haii !<3 saw your requests being open and i was thinking poly! jily x reader .. >_< !! just an idea !! ^_^
I'd rather lie then lose you , girl
⤷ You and James find yourselves caught in a push‑and‑pull of rivalry and alliance, both trying to capture Lily’s attention while navigating the tension between competition and connection. What begins as playful banter and subtle gestures grows into charged silences, unexpected confrontations, and moments of vulnerability. ── .✦ ⋆. ִ ࣪𖤐 ˚ Jealousy Jealousy , Angst , Tension, Enemies to Lovers , Mutual pinning , Poly relationship , platonic!Sirius , Background Wolfstar , Simp Peter , James and Reader are obsessed with Lily 𓂃 ࣪˖ ִֶָ𐀔 7k
You’ve always hated how James Potter makes everything into a performance. From the moment you realized you both wanted Lily Evans, it became a war — not of wands, but of wit, charm, and sheer stubbornness.
You catch yourself watching him across the Gryffindor common room, the way he leans back in his chair, laughing too loudly at something Sirius said, just so Lily might glance his way. And when she doesn’t, he tries harder. You know the pattern because you do the same thing. You’re just as guilty of orchestrating little moments — answering questions in class with extra flourish, carrying her books when she forgets them, lingering in the library hoping she’ll notice.
But James is your mirror and your enemy. Every time you step forward, he steps too. Every compliment you offer Lily, he counters with one sharper, louder, more dazzling. It’s infuriating. You can’t stand the smug tilt of his grin when he thinks he’s outshone you, nor the way he mutters under his breath when you’ve managed to steal Lily’s laugh for yourself.
The rivalry has become its own language. Quidditch practice turns into a battlefield — you dive for the Snitch not just to win, but to prove you’re faster, braver, more worthy. In Potions, you angle your cauldron so Lily sees your perfect brew, only for James to “accidentally” spill his ingredients in a way that makes her laugh. Every interaction is a duel, every glance a challenge.
And beneath it all, there’s a strange, unspoken recognition: you and James are cut from the same cloth. Both reckless, both desperate, both hopelessly tangled in Lily’s orbit. You despise him for it, but you also understand him better than anyone else. That’s what makes the rivalry burn so hot — because in him, you see the reflection of your own obsession.
It’s exhausting, exhilarating, and impossible to stop. You’re locked in this endless dance, two rivals circling the same girl, each convinced you’ll be the one she finally chooses.
You’re leaning into Lily, finally savoring the quiet victory of her warmth against your side, when the inevitable happens.
James Potter storms into the moment like he owns it. His voice is loud, his laugh exaggerated, his ego filling the space until Lily’s attention flickers toward him. He drops into the chair across from you with all the subtlety of a Bludger, running a hand through his hair in that practiced, arrogant way.
“Evans,” he says, grinning like he’s just scored the winning goal, “you should’ve seen me out there — best Chaser Hogwarts has ever had. Snatched the quaffel right out from under Mulciber’s nose.” He leans forward, eyes bright, waiting for her admiration.
You feel the shift immediately. Lily’s gaze slides from you to him, her lips twitching with amusement at his theatrics. It’s infuriating — the way he can bulldoze into any moment, the way he demands attention like it’s his birthright.
You tighten your grip on the armrest, biting back the urge to snap. Because this is what James does: he interrupts, he overshadows, he makes everything about him. And worse, he knows exactly what he’s doing. His smirk lingers on you, a silent challenge, daring you to fight back, daring you to prove you can hold Lily’s gaze against his relentless charm.
The rivalry reignites in an instant. What was soft and private becomes contested ground again. Lily, caught between your quiet closeness and James’s loud bravado, is the battlefield. And you know you’re not about to surrender.
Slughorn’s classroom smells faintly of singed nettles and over-boiled potion, and the tension between you and James is thick enough to choke on. Both of you had lunged for Lily the moment partners were announced, voices overlapping, stubbornness clashing. Slughorn, too indulgent to intervene, let it happen — and so Lily ended up with both of you hovering at her side, a recipe for disaster.
You’re measuring ingredients with precision, determined to prove your worth, when James leans in too close, his elbow knocking against your arm. The vial tips, liquid spilling into the cauldron with a hiss. The potion erupts in a plume of smoke, splattering across the desk. Lily groans, pinching the bridge of her nose.
“Honestly,” she mutters, “you two are impossible.”
Slughorn’s voice cuts through the chaos: “Detention. Both of you. Tonight.”
You freeze, fury burning in your chest. James, of course, grins like he’s won something. “Well,” he says, brushing soot off his sleeve, “at least we’ll have quality time together. Can’t wait.” His smirk is aimed at you, not Lily, and it’s infuriating.
