Before Season 3 started we were told this would happen. Instead Lyra did not even show up at all, Winn had no Love Life and for a large part of the season no subplot of his own (which prompted Jeremy to leave the show), and Guardian took the backseat in this season. I don’t know what happened, I guess the negotiations with the actress did not work out. Lyra just disappeared without any explanation. Now she was not the right girl for Winn, but having her there would have given him something to do and might have kept Jeremy on the show. And we would have had one less character on the show, who disappreared in-between episodes. So yeah, we would have wanted this. There is no question there.