Invader Zim Rewatch Thoughts
Enter The Florpus:
We start with some very good sound design, and the dramatic anime opening here really is impressive (and funny)
I don’t take these as canon “realistic” designs for Irkens, just an interpretation. Partly because of the inaccuracies everywhere else
Or, as we see later, since this is just a totally different reality we don’t have to apply any of this to the main universe either way
If you’re reading this you probably already knew, but Foodio is what Membrane is working on in 10 Minutes to Doom (voiced by Dee Bradley Baker there) and that’s not the only reuse of things from the unfinished episodes so that’s fun
There’s a little family portrait in the hallway which is so cute :)
There’s a lot of Membrane family stuff in this movie but still no evidence of a mom to be found. I’m still in support of clone-Dib
The Dib and Gaz picture is cute too
Dib’s drawings of Zim are so funny. Now in the real world, I’m curious who specifically drew them
The way he just has “ZIM” written on the wall over and over (I guess it’s a little understandable when Zim is his best chance to be recognized and/or could be doing something crazy in secret/in space)
“Human brains: control, mind meats, spooky?”
“ZIM: evil alien monster”
An impersonal “Thanks for being a fan!” On his signed Membrane poster (it’s actually really cute that he even has that)
The little music cue goes “Zim!” And then “stretches!!” You can hear it better by finding the soundtrack on its own
I get why it would’ve been too long of an official title, but the movie opens as “Dib Membrane vs Invader Zim: Enter the Florpus” and of course it really is a Dib movie.
There’s more you can do with human characters who have people they love and care about, any conflict about Zim is always going to be about himself. Zim needs X thing, Zim needs to get out of X situation, Zim wants the approval of the Tallest (and is still too delusional to comprehend that they hate him; seriously, It would be a LOT harder than people think to get Zim to believe his mission is fake)
So I get it; the stakes were pretty much as high as they could go with the threat of Zim being captured and killed/experimented on, or Dib/the entire human race being in danger of death/enslavement. So everyone’s already in life-threatening danger, and because of that, the only way to make the movie feel “bigger” than the series was to raise emotional stakes.
The stuff we got from Zim’s emotions is basically the most we’re gonna get. He’s sad for himself and never worried about anyone else. So with what they were trying to achieve this time I understand why it’s the Dib movie. I still really wanted a Zim movie though and now we’ll never get one :(
With all that said, the opening “Invader Zim” logo is SO COOL the music and animation for it is great
That one angle where Zim is in shadow while walking in front of the camera is neat
Something about his PAK looks really nice in the movie. The art style here makes things feel very solid and I like that
“No Irken would ever become a chair.” This movie came out after issue #25 where Zim does in fact become a chair, in a much more literal sense too
In these new backgrounds, Zim’s dumb alien saucer wallpaper is now much more distinctly alien saucers. I’m just curious why that’s on his wallpaper at all lol
The hologram sticker things on the Super-Massive are a very cool feature; I’d like to see them better up close
In the show we see a lot of variation in Irken skin tones, so it makes me sad that every Irken we see on here, including Zim and The Tallest, has the exact same skin tone. In the show, Zim’s skin tone leans to a more yellow-y green, The Tallest are often more neutral-green (or at least a little less yellow than Zim), and Skoodge is blue-green. In ETF everyone is the same pale blue-green
These cheap-looking rigged animation parts make me so sad; they stick out so badly dude like this part looks terrible to me (the only thing saving these visuals is the still-image hologram picture of Zim in the background). Now to be clear, I’m saying that based on the high animation standards that this movie has set. Obviously if this was a fan animation it’d be impressive
Notice how in the very next shot everything looks way better? No matter what they’re doing, I no longer feel like I’m watching cardboard-cutout puppets. Tallest-puppets foreshadowing?
‘HUMANDIB.JPG’ where did he get such an exaggeratedly happy picture of Dib anyway?