You glare back, jaw tight. Detention with James Potter — the very definition of hell. Lily shakes her head, already turning back to her notes, leaving you and James to stew in your shared punishment.
The library feels like it belongs to just the two of you. The scratch of quills and the faint rustle of pages fade into the background as Lily leans closer, her hair brushing your arm while she sketches out the shape of an ancient rune.
“You see how this one curves?” she says, her fingertip tracing the symbol. “It changes the meaning entirely if you angle it wrong.”
You nod, though your eyes are more on her than the parchment. “So… precision matters. Good thing I’ve got you to keep me from embarrassing myself.”
Her lips twitch into a smile. “You’d be hopeless without me.”
You grin, leaning just a little closer. “Hopeless, maybe. But at least I’m entertaining.”
She laughs, soft and genuine, and the sound makes your chest tighten. You tease her about her neat handwriting, she nudges your elbow when you deliberately mispronounce a rune, and the air between you hums with something unspoken. It’s not grand gestures or rivalry — it’s the quiet thrill of her choosing to stay here, choosing to share this moment with you.
Still, her brow furrows when she sets her quill down. “I can’t believe you’ve got detention with Potter tonight,” she murmurs. “The two of you together… it’s a disaster waiting to happen.”
You roll your eyes, but keep your tone light. “Don’t worry. I’ll survive him. Besides, I’d rather be here with you than anywhere else.”
Her cheeks flush faintly, and though she shakes her head, her smile lingers. The runes blur on the parchment, because all you can think about is the way her laughter feels like victory — quiet, private, and yours.
Slughorn’s voice carries across the dungeon, warm but firm: “Since you two seem to think Potions is a stage for your rivalry, you can spend tonight cleaning up the mess you made.”
The classroom is empty now, save for you, James, and rows of cauldrons crusted with residue. The air smells of burnt nettles and spilled potion. Slughorn has left you with a bucket, rags, and a pointed look that promised he’ll be checking in later.
You grip the rag, glaring at the nearest cauldron. “Brilliant. Just brilliant. Stuck here with you.”
James smirks, already rolling up his sleeves. “Don’t sound too excited. I know detention with me is the highlight of your week.” He runs a hand through his hair, as if even scrubbing cauldrons requires dramatics.
You scrub harder, determined not to rise to the bait. But of course, he keeps talking. “You know, Evans will probably pity you after this. Maybe she’ll even thank me for putting up with you.”
You snap your head up, rag dripping. “You’re delusional. If anything, she’ll pity me for being stuck with you.”
The banter bounces back and forth, sharp as hexes. Every cauldron becomes a battlefield, every word another jab. Yet beneath the irritation, there’s a strange energy — the rivalry alive and sparking even in punishment.
Slughorn’s footsteps echo faintly from his office, reminding you both to keep working. You sigh, leaning over the cauldron, muttering, “If you spent half as much effort cleaning as you do talking, we’d be done by now.”
James grins, tossing his rag into the bucket. “But then you’d miss out on my company. Admit it — detention’s not so bad when it’s me.”
The dungeon is heavy with silence, the only sound the scrape of rags against cauldrons. You’re bent over your work, determined to ignore James Potter entirely, when the hairs on the back of your neck prickle. There’s a presence behind you — close, too close.
You turn sharply, and he’s right there. James stands barely a breath away, his grin cocky, his eyes glinting with mischief. The suddenness of it jolts you, and instinctively you stumble back, your shoulder hitting the cold stone wall behind you.
“Merlin, Potter!” you snap, heart racing. “Do you have to sneak up like that?”
He smirks, leaning one hand against the wall as if he planned it all along. “Didn’t mean to startle you. Just wanted to see if you were actually working or just sulking.”
You glare, pressing yourself against the wall, trying to regain composure. “Unlike you, I don’t need an audience to scrub a cauldron.”
James tilts his head, still too close, still radiating that insufferable confidence. “Maybe. But it’s more fun when you react like that.”
“Relax. Just wanted to ask you something.” His grin sharpens. “Why Lily? You know I’ve been obsessed with her since third year. Everyone knows it. So why are you suddenly acting like she’s yours to chase?”
Your jaw tightens, the words spilling out before you can stop them. “Just because I didn’t make it a big deal back then doesn’t mean I didn’t like her. Not everything has to be a performance, Potter.”
His smirk falters, replaced by a flicker of irritation. “Performance? You think that’s what this is? I’ve been fighting for her attention for years. You can’t just swoop in and—”
You cut him off, voice sharp. “And what? Pretend you’re the only one who sees her worth? You don’t own her, James. You don’t get to decide who’s allowed to care about her.”
