is feeling agitated. It’s just that the unease is drifting vaguely.“Don’t worry. Makoto––” With the timing as he’s about to head to the starting block, Haruka called out to him.“I’ll swim with you.” With that one phrase, he felt the unease disappearing as if the fog’s clearing.“––Yeah!”
“Makoto––”Haruka’s voice––. Even now as he’s about to be swallowed by the water, that voice is the only thing he doesn’t fail to hear. “Don’t forget. I’m with you!” Right. Haruka said that he’d swim with him.“I’m swimming with you!” He’s swimming with him. Haruka is swimming with him. He was able to become strong just by thinking like that. He was able to stay with strong feelings. Brushing aside both resignation and despair, a hot lump comes welling up from the depths of his chest.
I’ll accept myself, too, he thinks. If Haruka’s with him, he ought to be able to do it. There’s nothing he can’t do. He can overcome anything. If he’s with Haruka, he can accept anything––.
As we can see, MS Makoto was hopeless in the water when Haruka was not with him. This was the primary reason why he also quit the swimming club. Supporting Haru came secondary to MS Makoto later.
From Timeless Medley: The Eternal Blue of Journeys to Come!
Makoto: I’m sorry, even I’m leaving the club.
Ikuya: It’s not your fault Makoto. Take care of your siblings.
Makoto: Yeah. Thanks. But I’m reallly sorry. It was almost time for the tournament and our team broke up. Asahi left so suddenly... And Haru, I wondered what really happened with him. I thought I understood Haru but I probably didn’t understand him at all.
Makoto told Ikuya and the rest of the swimming club that he resigned because he had to take care of his siblings. That may have been true to some extent but I believe Makoto’s fear of water was the primary reason.
High Speed 2 Ikuya knew about Makoto’s fears so he heard Makoto’s unspoken words. It was the safest statement to stop people from inquiring more about him. Even so, the members of the SC would have just assumed that Makoto and Haru were just joined by the hip.
To summarize these notes I’d like to list the reasons why Middle Schooler Makoto quit the swimming club in order of importance:
Without Haruka near, he couldn’t overcome his fear of water and therefore cannot swim .
He had to help his parents take care of his twin siblings.
Even though he didn’t know the cause of Haru’s depression, he quit in solidarity and support of Haru.
I wish Kyoani did better on the explanation for the school clubs though. In Starting Days, Makoto said they were required to have an after-school club (I didn’t see this rule in HS2 Novels). Yet both of them quit!
Does that mean Makoto and Haru joined different clubs after their first year? Or was Makoto suddenly exempted from the rule because he had to go home early to take care of his siblings? and what about Haru.. did he join the Art Club, perhaps? Well we’ll never know what happened in those hidden three years but it’s fun to speculate.