Disproportionate Retribution Loser Poll Finals:
Amane Momose's (Milgram) Disproportionate Retribution)
"Keep in mind that MILGRAM is still ongoing, so nothing is fully confirmed yet. But in trial 1, the prevailing theory was that she was indoctrinated into a cult (via family) which abused and brainwashed her, eventually causing her to kill someone. The audience voted her guilty in trial 1 because they thought it would "teach her what she did was wrong" and somehow un-brainwash her. However, it didn't, but rather dug her deeper into the hole of cult indoctrination and now she speaks for the cult. Along with all the other guilty prisoners, her access to items have been restricted and her freedom of movement has been cut down, making her quality of life really kind of horrible. The other guilty prisoners were beat up within an inch of their lives by another prisoner, but she wasn't. As of trial 2, there is a new prevailing theory, that being that she killed her abusive mother."
Battler Ushiromiya's (Umineko No Naku Koro Ni) Disproportionate Retribution:
"Didn't remember/keep a promise he made when he was 12. Lost almost his entire family brutally because of it 6 years later. This is disproportionate because bro was literally 12 when he made the promise and who expects that to come up and bite them in the ass?"
C!Tommyinnit's (DSMP) Disproportionate Retribution:
"Crime: Property Damage/Griefing/disorderly conduct
Punishment: Exile, isolation, psychological torture
Out of proportion: that was some small time crime with war crime consequences"
Which Retribution is more Disproportionate?
Amane's quality of life being terrible because she killed someone
Battler having his family killed because he didn't keep a promise
c!tommy being exiled, isolated and psychologically tortured for property damage
Voting ended onFeb 3, 2025