The air between you crackles, the rivalry boiling over into something rawer. His grin returns, but it’s strained now, defensive. “Guess detention’s not so boring after all,” he mutters, though his eyes don’t leave yours.
The rag slips from your hand, potion residue streaking across the cauldron, but you don’t care. You’re too busy glaring at James Potter, who’s leaning in close, his grin sharp, his eyes daring you to flinch.
“You think you’re the only one who’s ever cared about her?” you snap, voice low but cutting. “All those pranks you pulled — the ones that hurt her, embarrassed her, made her roll her eyes at you? You call that devotion? You’ve been obsessed since third year, sure, but obsession isn’t the same as respect.”
His smirk falters, jaw tightening. You press on, knowing exactly where to strike. “Every time you humiliated her in front of the class, every time you made her feel like a prize to be won — I saw it. I saw the way she hated it. And I hated you for it. Just because I didn’t shout my feelings from the rooftops doesn’t mean they weren’t there. I’ve liked her for years, Potter. I just didn’t make it a circus.”
His anger rises like a storm, his chest heaving, his eyes narrowing. He steps closer, the space between you shrinking until your back hits the cold stone wall. You tilt your chin up, defiant, refusing to back down even as his presence looms over you.
“Shut up,” he growls, voice rough.
Your lips curl into a smirk, your heart pounding but your defiance unshaken. “Make me.”
His gaze drops, lingering on your mouth. The smirk fades, replaced by something heavier, something dangerous. He leans closer, so close you can feel the warmth radiating off him, the rivalry twisting into something steamy, something you never thought you’d let happen. Your pulse hammers, your back pressed against the cold stone wall, and for a heartbeat it feels inevitable — James Potter is about to kiss you.
And then—
“Detention’s over,” Slughorn’s voice booms from the doorway, shattering the moment. You both jolt apart, the spell broken, the air still charged with what almost happened. James straightens quickly, running a hand through his hair, trying to mask the flush on his face. You grab your stuff and leave, but your heart is still racing, your lips tingling with the kiss that never came.
You’re lying awake in your dorm, the stone walls pressing in, the silence too loud. Sleep won’t come — not after detention, not after the way James leaned in, not after the way your heart betrayed you.
You press your palms against your eyes, trying to make sense of it. Lily has always been the center of your world: her laugh, her brilliance, the way she makes you feel seen. You’ve fought for her attention, battled James for her smile, convinced yourself she’s the only one who matters.
But tonight, when James was inches away, when his anger twisted into something hotter, you felt it. The pull. The spark. The possibility of something you shouldn’t want. And now you’re caught in the impossible question: do you like Lily, or do you like James? Or — terrifyingly — do you like them both?
It feels wrong, contradictory, like betrayal. How could you want Lily’s warmth and James’s fire at the same time? How could you crave the softness of her laugh and the sharpness of his defiance? Yet your heart won’t let you choose. It beats for both, tangled in rivalry and affection, in longing and confusion.
You roll onto your back, staring at the ceiling, the weight of it pressing down. You’re trapped in a triangle of your own making — Lily, the girl you’ve always loved, and James, the rival you can’t seem to stop wanting.
The next morning feels strangely quiet. You sit through breakfast, through classes, through the hum of Gryffindor chatter, but you don’t reach for Lily with your usual teasing remarks. You don’t angle your chair closer, don’t toss her sly compliments, don’t try to make her laugh just to prove you can. Instead, you keep your head down, quill scratching across parchment, letting her space breathe.
James, too, is left untouched. No sharp words, no muttered insults, no baiting him into another duel of egos. You pass him in the corridor, and though his eyes flick toward you, waiting for the spark, you don’t ignite it. You let him walk by, his smirk fading into confusion.
It’s not surrender — it’s exhaustion. After last night, after the almost-kiss that burned hotter than any argument, you can’t bring yourself to play the same games. You’re tangled in feelings you don’t understand, torn between Lily’s warmth and James’s fire, and the weight of it presses down on you.
So you stay quiet. You study beside Lily without flirting, you share a classroom with James without fighting. And though the silence feels unnatural, it’s the only way you can keep from unraveling completely.
The roar of the crowd shakes the stands as Gryffindor faces Hufflepuff — a team known for their speed and quiet precision. The air is sharp with anticipation, scarlet and gold banners whipping in the wind.
You mount your broom, the Seeker’s role heavy on your shoulders. Across the pitch, James Potter is already circling like a hawk, his grin wide, his confidence unshaken. He’s Chaser today, and you can feel the rivalry simmering even here, though you’ve sworn not to fight him outside the game.
