Hey! Fellow ADOW fan here. I saw your post about season 2, and I was wondering what your opinion of the characters that are introduced in season 2 (particularly Philippe, Gallowglass, and Father Hubbard) is in terms of casting, adaptation from the book, etc?
Hi, thank you for the question! So many characters to discuss, let’s see...
I absolutely adored the casting for Mary Sidney, and I think her character and vibe were perfect. Same for the Queen, it’s nice to see an older Elizabeth not being played by a conventionally beautiful 30-year-old for a change. She was perfect, as you guys could glimpse from the trailers.
I do have to say that (privately) I wasn’t sure about the casting of Paul Rhys for Andrew Hubbard, mostly because of his age and demeanor in the books, but I was wrong because he is UNRECOGNIZABLE in the show and plays his part very well.
I had similar feelings for Philippe, I thought someone else could have been a better fit, but James Purefoy has done a spectacular job becoming Philippe and I have nothing but praise for him. He definitely captured the larger-than-life charisma of Philippe. You’ll see.
Goody Alsop is perfect. There is a little surprise with Susanna Norman - which isn’t a secret because author Deb Harkness herself has tweeted it a few times - she is played by the amazing Aisling Loftus, who is also reprising her role as Sophie. Yes, she’s playing two characters this season and it’s absolutely genius, because this way you can truly see the family resemblance.
I think the choice for Louisa de Clermont is very fitting, as were Walter Raleigh, Henry Percy, and William Cecil.
For Phoebe, I wanted to have no expectations and let Adelle surprise me, and she certainly did. I loved what she did with the character, especially because we see so little of her in Shadow of Night and even The Book of Life. She kind of keeps a marginal role until we truly get to know her in Time’s Convert, and I was so happy to see more of her in the show. Phoebe fans will adore episode 4.
Pierre and Françoise were great. So were Rudolph II and Edward Kelley.
And now, to my all-time favorites, Gallowglass and Kit. Absolute scene-stealers. A+++++++++ for casting and for acting. Tom Hughes does an incredible job in showing Kit’s duplicitous nature, his feelings for Matthew, and glimpses of his daemon madness.
Steven Cree is brilliant as Gallowglass. He is Gallowglass, exactly how I’d pictured him in the books. From his very first scene, you can tell his chemistry with Matthew is so genuine and really shows Gallowglass’s loyalty and love for his uncle.
Wow, I do hope I’m not forgetting anyone. If I am, know that it wasn’t intentional so don’t read anything into it. You’re welcome to send in more questions if you want, and I’ll answer what I can.
My (non-spoilery) review of season 2 is almost finished, I’ll publish that soon, so stay tuned!
I’m also dabbling with the idea of publishing another article after everyone has had the chance to watch the new season where I go all in and unpack everything. Definitely write me any questions/requests as you’re watching and I’ll be sure to analyze those scenes in the spoilery review!