“We don’t care, Zim.” See they’re done, they’re not even interested in humoring Zim anymore
Undisguised Zim and Gir pictures on the fridge? If it’s just more drawings then I guess that’s not supposed to be a big deal, but now I’m left wondering whether it was Zim or Gir who put these drawings on the fridge lol
Also you can hear Flibba Dibba Hoinka Smeedge in the background of the recording, but it sounds like it’s a much more chill version
“Besides reminding me how cool I look and sound that was of no help.“ Amazing level of self-obsession; he does look and sound cool
Zim is still so sure that he’s the greatest, but in holding himself to that standard (at least mentally holding himself to that standard), he is actually terrified of failure.
As the audience, it’s hard to tell whether Zim is just lying to himself or if he’s actually that delusional. He definitely lies about some things, but most of the time he seems to have genuinely convinced himself of the reality that he wants
“I don’t think they heard anything!” Is at least one example where he is lying to himself; we can see after Gir corrects him that Zim definitely does know that they heard him
I remember these two shots were in the teaser trailer, and at the time I got my hopes WAY too high because of this; absolutely a sick joke <\3
And ignoring the trailer, it’s generous that we got a scene like this animated at all so we can be teased again with some ideas of what The Trial could’ve looked like
Zim’s fantasy includes The Tallest saying that Zim used to be their “best, most amazing invader,” so even in this worst-case scenario we can see that his version of reality is in fact incredibly delusional
“But now you’re dumb.” “Also stupid.” Now that’s not far off from reality; I just learned in my rewatch of The Frycook that Zim’s wanted sign said “wanted for multiple counts of stupidity”
Now we do get some almost-lore from this sequence. Re-encoded as nothing is very interesting. Is that actually something they do? Or is Zim just terrified of being “nothing”? Maybe both
Also “stripped of your Invader rank.” In The Frycook, Sizz-Lorr shows Zim to his face that he’s still encoded as a food service drone. But maybe, much like one of the delusions he has in this very movie, Zim decides that the undeniable truth that he is an invader is higher than what anyone can do or say. “I know I’m an invader; therefore, that’s just a mistake. or therefore Tak is lying,“ etc., even if the logic behind holding onto that belief does not follow at all and at times is completely contradictory.
Shading on Zim’s face implying form :D
Some very sick sound effects on the re-encoding part
It’s fun seeing the crowd of Irkens in the background, but it also just makes me wish we got a Zim movie with a bunch of Irken stuff
“The Tallest could be here any day now!” It’s interesting that he thinks he’s running out of time; I wonder what he’s actually basing that on. In Dib’s Wonderful Life of Doom, the armada didn’t come for like 40 Earth years or something, but I don’t really hold a lot of stock in that. And in Battle of the Planets, Zim tells them to bring the armada tomorrow and he expects it to happen
You know what? I think this is another example of the times I’ve mentioned where Zim will get stuck on one idea and will NOT stop to reevaluate. Instead of taking advantage of Dib’s current absence by just thinking up something to do, he’s so hung up on figuring out what he had originally planned that he wastes all his time. Why is that kinda relatable?
I like how you can already see the cloning-pod-whatever thing that Clembrane is in; it’s kinda in the middle of the screen, so I’m sure they specifically wanted the audience to notice it
“Access The Tallest’s computers and retrieve their flight plan.” I would bet this is something he’s not allowed to do
Every part of Zim’s base looks amazing in this movie. There’s a handful of scenes with a very good sense of scale, and this big holo-room is one of them. It feels so big and cool in here it’s like a dream
“Hmm. I’m sure it’s there, somewhere.” I adore this line SO much; the little beginnings of doubt here and the seriousness is something I don’t think we ever saw Zim exhibit before.