Madam Hooch’s whistle pierces the air, and the match explodes into motion. Hufflepuff’s Chasers dart like lightning, weaving patterns that force James to push harder, faster. He barrels through their defense, Quaffle tucked under his arm, hair flying as he scores with a flourish that earns a roar from the Gryffindor stands.
You, meanwhile, are scanning the sky, eyes sharp for the glint of gold. The Snitch flickers in and out of sight, teasing you with flashes near the goalposts. Every muscle is taut, every heartbeat pounding with the thrill of the chase.
James swoops past you at one point, shouting over the wind, “Don’t let them outrun you, Seeker!” His grin is infuriating, but it sparks something in you — a determination to prove yourself, not just to Lily, not just to him, but to everyone watching.
The stadium is alive with scarlet and gold, the Gryffindor stands roaring as Remus calls the commentary with his steady, clever voice. You’re high above the pitch, the wind biting at your cheeks, eyes scanning for the Snitch.
Below, James is in his element — darting through Hufflepuff’s tight defense, Quaffle tucked under his arm as he scores with that trademark flourish. The crowd erupts, but your focus is elsewhere. Because when you glance toward the stands, you see Lily. She’s cheering for you, her voice carrying even through the chaos, and pride surges through your chest.
You grip your broom tighter, determination sharpening. Out of the corner of your eye, James streaks past again, another goal under his belt. But then — a flicker. Something golden, darting near the far end of the pitch.
The Snitch.
Your heart leaps as you dive, the wind screaming in your ears. At the same moment, the Hufflepuff Seeker spots it too, their broom cutting through the air like a blade. The two of you race neck-and-neck, every second a battle, every inch of distance fought for. The Snitch glitters just ahead, teasing, taunting, promising victory to whoever reaches it first.
The wind whips past your face as you and Alex Wood — Hufflepuff’s Seeker — dive in perfect sync, both chasing the flicker of gold darting across the pitch. The Snitch glints, teasing, weaving through the chaos of the match.
Above, Remus’s voice carries over the roar of the crowd: “And Potter scores again! Honestly, even if we don’t catch the Snitch, with the way James is racking up points, Gryffindor could still take this!”
You scoff internally, jaw tightening. Of course Remus would praise James. Everyone always does. But you don’t let the irritation distract you. You force yourself to focus, eyes locked on the Snitch, every muscle taut with determination.
Alex is right beside you, his broom cutting through the air like a blade. The two of you are neck-and-neck, the Snitch darting just ahead, golden wings flashing in the sunlight. The crowd gasps as you both dive lower, weaving between Chasers and Beaters, the chase so fast it feels like the world is blurring around you.
James scores again out of the corner of your eye, the stands erupting in cheers, but you don’t look his way.
The Snitch gleams like fire in the sunlight, darting just ahead of you and Alex Wood. Both of you dive, brooms cutting through the air at breakneck speed, the crowd gasping as you weave between Bludgers and Chasers. The wind screams in your ears, your fingers aching from gripping the broom, but you don’t let go — you push harder, faster, every ounce of focus locked on that flicker of gold.
The Snitch darts low, skimming just above the grass. You and Alex tilt into a dangerous dive, the pitch rushing up beneath you. The crowd screams, half in awe, half in terror, as you stretch your hand forward, fingertips brushing air — and then, contact. The wings beat frantically against your palm, but you close your fist tight. Victory.
The whistle blows, the game is over. Gryffindor wins.
But as you hover there, Snitch clutched in your hand, the stadium doesn’t erupt for you. The cheers go up for James, his name echoing across the pitch, his goals celebrated louder than your catch. He’s basking in the glory, hair windswept, grin wide, while you sit with the Snitch burning in your palm, pride tangled with frustration.
You won the match, but James Potter stole the spotlight.
You grip the Snitch tight in your hand, heart pounding with the thrill of victory. The cheers are deafening, the stadium alive with scarlet and gold — but they’re not for you.
You fly down, hope flickering that maybe Lily will notice, maybe she’ll see you, the one who actually ended the match. You land, adrenaline still buzzing, and start toward the stands where she’s cheering.
But then you stop dead.
Lily is already running — not toward you, but toward James. Her hair flies behind her as she leaps into his arms, laughing, radiant. He catches her effortlessly, twirls her around, and before you can even breathe, their lips meet in a kiss. The crowd erupts louder, Remus’s voice booming James’s name, the Gryffindor team piling in celebration.
