The Odyssey, The Iliad, & The Winchesters
A thinkpiece on the upcoming The Winchesters prequel show to Supernatural;
Let’s set the stage and learn who our main storytellers will be: Jensen and Robbie Thompson under Chaos Machine Productions (CMP).
When initial criticisms came out during the June 2021 leak, I wondered how many people voicing their opinions and concerns were newer Supernatural fans and/or wasn’t aware of Robbie’s impactful time of the show.
I know many fans had started during “Dabb Era” which comprised of seasons 12-15 where Andrew Dabb was the showrunner of Supernatural.
Robbie’s last episode was in season 11. He never got to write for “Dabb Era” and many fans who started in this time were not around during peak Robbie fandom.
His first episode was Slash Fiction, 7x06. It was an episode where we saw leviathan pretending to be Sam and Dean, trying to draw them out, and putting them on every wanted list in America. It’s also the episode where we meet Frank Devereaux, played by Kevin McNally.
Robbie’s final episode was Don’t Call me Shurley, 11x20, where we saw the return of Chuck and confirmed his identity was that of God. It’s where we get some Chuck and Metatron dialogue, setting up what will eventually become the final battle by the end of the show. Oh also, Robbie made God queer — so that was pretty sweet.
In between those episodes, Thompson penned several that became iconic in certain sectors of the fandom like LARP and the Real Girl, Goodbye Stranger, First Born, Fan Fiction, and Baby.
And that’s not even all of them. Gifsets, fan edits, fanfic, fanart, Twitter threads, and other Tumblr posts still get made to this day off of fan-favorite episodes he’s written.
Robbie is an exceptionally talented writer. Between the way he approaches a story, the way he approaches puzzles (figuring out canon, making a story around one idea, etc…), and how he develops characters or works with the existing canon of characters that aren’t his — he’s someone I would want working on a Supernatural spin-off story of this size. He’s also just… a big ol’ fan of the show.