The line delivery is also perfect
In terms of colors and hair I do prefer specifically Dib’s movie/comic design
I like the updated logo on Dib’s alien-hunting briefcase, very clean
“You saw those sting marks, and you know I eat a lotta honey now!” This isn’t a laugh-out-loud thing to me but I really like this bit (and Andy Berman’s voice and line delivery are amazing)
I don’t need to mention all the references in Dib’s garage because I’m sure there’s already sources on those, but it is very interesting to have pilot Dib’s food launcher there
I love that he’s painted his name on the side of the ship over the Irken logo, that’s such a human detail and very in-character for Dib
It’s crazy that we’re retconning Dibship Rising’s erasure of Tak’s AI, but I do think it’s a way better choice to stick Dib with a ship that has a mean computer. It’s very funny in contrast to Zim’s apathetic computer, and as shown in the comics, it gives him a reason to talk out loud
The vampire bee sighting doesn’t do it for me. It’s fine, I just thought it was funnier as something that’s only mentioned
It’s pretty hilarious that Dib never refers to Gir by name. It’s always “Zim’s evil robot” or something similar and I like that they were consistent with that here too
The kids in the Bloaty’s commercial are behaving too normal for my liking and there’s no terrifying music, for that I prefer the Bloaty’s commercials in the show
“Dib’s Master” is hilarious and fitting with Zim’s knowledge of human families
Zim’s eyeball gets squished into the floor after he falls off the couch and I enjoy that level of physics in cartoon characters
Zim sees being an invader as his only purpose, and the hard evidence he was given for why his mission isn’t real were all from secondary sources, albeit ones that usually are almost undeniable (The Planet Jackers, Sizz-Lorr), but The Tallest kept humoring him to some extent. Therefore, when he sees undeniable proof directly from the source that The Tallest aren’t going to allow him to complete his mission, he has to believe it.
In some deleted animatic dialogue for this scene, Zim says: “They must’ve found out I forgot what phase two is,“ which is still a delusional thing to say. The Tallest are “shmillions of light-years away,” and if hypothetically they were coming to Earth, and if Zim forgetting phase two did change their minds, they would still be WAY closer to Earth; it’s just physically impossible for this to be the reason
“You know, my dad doesn’t respect what I do either.” I am genuinely curious if Dib thinks The Tallest are in some way Zim’s parents/parental figures. Like maybe some kind of queen bee/bug situation. I only ask because he emphasizes the “my” in “my dad,” and he says “either.” Along with that, does Dib know that Zim is an adult?
Also very interesting here for him to start kinda maybe trying to show how he relates to Zim? He’s kinda just saying “well I have that problem too” and then it’s pretty much just him venting for a second
“The world I just saved without anybody knowing.” There’s some of that proper Dib characterization; he had nothing to do with Zim giving up but claims to have just saved the world lol
Zim on the floor is so sad
Zim is such a doomed character, man. With the Irkens’ pre-programmed lack-of-love-and-friendship thing he could never even have a chance to care about or relate to others; the way he is he doesn’t know what he’s missing and thinks it’s a gross and weak thing. So when Zim is depressed, all he can do is mope around and eat, alone.
Now, just like they had to make Membrane less neglectful, or it might’ve been a lot more serious to explore; when this movie is changing the formula and taking a deeper look at the characters and how their situations affect them, then Zim’s doomed state definitely feels a lot more sad. They can’t tweak or balance it like they can the human characters by applying human nature or loved ones, so in this movie he just becomes a much more pitiable villain lol
Oh, and if you haven’t seen that lore then here it is; it‘s from comic issue #50, which was written by Jhonen (this lore is also implied in Nubs of Doom and in issue #20 which was also written by Jhonen):
The fact that Dib is so confident that Zim will agree to help him with all this is very funny to me. Zim had given up on life and even put himself in Dib’s handcuffs, so I guess with him being that done trying Dib is assuming that he’d be willing to do whatever at this point. It’s just funny that he asks him the way that he does, removes Zim’s handcuffs, and offers a handshake lol
Cool robot thing, dunno why it’s not typical Irken colors
Zim’s depressed voice is funny I’m sorry
We get Dib complimenting Zim because Zim is helping him. This scene is VERY interesting to me actually. I don’t know if it’s the bizarreness of them interacting in such a non-hateful and cooperative way, and it almost feels sad? Maybe something about how similar they are and how they almost feel like friends here? When we know they would never actually be friends, for many, many reasons (especially since Zim inherently can’t). It’s kinda cute the excitement Dib shows at getting help from Zim, a little messed up when that’s paired with him getting ready to use it to expose Zim, but still.