You stand frozen, the Snitch burning in your palm, invisible in the shadow of their moment. Pride curdles into something sharp, something hollow. You won the match, but James won her.
Something raw ignited deep within you, sharp and unrelenting. Were you jealous? Hell yes, you were. Of course the two people you had once loved—maybe still loved—would end up together.
But the jealousy twisted strangely. Was it James you envied, for winning Lily’s heart? Or Lily, for holding James’s? The ache didn’t choose sides; it burned at both.
You told yourself you should be happy for them. They deserved happiness. They deserved love. People would rejoice to see them together, radiant and whole.
The roar of the crowd still rang in your ears, the taste of victory bitter on your tongue. The snitch sat cold and weighty in your palm, its wings twitching faintly as though mocking you.
You felt their eyes on you before you saw them. Lily moved first, her steps light, her smile warm, the kind of smile that could melt stone. She reached for you, voice soft, “Congratulations. You were brilliant out there.”
And then James. His gaze caught yours, hazel eyes bright with pride, the kind of pride that should have set your chest alight. He looked at you as though you had done something extraordinary, as though he wanted to share in it.
But you didn’t see it. Or rather, you refused to.
The bile rose again, jealousy twisting sharp inside you. Of course it would be them—Lily and James, together, radiant, whole. Of course they would find happiness in each other. And of course you would be left standing here, clutching a snitch that suddenly felt like nothing at all.
You turned on your heel before their words could sink deeper, before their eyes could pierce further. The cheers of the crowd blurred into a dull roar as you walked away, back to the changing rooms, back to silence.
The snitch fluttered once in your hand, then stilled.
You changed quickly, the smell of sweat and grass clinging to your skin, the snitch still cold in your palm. The cheers outside rang louder with every passing second, Gryffindor voices spilling through the walls, celebrating victory, celebrating them.
You slipped away, robes dragging, footsteps heavy, until you reached your dorm. The door shut behind you with a dull thud, sealing you in silence. You sat on the edge of your bed, the snitch resting uselessly in your hand, its wings twitching faintly before falling still.
The cheers from the common room carried through the stone, muffled but relentless. Every laugh, every shout of triumph was a reminder of what you weren’t part of, of the joy that belonged to them and not to you.
You loathed yourself in that moment—loathing the jealousy, the ache, the bitterness that clawed at your chest. You told yourself you wouldn’t care. You told yourself you were happy for them. James and Lily deserved happiness. They deserved love. They deserved the golden story everyone wanted them to have.But the word happy rang hollow. It was a mask, a lie you forced yourself to wear. Because beneath it, the truth was sharper: you couldn’t bear to watch them together.So you made up your mind. You would avoid them. You would keep your distance, keep your silence, keep your storm locked inside. If they wanted happiness, they could have it. You would not stand in their way.And yet, as the cheers swelled louder, you felt the emptiness press harder. Avoidance wasn’t freedom. It was exile. And you knew it.
But the word happy rang hollow. It was a mask, a lie you forced yourself to wear. Because beneath it, the truth was sharper: you couldn’t bear to watch them together.
So you made up your mind. You would avoid them. You would keep your distance, keep your silence, keep your storm locked inside. If they wanted happiness, they could have it. You would not stand in their way.
And yet, as the cheers swelled louder, you felt the emptiness press harder. Avoidance wasn’t freedom. It was exile. And you knew it.
You slip into the dress—dark burgundy faux leather, the halter neckline framing your shoulders with sharp elegance. The bodice clings like armor, corset‑style with lace‑up detailing that snakes down both sides of the front, cinching your waist tight. The skirt flares in layered folds, every movement catching the light with a subtle sheen, gothic yet modern. Silver necklaces rest against your collarbone, one cross pendant glinting faintly, and the black shoulder bag hangs at your side, completing the look with an edge that feels both defiant and deliberate.
The music from the common room thrums through the floorboards as you descend the stairs, the burgundy dress clinging like armor, silver cross glinting against your collarbone. You tell yourself you’re ready — ready to face them, ready to prove you can stand in the same room without breaking.
But the sight that greets you stops you cold.
James’s hands rest firmly on Lily’s waist, her arms looped around his neck. They’re laughing, spinning in time to the music, the crowd around them cheering louder with every turn. And then, as if the world itself conspired against you, he twirls her once more and their lips meet in a kiss.
The cheers swell, Gryffindor voices rising in triumph, not just for the match but for this moment — their golden couple, their perfect story.
