The entire rose debacle can be summed up by a single image:
seen from China
seen from India

seen from India

seen from India
seen from Italy
seen from Russia
seen from Brazil
seen from Georgia

seen from France
seen from Japan
seen from Canada
seen from Denmark

seen from Malaysia
seen from Türkiye
seen from T1
seen from Germany
seen from Germany
seen from Canada
seen from South Korea
seen from United States
The entire rose debacle can be summed up by a single image:
Girl you’re literally making fun of someone who’s obviously mentally retarded. Have you even opened her fics? She has a disability or is a kid. Lay off.
Fine, I'll lay off! She claims to be in her 30s but I wouldn't be surprised if she was lying about her age.
Add homophobia to the list of Rose's prejudices. Of course gay men can be misogynistic like everyone else, but to generalise all gay men as being misogynists when it's not true at all? What a disgusting creature.
well ok I just asked mrose2000 for proof that you had sent them a death threat and they said they can’t remember because they have adhd and I was being ableist for asking for proof and sexist for not just taking them at their word and then they blocked me. So I asked someone else and apparently mrose2000 is a fandom-famous racist so that’s great
Tell rose that if I wanted to send her death threats, I would not hide behind a fake name for that. Rose, if you're reading this (which I know you are, given your stalking tendencies) know that I will find you and send you to hell where you belong! See? I don't need anonymity for this.
I didn't even know about the racism, but I suspected it from how rose seems to think only blonde and blue-eyed women can be beautiful and used Bella being dark-haired and dark-eyed to prove she's not supposed to be hot in the books despite her being described as a great beauty and not despite but in part because of her dark features.
Also, as someone with ADHD myself, that's the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard about it and that's saying a lot.
This rose person needs some serious help. She has been harassing the entire Bellamort fandom since August of 2024 despite being blocked and ignored by nearly everyone and is pathologically obsessed with Bellatrix. Even hp-confessions had to tell her to stop harassing people. I also remember her trying to demean Bellamort and Bellatrix on Reddit but her account got suspended 😂
Hi, I'm the anon who knows rose irl. She insults Bellatrix's looks because she's jealous. She's always been bullied for being fat. Her belly hangs down to her knees. She's really fat and short.
Oh God! I don't like body shaming anyone, even someone like Rose, but that does explain why she's so jealous of Bella and why she places so much value on male attention. The worst insults she can make up about Bella are Rodolphus and Voldemort not caring about her (which is objectively false according to the books themselves). It also explains why she insults her for being tall and slim and having a strong jaw, which is something only slim people can have.
It's really pathetic. I hope she gets therapy. She needs it badly. It would be far easier for her to just lose weight instead of spending her emotional energy on this.
I see you have been posting a lot of things about someone called Rose, who goes by MRose2 on AO3. His name is actually Max Roswell and he lives in Springfield, Connecticut. He is a dangerous online predator and haunts forums and websites, infiltrating forums in order to access minors to groom them.
Rose is an American man???
https://www.tumblr.com/mrose2000/772047052748242944/since-ive-seen-this-get-raised-again?source=share
Since this person always disables reblogs, I'm linking this post to tell her that appealing to the masses is a very common logical fallacy and does no favour to her 'arguments'. Also, the 'fandom' she's referring to interprets the series very differently from the author due to their headcanons and lack of understanding.
Case in point:
To answer her questions:
1. Argumentum ex silentio (she gave them a child and declared CC canon).
2. Cherry picking; begging the question.
3. Argumentum ad populum
4. Argumentum ex silentio (she gave them a child and declared CC canon)
5. Argumentum ad populum
6. Begging the question; ad hominem; appeal to motive
7. Begging the question; bulverism
This 'person' is the definition of invincible ignorance.
mrose2000 privately confessed to me that she’s online dating a 13 year old from japan