But again, Dib’s characterization is very different here. This movie actually had no mentions of alien autopsies or scooping Zim’s insides out, so maybe movie-verse Dib is intended to be a little less aggressive in that regard? Who knows
He definitely feels much more like a real kid; he’s naive and was put in kind of a scary, irresponsible position. Obviously being the self-proclaimed “sole defender of Earth” from the moment he met Zim meant he was already facing a danger that he should not be facing. But I dunno, something about how he had no supervision and no second opinion in the decision to try getting help from Zim just feels so wildly out of hand if that makes sense?? Like I feel scared for him lol
“Childergy” kinda kills me
I love how Zim can’t help but flash the Irken symbol around everywhere, like he wouldn’t still do that if he was invading the planet of a space-faring race, right?
Dib’s modified bracelet restraining and moving him like that is terrifying; the speed and the metal clanking of it really complete the scene
Also Zim prepared ALL THIS in like one day and one night, while still depressed, and to some extent probably under the nose of Dib. He can be pretty impressive, but especially when he’s got nothing left to lose.
What kind of coordination did Zim and Dib even have with this? Was Dib seriously confident enough to just go home until he needs Zim?? Because that seems to be the case, he appeared to be completely ignorant of what Zim was going to do to take over the keynote stream: “Did you use your alien stuff to take over the control room?” I love that line too
Once again Zim is good at working a crowd (even if he throws in random hateful insults)
[Children sing, people rejoice, fatalities minimal]
I pretty much thought every big-head Dib joke in the series was funny, but this one does too much in my opinion. Everyone’s got their own opinions on comedy, but to me it would’ve been SO much funnier if Dib had looked exactly the same on the TV
They animate Gir’s mouth moving for all of his singing on this part, and that’s not my preference. When he’s in his dog suit I like it more when, like in the series, they only show his mouth open for things like screaming and eating
Minimoose’s dramatic theme is amazing
The little Irken-branded nanochip thing is really cool to me. I love how everything has to have the Irken logo. How do you make such tiny tech anyway?
“Iiiiii- teleported the Earth to a part of space directly in the path of the Irken Armada.” One of my favorite lines in the movie—I just love his delivery so much; he does this funny up-and-down thing with it. Also the way he says “Irken Armada” with such aggression
“Now the Tallest have to visit me next.” [He says in a somewhat desperate tone]
I love the theme for when the florpus shows up
What’s funny is in all this stopping-to-write-my-notes I completely forgot about the florpus
“Is that part of your brilliant plan, Zim?”
“Eh, probably. I mean, I’m so incredible even I don’t know everything I do!” From his expression and hesitation that’s clearly not an excuse he believes yet, and I’m once again curious how much of Zim’s confidence is him lying to himself vs how much is genuine belief
“He’s only a shmillion light-years away on Moo-Ping 10!” This is the second time in the movie Zim’s used “shmillion,” which is a measurement he also used in The Trial :D
“Why don’t you hop in your spaceship and go rescue him? Oh wait, you don’t have a spaceship!” Is another favorite line, incredible line delivery. It’s also so petty; this is a grown alien making fun of children for something horrible he’s putting them through lol
I love the Comms Officer (played by Fred Tatiscore, who is great)
Poor guy is the most reasonable one on the ship (or the only one brave enough to make suggestions anyway)
Upon this rewatch and analysis, a lot of the jokes have not been hitting for me (is there also just fewer jokes in general? Compared to the series?) but Gir horrifically stuffing himself with pudding does land for me, that made me laugh out loud
I know it’s a reference (my dad has told me about it because it’s not something of my generation) but the ham isn’t funny to me either
I know I’ve got some issues with this movie but the Tak escape stuff being cut is one of the biggest things that really sucks. I know we know secondhand what happened and why, but the ship having the secret motivation of going to break Tak out of prison makes it a lot more believable that the ship would seem to cooperate so fast. Without that scene, it feels a little cheap that they’d be able to convince the ship so easily
One of Gir’s signs says “YeY TALLiTS” and I never saw that one before