Lily’s outfit radiates elegance with a romantic edge. She’s in a deep burgundy cocktail dress, strapless and satin‑like, the bodice fitted with asymmetrical pleating that sculpts her waist. The skirt flares in soft folds, giving her movement a graceful volume. At her side, a cascade of gathered fabric and ribbon‑like ruffles adds drama, catching the light as she spins. It’s striking, sophisticated, and perfectly suited for the glow of celebration.
James, by contrast, is sharp and commanding in a black three‑piece suit. The blazer is tailored with clean lapels, paired with a matching waistcoat accented by a silver chain. His black dress shirt and patterned tie complete the ensemble, sleek and formal, the kind of look that makes him stand out even in a crowded room. Together, they look like the golden pair Gryffindor has been waiting to cheer for — her in rich, romantic burgundy, him in polished black.
You slip away from the dance floor before the storm inside you can break loose. The burgundy dress feels heavier with every step, the silver cross at your collarbone like a reminder of the armor you’ve chosen to wear tonight. You set your bag down on a table, and head straight for the corner where Sirius is holding court with a bottle.
“Beautiful catch!” he exclaims the moment you arrive, clapping you hard on the back. His grin is wide, his voice booming over the music, and for a second the ache in your chest eases. Sirius pours you a shot without waiting for your answer, sliding it across with a wink.
You knock it back, the burn sharp, grounding. Another follows, Sirius keeping pace, his laughter infectious. Soon Peter joins, his cheeks already flushed, his words tumbling out in a rush.
“I’ve had a crush on Sylvia forever,” he blurts, eyes wide as if confessing a crime. “Ravenclaw girl, you know? Sylvia. She’s brilliant. I swear, since first year—”
Sirius howls with laughter, nearly spilling his drink. “Merlin’s beard, Wormtail, you’ve been pining for her longer than James and [Name] have for Lily!”
The words hit like a Bludger. Your smile falters, the burn of firewhisky suddenly bitter on your tongue. Sirius notices immediately — he always does. His grin fades, his sharp eyes following the line of your gaze across the common room.
There they are. James’s hands on Lily’s waist, her arms looped around his neck, the two of them spinning in the glow of Gryffindor’s victory. The cheers swell around them, golden and relentless.
Sirius leans closer, voice dropping low, teasing but edged with curiosity. “Jealous, are we?” You start to shake your head, the denial half‑formed on your lips, but Sirius’s brow arches in that way that says he’s already seen through you. His grin fades into something sharper, more knowing, and you feel the fight drain out of you.
Your eyes betray you anyway. They keep flicking back to James and Lily, tracing the way his hand rests on her waist, the way her laugh spills against his shoulder, the way they move together as if the whole room belongs to them. Every spin, every kiss, every cheer pulls your gaze like a magnet you can’t resist.
Sirius gasps suddenly, loud enough to make Peter jump. He leans in, voice pitched low but matter‑of‑fact, as if he’s announcing the weather. “Bloody hell. You like both of them.”
Remus steps into the room, his voice cutting through the haze of laughter and firewhisky. “What’s going on here?” he asks, eyes narrowing with that quiet, perceptive weight that always makes you feel seen.
Sirius, still grinning, opens his mouth — ready to spill the truth, ready to announce your storm to the world. But before he can, you move.
Your hand shoots out, grabbing him by the waist, pulling him sharply toward you. His balance falters, his grin twisting into surprise. With your other hand, you press firmly against his mouth, silencing him before the words can escape.
The room stills for a heartbeat. Sirius’s eyes widen, then gleam with mischief, muffled laughter vibrating against your palm. Remus raises a brow, suspicion flickering, but you hold your ground, your grip tight, your storm locked behind the gesture.
Sirius’s eyes gleam with mischief as he opens his mouth and — to your horror — licks your hand. You jolt back with a startled gasp, muttering, “Eww!” as you yank your hand away and rub it on your dress trying to wash aww Sirius' saliva. He slips easily out of your grasp, laughing, and saunters over to Remus with that swagger only Sirius Black can pull off.
Throwing an arm around Remus’s shoulders, Sirius smirks and calls out loud enough for you to hear: “Oi, now listen — I know I’m hot, and I love being manhandled as much as the next bloke, but I’m taken, yeah girl?”
Remus chuckles, shaking his head at Sirius’s theatrics, while Sirius shoots you a wink, clearly reveling in your flustered reaction. The tension that had been pressing down on you eases just a little, the mood lightening as Sirius turns your storm into something ridiculous, something you can laugh at — even if only for a moment.
The three of you burst into laughter, Sirius wiping his mouth with exaggerated flair while Remus shakes his head, amused despite himself. The firewhisky burns warm in your chest, the tension that had been coiled inside you loosening as the moment turns ridiculous. For once, you’re laughing — really laughing — and it feels almost like freedom.
