@kajuned replied to your post “Things I immediately love about the cold open of Home: JENNY: Hey,...”
I still don't like blaming Lucifer for everything that went wrong in Mary's life and saying her chance to punch him was her getting revenge. Mary's worst enemy wasn't the Devil, it was her guilt. If she thought what she did back then - making the deal - was her worst crime, then forgiving herself was the key to fixing it. Guilt can cause stagnation in one's life, not failing to punch someone just because he was bad or evil. :P
Heya, sorry it took so long to reply to this!
I'm afraid that was another flippant post completely ignoring everything I've ever said about Mary's arc in season 12 for the sake of talking quickly and making another point... (I should stop doing this :P)...
I think her arc in season 12 was utterly shaped around her guilt and addressed deeply and fairly comprehensively to the point where I don't think they *need* another arc with that much concern about her guilt. Whether she still feels a pang about it whether she can help it or not, for the interpersonal family stuff they brought it to a resolution in 12x22 and used 12x23 to cosmically vindicate her with the AU, basically saying, now we did the interpersonal stuff we can show that cosmically Mary did a good thing/her deal is not a cause for shame or personal regret. So to me it has been addressed enough to move on past that point, and is no longer an ~active~ part of her characterisation, just like I assume Dean's no longer going to yearn for the grenade launcher on screen, and instead will be able to look fondly at it like hell yeah I shot that thing :P
Since Mary's personal part in the deal has been cosmically absolved (whether people feel this arc was enough/went deep enough I'm pretty sure the story considers it done and dusted based on the choices of absolution/immediate reassurance via convoluted AU premise) I was sort of stepping back and looking up and saying, well, anyway, she only made the deal because Azazel made her because Lucifer asked him to find a special child for the whole sake of the cosmic plan and blah blah main plot of 1-5... Since Lucifer is one of the core instigators, Mary getting to meet him and punch him a few times has a nice cathartic feeling for me, even if it's not really an actual revenge or whatever at this point (and narratively I assume if they're going to be trapped together, Dabb will hopefully weave some way for Mary to address the wider cosmic stuff in the AU designed utterly around the meta cosmic stuff to do with the season 1-5 plot, which will ACTUALLY give her a chance for more catharsis/better on-screen revenge or whatever).
So punching Lucifer has nothing to do with her personal arc about guilt, I just kind of love that she did it and I am looking forward to what comes next with that, since she has moved through a lot of important steps when it comes to the guilt arc and I think this is for her now to have moved beyond the insular family stuff which motivated her/blinded her in season 12...
I'm probably consistently going to keep talking about things in terms of "Mary now gets to deal with cosmic guilt and understand it's not her fault" as "got to punch Lucifer in the face" and "confronted her own personal demons of guilt through every part of her season 12 arc and came to a better understanding with her sons about what she did to them" as "hugged it out" and for that matter, stuff like "Dean has achieved an alarming level of self-actualisation and personal understanding of his own life based on his childhood trauma and getting to address it through Mary's neglect and voicing his feelings about John's abuse and her deal and having to parent Sam etc etc" as "got to shoot the grenade launcher"... this blog is helplessly euphemistic because I'm lazy :P