This throne part is decently funny, but I can’t help but wish Zim had something to actually do here. I understand why they’re essentially doing nothing; Zim thinks he’s fully won and is waiting for The Tallest to get here, but he just feels isolated, and the scene feels a little pointless to me. Maybe if it was more funny, I wouldn’t feel that way
The Tallest: [making fun of the guy who just doesn’t wanna die]
You guys have all listened to the full version of Flibba Dibba Hoinka Smeedge, right? I’ve seen a few people say they legitimately like it, but to me this is so intentionally bad (in a good way.) Obviously it has a good beat, but all the sounds and uncanny singing is almost scary lol
Again, this part with Dib singing would be a lot funnier if the movement from this sudden cardboard animation wasn’t so bizarre
The guards are singing the song haha
Yeah, so the ship’s diversion was rescuing Tak, and casual viewers don’t get to know that :[
“Normally” Dib crying on the floor is hilarious? Does he do this often? Because I wouldn’t blame him
Why are all these guys in the same cell anyway? How many of them are Zim’s prisoners? He’s got a lot in the comics (where does he get the money to keep them there? That’s another can of worms. Maybe that’ll be a separate post lol)
I adore Minimoose being used as a balloon. One of my favorite things about this series is the way the characters are just doing stuff
I like the detail that the control gloves from Tak’s ship are made for Irken 3-fingered hands
This Dib and Membrane falling scene is very good to me. The narrative parts, yes, but also the animation for Dib like kicking the button to unlock Membrane’s seat and grab his hand—it’s so frantic and good-looking
Wait. How does Membrane drink tea through his lab coat collar? How did I not notice that until now??
We got a sick PAK legs use before Zim evilly floats away with Minimoose (slowed down so we can see how cool it is)
It’s interesting that they changed the color of his PAK legs; they look really cool like that
“Then why are you ugly!?” Is so funny and so iconic. Thank you Richard Horvitz, for your improv
Very good music for Membrane’s dramatic entrance
Im sorry, but this fight part takes me out of it so bad. It’s the same rigged animation that looks so strange and cheap. I’m sure it was a budgetary thing, but that doesn’t mean I have to like it
I understand that there’s technically more movement and flourishes and little physics things you can add with this kind of animation compared to hand-drawn (because it’s faster and cheaper), but I think that makes it worse too. The way it looks like stiff cardboard while simultaneously moving far too much compared to how the rest of it is animated. Almost like the (wrong) idea that more frames = better animation
If I could describe these later action bits in one word, it would be: overstimulating. It’s SO much SO fast and SO loud, and depending on my mood, it can be genuinely too much for me to watch. There are some funny jokes, but a lot of them feel like they’re talking over each other if you know what I mean?
Because of that, and because of the Tak stuff and whatever else was cut for time (and it sounds like they had to cut a good bit), this movie SERIOUSLY could’ve used like 10 more minutes at least
Again, the ham joke: it’s not as much a joke as it is a reference (and the inclusion of a random object, trying to seem funny just because it’s a random object) That’s why it’s not funny to me. Zim getting hit with the ham and making a pathetic little sound when he does is funny, but the “references for the sake of references” doesn’t do it for me. I could see how it could theoretically be funny even if you don’t know the references, but it’s not my thing
Remember the Jurassic Park reference in Megadoomer? That blended in, and I found it funny (It also was understimulating lol)
Zim getting snatched by his head hahahaha
“I did my best :)” that lands for me
This is a good time to address Zim’s current state. Since he teleported the Earth away, he doesn’t have access to his space station. He didn’t leave the Earth in preparation for the organic sweep; he sees the Armada’s lasers pointed at the planet and doesn’t seem concerned about the fact that he’s still on it. (In fact, he’s still cheering on his victory.) He’s also not comprehending why it’s a problem that they’re in the Florpus??? Lunatic
“The Irken Armada is already here!” Was delivered SO well
I’ve seen people use this as proof that Zim is a child; it’s a pretty typical swap AU, and if Zim were his real age as a human, he would be a pile of ashes. If Dib and Gaz were their real ages as Irkens, they’d be WAY tinier. And besides that, we know Zim is an adult, so there’s no reason to try and reinterpret established canon through the lens of a swap AU.