But you fail to notice the way eyes linger on you from across the room. James and Lily, still close together, pause in their dance. His hand rests on her waist, her fingers curl at his neck, but their gazes flick toward you, toward Sirius and Remus at your side. There’s something in their look — not quite jealousy, not quite suspicion, but a weight you can’t name.
They watch the three of you with something. Something unspoken, something that makes the air shift. And though you’re caught up in Sirius’s antics and Remus’s quiet chuckles, the truth is, the golden couple isn’t as oblivious as you think.
jillyś pov
James’s hand tightens just slightly at Lily’s waist as his eyes linger on the three of you across the room. Sirius is laughing, Remus is smiling, and you — you’re laughing too, freer than he’s seen you all night.
“Funny, isn’t it?” James mutters, his voice low, almost sharp. “They look like they’re having the time of their lives.”
Lily tilts her head, her gaze following yours, watching the way Sirius leans close, the way Remus chuckles, the way you glow in their company. Her smile falters, replaced by something quieter, heavier. “Strange,” she says softly. “I didn’t think [Name] would… fit so easily with them.”
James’s jaw tightens, his eyes narrowing as Sirius brushes your shoulder in jest. “Too easily,” he mutters, a note of jealousy threading through his voice.
Lily exhales, her fingers curling tighter at his neck. “Don’t tell me you’re jealous,” she teases, though her tone carries its own edge.
James doesn’t answer right away. His gaze stays fixed on you, on the laughter you share with Sirius and Remus, on the way the three of you seem untouchable in that moment. Finally, he murmurs, “Maybe I am.”
Lily’s lips press together, her own eyes lingering longer than she means to. “Maybe I am too.”
You catch sight of them moving toward you — James with that familiar swagger, Lily at his side, her hand brushing his arm. For a heartbeat, your chest tightens, bracing for James to mock you, to throw his victory in your face, to remind you he finally has Lily. You can’t take that right now.
So you slip away, weaving through the crowd until you reach the dance floor. The music swells, and you let your hips sway, the burgundy dress catching the light as you move. It’s reckless, defiant, a way to drown the storm in rhythm.
You glance back over your shoulder, expecting smugness, expecting James’s grin and Lily’s glow. But what you see instead makes you falter. Their faces aren’t triumphant — they look… hurt.
No, you tell yourself, it can’t be that. Probably just because you’ve stolen their space on the floor, claimed the spotlight for a moment. That must be it. You push the thought down, keep moving, keep swaying, keep pretending the music is enough to silence the ache.
The party winds down, the music fading into softer echoes. One by one, the other houses drift away, their laughter trailing off into the corridors. Even most of Gryffindor begins to peel away toward their dorms, leaving only scraps of the celebration behind.
You’re still on the dance floor, the burgundy dress catching the dim light, Sirius and Remus nearby, when Marlene spots you. Her eyes flicker between the juniors lingering at the edges and the three of you. With a quick, decisive tone, she ushers the younger ones off to bed, then excuses herself to her own dorm.
And suddenly, it’s just the three of you.
The common room feels different now — quieter, heavier, the air charged with something unspoken. The cheers are gone, the crowd dispersed, but the tension remains. You stand there, aware of James and Lily across the room, their eyes still following you, their movements slower now, their expressions unreadable. Sirius leans back against the table, smirking, Remus’s gaze steady, thoughtful.
It’s no longer a party. It’s a moment suspended, stripped of noise, leaving only you three — and the storm that’s been circling all night.
James shifts his weight, hands buried deep in his pockets, his gaze fixed but unreadable. Lily crosses to the table, fingers curling around a half‑finished drink, the glass catching the firelight as she lifts it. The silence between you all hums, thick and charged, every movement deliberate.
You reach for your bag, the strap sliding over your shoulder, the decision to leave already forming in your chest. The room feels too small, too heavy, too full of things unsaid.
James’s eyes flicker toward you, narrowing just slightly, as though he’s bracing for words he won’t say. Lily takes a slow sip, her gaze lingering over the rim of her glass, watching you with something softer, something harder to name.
James shifts his weight, hands still buried in his pockets, and finally breaks the silence with a steady voice. “Good game tonight. That catch… it was brilliant.”
You glance up, surprised by the softness in his tone, and reply before you can stop yourself. “Thanks. You played well too, James. Couldn’t have pulled it off without your passes.”
Lily, sipping her drink, lets out a laugh that’s half‑teasing, half‑genuine. “Wow. James and [Name] complimenting each other? Never thought I’d see the day.” Her eyes sparkle, but there’s something else beneath it — something heavier.
