Discover Top Posts Tagged with #jen frederick

When It’s Real

Erin Watt

Started: Jan 15, 2025

Finished: Jan 16, 2025

★★★★½

“Maybe love isn’t supposed to be easy. Maybe it’s supposed to be this complicated, messy thing that we fight for.”— Oakley Ford

Vaughn Bennett agrees to fake date nineteen-year-old pop star Oakley Ford to make him look less like a PR nightmare. She’s got twin brothers who treat chaos like a hobby, an older sister who doubles as her second brain cell, and a boyfriend named W who is the dictionary definition of “man written by red flags.” Oakley is Hollywood’s most reckless golden boy, and together they sign a contract that’s supposed to be fake but ends up ruining my emotional stability.

Review:

This was the book that dragged me back into reading as a teenager, which means I am permanently bonded to it like a hostage with Stockholm syndrome. Rereading it now felt like finding an old diary and realizing half of it was super embarrassing but the other half was still alarmingly relatable. Nostalgia is manipulative like that, and unfortunately it still works.

Fake dating is my addiction, and this was my gateway drug. Oakley, pop star disaster with the energy of a lit match in a fireworks factory, collides with Vaughn, the allegedly normal girl who is , apparently, already one bad day away from listing her brothers on eBay. The setup should feel ridiculous, but it doesn’t. The balance and vibe kinda work. He falls first, which is the natural order of things, and watching him pine while pretending not to gave me actual serotonin. Like what my dog should do instead of raising my blood pressure. Their chemistry isn’t only banter. It’s in the tiny moments where fame and real life grind against each other until sparks start flying.

Vaughn is the only thing keeping this book from floating away in a glittery haze. She’s working, parenting, surviving, and trying not to collapse while her twin brothers do their best impression of caffeinated raccoons, gotta love em’. Her older sister adds stability, but there’s only so much she can do so Vaughn is the carrying a lot of weight. And then there’s W. W is the kind of boyfriend who calls himself a “real man” while refusing to do the bare minimum, which is just a little too realistic for me. He thinks sex is part of a loyalty program and Vaughn should be grateful just to redeem her points. Watching her start with him is brutal, but watching her realize she deserves better is the whole payoff.

And Oakley. His arc is one of my favorite redemption stories, mostly because I have a screwed up sense of love, but he turned it around pretty damn fast. He starts spoiled, cocky, and immature, basically the human equivalent of a YouTube apology video waiting to happen. But did that make me hate him? Apparently not, which concerns me immensely. But then the edges crack. You see the vulnerable nineteen-year-old who wants to be seen as human instead of a brand, and I fell for that too. He goes from walking PR hazard to someone who actually earns Vaughn’s respect, and I hated how much I loved it. It’s the kind of growth that makes you want to throw the book across the room just to cope.

The family dynamics seal the deal. The twins are comedy relief with no off switch, Paisley, the older sister, is so great, and the messy, real-life obligations Vaughn faces keep the romance believable. The contrast between her world of bills and babysitting and Oakley’s celebrity circus is what makes their relationship feel earned instead of just Wattpad wish fulfillment.

I’ll admit it drags in the middle, like someone added filler episodes to stretch the season. By the end I didn’t mind that though, I kinda wanted more. Oakley’s early behavior is immature, but honestly, that’s just nineteen-year-old boys in their natural habitat. And yes, the beats are predictable, but cliché is comfort food, and I inhaled it anyway.

Other readers point out the age gap discourse. He’s nineteen, she’s seventeen, and technically yes, that makes people twitch. I get it, but it’s a two-year difference. When I read it at 16, it felt fine. At 19, still fine. By 23, I see why people side-eye it, but the issue is more about life stages than math. And they were actually in a similar stage of their lives despite the 2 year age gap. For me, it was never enough to ruin anything.

So yeah, When It’s Real is still one of my comfort reads. It’s fake dating, family chaos, pop star meltdowns, and character development that actually lands. It’s cliché, it’s messy, it’s addictive, and apparently my teenage self had more taste than I gave her credit for. (But not much)

★★★★½ four and a half stars, because apparently my love language is fake contracts, redemption arcs, and men with guitars who trick me into forgiving them. Can you tell how unhealthy my love life is?

#jen frederick

Trending Tags

Recently Viewed Tags

#jen frederick