Side note: I wish we could’ve had a shot of human Zim not screaming for a better look at his face. He looks cute, like look at his hair
The live-action dog bit isn’t funny to me either </3
Zim really does have an insane amount of confidence with which he asserts to Dib that “I won actually!” He’s like a kid who changes the rules to a game when he’s losing
When there’s so much damage to the Earth, it’s hard to suspend your disbelief that Membrane is still in... disbelief. Like I don’t know how I feel about their handling of it, but obviously it is a requirement for status quo; if Membrane genuinely found out about him then Zim would be donezo
The Tallest have been killed; that’s 4 accidental regicides for Zim (although this one was more Red and Purple’s fault let’s be real), but Zim himself has died before in the series, so we know death doesn’t have to be a permanent change to canon
“Thaaat sounded like a yes to me.” Does he really believe that?
This is my interpretation of Zim throughout this movie, which I’m pretty confident about;
Zim came up with this big drawn-out plan, so drawn out that he forgot what the next part was, and he let that slip in front of The Tallest.
When he finds out The Tallest aren’t coming, he assumes it’s because he “failed.” In some deleted dialogue, it sounds like he specifically thinks he lost The Tallest’s respect because he forgot phase two of his plan, he thinks that is the entire reason they aren’t coming anymore.
“I truly felt I had failed the Tallest, but then you told me about the power of the bracelet, inspiring me.” So we don’t get all the details about what Zim is thinking during his plan, but I think that he’s decided that teleporting the Earth is his new phase two. That now means in Zim’s mind that 1: he’s now not failed The Tallest, and 2: in carrying out this plan; he’s also made it way easier for The Tallest to bring the Armada to Earth. (Won’t they be so glad he took care of that?)
Then we get to the ending. He doesn’t need to cover for his plan of teleporting the Earth, because it sounds like he never called The Tallest to tell them about it (maybe he just wanted to “surprise” them? The same way he wanted to in Backseat Drivers?) but in the end he does still feel the need to assure The Tallest that he hasn’t failed, that he actually did carry out phase 2 of his plan, which he’s now decided is: stealing Dib’s ceramic clown-puppy. Obviously this wasn’t ever his plan, just a last-ditch effort at having done something. That still reflects that fear of failure, and it’s interesting that he’s confident he can cover with something like this when stealing a random useless trinket does nothing in furthering his mission. It’s like the illusion of productivity.
So why is he no longer worried about The Tallest not coming? Because he “proved” to them that he didn’t fail at his plan, he did something, so now there’s zero reason for them not to come.
Some extra thoughts: I liked the Membrane family’s emotional beats, but at times it seemed a little hard for them to balance the humor with it. More to say in the Dib section.
I think Zim’s depression was perfectly done. The fandom wants Zim angst, and I think the writers did a great job at avoiding a more fan-service-y take on this exploration of his character. They made sure that it was at least somewhat funny. Kinda like how in the DVD commentaries, you often see Jhonen emphasizing how the action needs to be funny; it can’t just be action.
Some of the changes are a bit much; Gaz might be the one who changed the most. She’s closer to a normal kid now because this story wouldn’t have worked out the same if Gaz had been the way she is in the show. I don’t assess Gaz’s character much, but in the movie she feels so different that, to me personally, I have trouble finding it believable when she’s being genuinely nice, but I also have trouble believing that she’d carry out threats the way she would’ve in the show. They’ve immensely stripped her of her previous apathy for sure.
Membrane is also different; obviously he’s always loved his kids, but they were pretty consistent about how neglectful busy he is, so it’s pretty strange how much more present he seems to be. Almost feels too normal.