The three of you linger in that fragile small talk, words brushing the surface while the silence underneath hums louder. You adjust the strap of your bag, trying to make an excuse. “Well, it’s late. I should probably—”
But before you can finish, Lily’s hand shoots out, catching your wrist. Her grip is firm, pulling you closer, right into the space between her and James. The sudden closeness makes your breath hitch, the firelight painting all three of you in gold and shadow.
James exhales, finally letting the weight in his chest spill into words. His voice is low, steady, but edged with something raw. “Why have you been avoiding us?”
You freeze, the strap of your bag tight against your shoulder, Lily’s hand still firm around your wrist. She’s pulled you closer, right into the space between them, her eyes searching yours with a mix of curiosity and hurt.
“I haven’t—” you start, but James cuts in, shaking his head. “Don’t. You have. Weeks now. You slip away when we walk in, you dodge us in the corridors, you vanish at parties. And tonight… you couldn’t even look at us.”
Lily’s grip tightens just slightly, her voice softer but no less piercing. “We notice, you know. We’re not blind. And it hurts, [Name]. Whatever it is… it hurts.”
The fire crackles, filling the silence that follows. You glance between them — James, jaw tight, eyes burning with something he won’t name; Lily, her gaze softer but heavy, her hand refusing to let you go.
You swallow, the storm inside you pressing against your ribs. “I just… needed space,” you mutter, but the words sound hollow even to you.
James steps closer, his voice low, almost pleading now. “Space from us? Or from what you feel when you’re around us?”
The question hangs in the air, sharp and undeniable. Lily’s eyes widen just slightly, her breath catching, but she doesn’t let go. She pulls you closer still, as if daring you to answer, daring you to stop running.
You shake your head, pulling slightly against her hold, your storm rising. “You’re imagining things. I’m not avoiding you. I just… don’t want to be in the middle of whatever perfect golden couple thing you’ve got going on.”
James steps closer, his voice low, almost dangerous now. “Don’t lie to us. We deserve better than that.”
“I was avoiding… myself. Avoiding what I feel when I see you together.”
James’s jaw slackens, his hands slipping from his pockets as he takes a step closer. “What you feel?” His voice is quieter now, but heavier, as if he already knows the answer.
You swallow hard, the truth spilling out before you can stop it. “I can’t stand it sometimes. Watching you two — perfect, golden, untouchable. And I… I like you both. More than I should. More than I can admit without breaking.”
Lily’s eyes widen, her grip tightening just slightly, but she doesn’t let go. Her voice is soft, trembling with something unspoken. “You like… both of us?”
The words hang in the air, undeniable now. You nod, the storm finally unleashed. “Yes. And it’s tearing me apart. That’s why I’ve been avoiding you. Because every time I see you together, it feels like I’m drowning in something I can’t have.”
Then James moves. He steps forward, closing the space between you, and pulls you into a tight embrace. His arms lock around you, strong and steady, his voice low against your hair. “You do belong. You’ve always belonged. We love you too.”
Before you can even process it, Lily presses closer from behind, her arms wrapping around both of you, her chin resting lightly on your shoulder. “We do,” she whispers, her voice warm and certain. “We love you. You don’t have to run from us anymore.”
The three of you stand there, tangled together in the quiet common room, the storm finally breaking into something softer, something real. The weight of avoidance, jealousy, and silence dissolves into the warmth of their embrace, into the truth you’d been too afraid to speak.
Months later, the memory of that night still lingers — not heavy anymore, but warm, woven into the rhythm of your days. The three of you have settled into something softer, sillier, and undeniably yours.
James still insists on pulling you into tight hugs whenever he sees you, grinning like he’s won the Quidditch Cup all over again. “Oi, don’t think you’re escaping me,” he teases, arms locking around you until Lily rolls her eyes and joins in, wrapping herself around both of you from behind.
Lily’s laughter is brighter now, mischievous and tender all at once. “Honestly, you two are ridiculous,” she says, though she’s the one who sneaks kisses to your cheek when James isn’t looking, only to laugh when he catches her anyway.
The three of you have become a fixture — studying together in the common room, sneaking butterbeer into late nights, teasing each other until the juniors groan and leave. What once felt like avoidance and storm has turned into belonging, into a trio that feels unshakable.
There are silly moments — James dramatically declaring himself your “favorite Gryffindor” only for Lily to shove him off the couch, you laughing until your sides hurt. There are flirty moments — Lily whispering “ours” against your ear while James pretends to pout, only to grin when you pull him closer. And there are soft moments — the three of you tangled together under blankets, the fire crackling low, the world outside fading away.