Now who I don’t think was tweaked was Zim. The character stuff I was analyzing about him here compared to the show actually feels like we picked right up where we left off, with Zim being a criminally insane little guy living in his own version of events.
I was very sad at how much less funny I found this movie to be upon rewatch; Zim himself is still very funny. Gir is still funny, but I do feel they leaned away from unhinged and more on the cutesy side with him (despite one of his lines earlier in the movie). Exactly why I think characters like Zim are still funny and a lot of the rest of the movie wasn’t is the distinction between character humor and gag humor. (I don’t know if those are actual terms. That’s just what I like to use.)
The way I define character humor is: “X characters being funny, the involvement of traits specific to (often expected, but sometimes unexpected of) X character, or something that wouldn’t be nearly as funny if it wasn’t X character doing or saying it.”
Gag humor is like that cat being arrested during the Peace is Nice song. It’s not character-specific; it could be from any other cartoon, and in this case it wasn’t funny to me. Not that IZ doesn’t have good gags; upon this rewatch, I’m appreciating even more how the show’s got some truly AMAZING gags, but most of the ones in the movie didn’t land for me at all. Almost everything I did laugh at was specifically character humor (like Gir being gross, Zim being egotistical, or The Tallest making fun of the Comms Officer for disagreeing with them.) What I’d say is that the series’ main goal was to be as funny as possible, and I think the movie’s main goal was to explore the characters in a deeper way than usual.
That’s a good segue into: “This movie was very lighthearted.” Obviously this was quite different in tone, a lot less cynical, and the (human) characters actually feel like they care about each other. I know there’s a handful of little dark jokes, but overall there’s a sense of safety in this movie that wasn’t in the series, and I don’t prefer it. “Safety” as in this feeling that nothing could ever go too wrong, that “we know the heroes will win and we won’t be surprised when they do” kind of safety. And maybe something about all the subversions just being little random things instead of something startling, bizarre, or scary happening. Maybe that feeling also comes from the far more distinct hero/villain roles for Dib and Zim, kinda makes it more predictable.
And actually one more reason: there’s a way in the series that the main characters feel physical in how they interact with their environments. Dib getting poked with a tack, Zim having to adjust his wig when it gets askew, hair falling wet in the rain, bodies shredded, bones (apparently) broken, etc., and not all cartoons have that solid feeling. I don’t have that feeling when I watch this movie. I know Dib has messy hair and eyebags later, but that’s about it. You’ve got when Dib gets crushed by robots and is fine right after being rescued, Zim is dazed after being crushed into the sidewalk by his throne but is fine a second later, or when Dib crashes through a chunk of concrete in a humorous manner.
Now the series does bend and break the physics of things, but they seem to know how often to hold back. In the movie I haven’t been convinced that these characters can be hurt by their environment. I genuinely think that some of this would’ve been fixed if they showed Zim get burned by human food or drink again. And I know that sounds dumb but those parts always feel like they were given a lot of attention, and they give Zim that sense of physicality or something to me. A visceral sense of tangibility.
To be clear, it’s not like a show can’t be more cartoony and less physical. There’s plenty of cartoons I love that lean more into cartoon physics, but I’m used to and I love that feeling in IZ’s series, it’s strange to not have nearly as much of it.
So about Dib: like Gaz, Dib feels a lot more like a normal kid too, and his mistakes definitely feel like ones a real kid would make.
Dib’s character arc is set up with him expressing he wants his dad to believe him. Later we see that what that desire really stems from is wanting his dad to love and be proud of him, which makes sense. He says earlier on that Membrane thinks he’s crazy, which supports the idea that he must be ashamed or disappointed in him. Membrane’s response is very sweet :)
Dib’s goal of exposing Zim would mean forever upsetting status quo, and we obviously can’t do that. So giving Dib some closure in that he doesn’t need to prove he’s right for his dad to be proud of him is actually a VERY strong conclusion to his character arc in this movie, super well done. (Especially considering just how many episodes end up horrible for Dib.)













